Israel/Palestine

Dick Dastardly

(937 posts)

33. If there are vidphone posts of everything then why dont the BDS supporters and event sponsors have

Wed Feb 13, 2013, 02:25 AM

Feb 2013

video supporting their contention about the students being disruptive.

As I said before a small microcassete or microchip recorder is very common in college to record lectures.

What is lame are all the excuses used to dismiss the recording in this thread.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

45 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Audio Reveals Brooklyn College Misled Public on Eviction of Jewish Students From BDS Event [View all] oberliner Feb 2013 OP

Looks like they will investigate, King_David Feb 2013 #1

None, of course ... holdencaufield Feb 2013 #2

Maybe the punishment could be delrem Feb 2013 #3

Such a big fuss was made of freedom of speech, King_David Feb 2013 #5

absolutely. and the speakers freely spoke. transcripts are freely available. delrem Feb 2013 #8

They ejected 4 Jewish students and would not allow them to ask questions at the meetings microphone, King_David Feb 2013 #10

'to utilize the open mike Q and A session ' HUH ? Is that a joke? King_David Feb 2013 #15

Really ? King_David Feb 2013 #17

Strange that they would have audio only when most of the world R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #4

Taking video would of been a distraction, King_David Feb 2013 #6

why recording was not only tolerated but captured with both audio and visual in Irvine azurnoir Feb 2013 #7

The Jewish students were forcibly expelled for having pamphlets on their laps, King_David Feb 2013 #13

andf the Arab students were not only forcibly removed but arrested tried azurnoir Feb 2013 #19

The expulsion must have been so forceful R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #24

As you like to say. Look over there, look over there. Dick Dastardly Feb 2013 #30

well it seems some are pointing lol azurnoir Feb 2013 #32

nobody was denied freedom of speech. the forum had a venue. delrem Feb 2013 #9

Really ? King_David Feb 2013 #11

There were many Jewish and anti-BDS students in the audience and at the mike. n/t delrem Feb 2013 #14

They thought they would get away with it, King_David Feb 2013 #16

Speculation on your part? R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #26

oh c'mon, either you can do better than that or delrem Feb 2013 #29

Yet there were other Jewish people there. R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #25

They were not denied freedom of speech. There was no right to freedom of speech. Dick Dastardly Feb 2013 #27

Except that the event was sponsored by the PolySci department of the school, aranthus Feb 2013 #35

I was not argueing whether it was right or wrong or its ethics. I just making the point that it Dick Dastardly Feb 2013 #36

Maybe you should watch e.g. _5 Broken Cameras_. delrem Feb 2013 #37

That movie was co-directed by an Israeli - and received Israeli funding oberliner Feb 2013 #38

Don't be asinine. delrem Feb 2013 #39

Please elaborate oberliner Feb 2013 #40

Judith Butler: delrem Feb 2013 #41

do you think Sodastream should be boycotted? Mosby Feb 2013 #43

Oh, come on. That is so lame. LOL! R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #20

If there are vidphone posts of everything then why dont the BDS supporters and event sponsors have Dick Dastardly Feb 2013 #33

The expelled students were the ones with the equiptment. Ask them. R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #34

"On edit: This is a great distraction from BDS." delrem Feb 2013 #12

Why Liberal Zionists Won't Join BDS King_David Feb 2013 #18

If that is what it is to be one, then so-called "Liberal Zionists" aren't up to scratch. delrem Feb 2013 #21

That is a great endorsement for the article, King_David Feb 2013 #22

My pleasure. delrem Feb 2013 #23

Its not strange at all. Recording lectures with a small microchip or microcassette voice recorder is Dick Dastardly Feb 2013 #28

You don't have to hold up anything. R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #31

The participants were not entitled to take video recordings... shaayecanaan Feb 2013 #42

One may hear papers, but as to if they were being passed R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #44

Amongst themselves, it seems... shaayecanaan Feb 2013 #45