How Memorial Day Was Stripped of Its African American Roots (Reply #2)

In the discussion thread: Black history that doesn't make it into the history books v2.0 [View all]

Thu May 31, 2012, 07:32 AM

Blue_Tires (55,412 posts)

2. How Memorial Day Was Stripped of Its African American Roots

File this one under "I learned something new today." It's the first I heard of African Americans having a role in the founding of memorial day.

"What we now know as Memorial Day began as 'Decoration Day' in the immediate aftermath of the U.S. Civil War. It was a tradition initiated by former slaves to celebrate emancipation and commemorate those who died for that cause.

These days, Memorial Day is arranged as a day 'without politics'--a general patriotic celebration of all soldiers and veterans, regardless of the nature of the wars in which they participated. This is the opposite of how the day emerged, with explicitly partisan motivations, to celebrate those who fought for justice and liberation. The concept that the population must 'remember the sacrifice' of U.S. service members, without a critical reflection on the wars themselves, did not emerge by accident. ..."

continued:
http://www.dominionofnewyork.com/2012/05/27/the-african-american-roots-of-memorial-day/#.T8QpYtX2ZLc

http://www.democraticunderground.com/1002738510

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

97 replies	Author	Time	Post
Black history that doesn't make it into the history books v2.0 [View all]	Number23	May 2012	OP
Mass incarceration	xrayvision2005	May 2012	#1
Amazing story of the partnerships between black escaped slaves and the native americans	Baobab	May 2016	#72
One set of events that was instrumental in the creation of an underclass was the biggest mistake	Baobab	May 2016	#73
We have to fix the 13th Amendment !!!!	Civic Justice	Mar 2018	#97
How Memorial Day Was Stripped of Its African American Roots	Blue_Tires	May 2012	#2
Wow!	Number23	Jun 2012	#3
That piece of history also mind blowing. I do know that in one of the old 'wards' in Houston,	freshwest	Jul 2015	#20
Destroying a people with by hiding their history. The truth should've been taught all along!	freshwest	Jul 2015	#19
My memory is getting bad -- too much stress	Blue_Tires	Jul 2015	#21
Supreme Court Rolls Back the Voting Rights Act	Number23	Jun 2013	#4
National Museum of African American History to Display Photos of the Gullah People	Number23	Mar 2014	#5
First learned about the Gullah People at the 2003 Florida Folk Festival	mia	Aug 2015	#23
The harlem Hellfighters/ Bronze Men	etherealtruth	Apr 2014	#6
Oh my God!! Amazing!	Number23	Apr 2014	#7
I listened to an incredible story about them on NPR ...	etherealtruth	Apr 2014	#8
One last kick	Number23	Jul 2015	#9
Black History in Canada is also not covered well at all, imo...	Spazito	Jul 2015	#10
An AMAZING contribution to this thread	Number23	Jul 2015	#11
I agree, black history is world history!	Spazito	Jul 2015	#12
Frederick Douglass speech July 5, 1852.	lovemydog	Jul 2015	#13
Another AMAZING contribution. Anything involving FD gets a huge okay from me.	Number23	Jul 2015	#15
That's a pretty awesome thread to find from the archives by Brewman_Jax, 23.. Mahalo!	Cha	Jul 2015	#14
M0rpheus, an exceptional DUer, PM'd me and suggested that I pin these two threads to the top	Number23	Jul 2015	#16
Oh, thanks for the history on that and what BrewmanJax is doing now, 23! Yeah, it's too bad about	Cha	Jul 2015	#17
Bookmarking valuable historical reading,	AuntPatsy	Jul 2015	#18
I discovered an amazing historical connection between a black Canadian doctor and Lincoln's...	Spazito	Aug 2015	#22
How the heck did I miss this???	Number23	Aug 2015	#24
It HAS been crazy here lately, hasn't it!	Spazito	Aug 2015	#25
This is probably the most awesome thing anyone has ever said about ANY group on DU	Number23	Aug 2015	#26
Thank you so much!	Spazito	Aug 2015	#28
A black doctor did the first open heart surgery.	xfundy	Aug 2015	#27
His name is Daniel Hale Williams ...	Spazito	Aug 2015	#29
Thanks, xfundy. I think this is one example where it actually DID make it into the history	Number23	Aug 2015	#30
My offering here	Chitown Kev	Aug 2015	#31
Holy crap what a find! I don't know how the heck I missed this until now	Number23	Sep 2015	#32
Photo of the presentation of the report:	Starry Messenger	Sep 2015	#33
The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks.	azurnoir	Sep 2015	#34
