In the discussion thread: How the NRA Rewrote the 2nd Amendment -- The Founders never intended to create unregulated guns [View all]
Response to friendly_iconoclast (Reply #56)
Thu Jun 6, 2019, 01:07 PM
discntnt_irny_srcsm (16,290 posts)
58. Pardon me for interjecting my rather focused discussion on Miller
https://www.democraticunderground.com/1172207514
Please take note of the following from the court:
1> Only weapons that have a reasonable relationship to the effectiveness of a well-regulated militia under the Second Amendment are free from government regulation. 2> In the absence of any evidence... I highlight #1 to report the court's opinion of what weapons should remain unregulated, in the words of the unanimous Supreme Court, from a case which many favoring everything from outright bans to limits, restrictions and permits often quote. Ask yourself, "What weapons are appropriate for the state militia?". Such weapons are the ones which "are free from government regulation". I highlight #2 to indicate that the court pointed to the lack of evidence presented as contributing to the decision. Miller was a known criminal. He had given evidence in court against other criminals. He was a known target for retribution. This is rather well proven by his murder which took place in April of 1939. Miller's appearance in court was prevented by his death. His counsel did not appear either. The only arguments and evidence were presented by the government prosecutor. |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
sharedvalues | May 2019 | OP | |
mainstreetonce | May 2019 | #1 | |
flamin lib | May 2019 | #2 | |
guillaumeb | May 2019 | #3 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #7 | |
guillaumeb | Jun 2019 | #16 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #17 | |
guillaumeb | Jun 2019 | #19 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #20 | |
guillaumeb | Jun 2019 | #21 | |
gejohnston | Jun 2019 | #22 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #23 | |
gladium et scutum | Jun 2019 | #29 | |
Snackshack | May 2019 | #4 | |
sharedvalues | May 2019 | #5 | |
friendly_iconoclast | May 2019 | #6 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #10 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #27 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #31 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #32 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #36 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #37 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #42 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #43 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #44 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #8 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #9 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #13 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #34 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #28 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #30 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #33 | |
Straw Man | Jun 2019 | #35 | |
MarvinGardens | Jun 2019 | #11 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #14 | |
MarvinGardens | Jun 2019 | #15 | |
jimmy the one | Jun 2019 | #46 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #48 | |
jimmy the one | Jun 2019 | #51 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #53 | |
MarvinGardens | Jun 2019 | #66 | |
jimmy the one | Jun 2019 | #76 | |
MarvinGardens | Jun 2019 | #77 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #78 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #79 | |
AtheistCrusader | Jun 2019 | #81 | |
sarisataka | Jun 2019 | #12 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #24 | |
sarisataka | Jun 2019 | #26 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #39 | |
gejohnston | Jun 2019 | #18 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #40 | |
gejohnston | Jun 2019 | #41 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #45 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #49 | |
hack89 | Jun 2019 | #55 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #56 | |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #58 |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #60 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #65 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #25 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #38 | |
jimmy the one | Jun 2019 | #47 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #50 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #59 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #61 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #63 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #80 | |
AtheistCrusader | Jun 2019 | #82 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #83 | |
AtheistCrusader | Jun 2019 | #86 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #85 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #87 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #88 | |
bigbrother05 | Jun 2019 | #52 | |
friendly_iconoclast | Jun 2019 | #54 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #84 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #64 | |
MarvinGardens | Jun 2019 | #67 | |
MythosMaster | Jun 2019 | #57 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #62 | |
yagotme | Jun 2019 | #68 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #69 | |
yagotme | Jun 2019 | #70 | |
sharedvalues | Jun 2019 | #71 | |
discntnt_irny_srcsm | Jun 2019 | #72 | |
yagotme | Jun 2019 | #73 | |
jmg257 | Jun 2019 | #74 | |
gejohnston | Jun 2019 | #75 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.