Wonderful. Thanks so much for this contribution	Number23	Sep 2015	#35
Dr. Beny Primm, Pioneer in AIDS Prevention, Dies at 87	MADem	Oct 2015	#36
This is wonderful and awesome	Number23	Oct 2015	#37
I'm glad that now I know it's here--more to come, eventually! nt	MADem	Oct 2015	#38
The Jim Crow Museum	Kind of Blue	Nov 2015	#39
Wow! This is an excellent contribution.	Number23	Nov 2015	#40
Thank You, Number23!!!	Kind of Blue	Nov 2015	#41
One of the things I love so much about this thread is its international flavor	Number23	Nov 2015	#42
It will be my honor and pleasure	Kind of Blue	Nov 2015	#43
African AMerican Intellectual History Society	tishaLA	Jan 2016	#44
Very nice. And you're right, the blog is absolute gold	Number23	Jan 2016	#45
The Birth of White Racism	hibbitus	Sep 2017	#96
The Story of Sembene!: How Ousmane Sembene Invented African Cinema	lovemydog	Jan 2016	#46
This is such a beautiful contribution to this thread. I love the international flavor here	Number23	Jan 2016	#47
yw n23	lovemydog	Jan 2016	#48
The OTHER trail of tears. Slave driving in the early 1800s	Takket	Jan 2016	#49
An amazing contribution to this thread	Number23	Jan 2016	#50
What happened to black Germans under the Nazis	BlueMTexpat	Jan 2016	#51
This is amazing. The list of Nazi victims is immense but this is the first time that I've seen peopl	Number23	Jan 2016	#52
Unfortunately, the US does not	BlueMTexpat	Jan 2016	#53
You are absolutely right. The US does not and never has cornered the market on racism	Number23	Jan 2016	#54
Extremely malodorous stench indeed!	BlueMTexpat	Jan 2016	#55
Message auto-removed	Name removed	Jan 2017	#94
When You Kill Ten Million Africans You Aren’t Called ‘Hitler’	Kind of Blue	Mar 2016	#56
Girl, THIS kind of thing right here is why every day that you don't post you are so sorely missed!!!	Number23	Mar 2016	#57
Aww, Number23, Thank You!	Kind of Blue	Mar 2016	#58
Thank you for this.	thucythucy	Jun 2016	#76
Thucythucy, you're welcome!	Kind of Blue	Jun 2016	#81
Per your request today ...	BlueMTexpat	Mar 2016	#59
Absolutely fabulous. Thanks so much!	Number23	Mar 2016	#60
This is a great thread.	BlueMTexpat	Mar 2016	#62
La Florida, St. Augustine, Little Africa, now Lincolnville, Florida	Kind of Blue	Mar 2016	#61
Freaking fabulous. How come stuff like this is hardly ever on the History Channel??	Number23	Mar 2016	#63
I know, right?	Kind of Blue	Mar 2016	#64
I love this thread too! It's the best one on DU. I am so glad that Brewman_Jaxx started it	Number23	Mar 2016	#65
Oh, now it sinks in why the v.20!	Kind of Blue	Mar 2016	#66
Whitewash	Kind of Blue	Apr 2016	#67
Jesse L. Brown	4Q2u2	Apr 2016	#68
K & R for an amazing thread	thucythucy	Apr 2016	#69
Never Forget: America’s Forgotten Mass Lynching: When 237 Black Sharecroppers Were Murdered In AR	MrScorpio	May 2016	#70
Mr. S, a great contribution. There are so many Rosewoods and similar in American history	Number23	May 2016	#71
Well...here was something I just learned about a couple of weeks ago.	Chitown Kev	Jun 2016	#74
Kev, what an amazing find! An incredible contribution to this thread	Number23	Jun 2016	#75
Young Fidel looks quite interesting as well	Chitown Kev	Jun 2016	#80
I have spent my whole evening on this thread.	DamnYankeeInHouston	Jun 2016	#77
I have to say, this thread and its creator -- Brewman Jaxx -- are the absolute best this web site	Number23	Jun 2016	#78
I'm a teacher, but only a student here.	DamnYankeeInHouston	Jun 2016	#79
Just so you know ...	1StrongBlackMan	Jun 2016	#82
Black folks with guns have ALWAYS put fear in certain people's hearts.	Number23	Jun 2016	#83
Yep ...	1StrongBlackMan	Jun 2016	#84
Not sure if this is known or not	Separation	Jun 2016	#85
Thanks for letting me know.	Number23	Jun 2016	#86
A Long-Lost Manuscript Contains a Searing Eyewitness Account of the Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921	sheshe2	Jun 2016	#87
That is incredibly difficult but incredibly IMPORTANT reading	Number23	Jun 2016	#88
Witchhunt in New York: The 1741 rebellion	JustAnotherGen	Sep 2016	#89
JAG a fantastic and incredibly interesting contribution	Number23	Sep 2016	#90
Wait until I post about Jim Guise	JustAnotherGen	Sep 2016	#91
"Inner Freedom Under Captivity"	Kind of Blue	Sep 2016	#92
Too bad that thread is no longer there	JonLP24	Dec 2016	#93
New York's Buried African-American History	HAB911	Feb 2017	#95

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.