HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Environment & Energy » Environment & Energy (Group) » World-first pilot plant t... » Reply #11

Response to TalkingDog (Original post)

Tue Aug 27, 2013, 07:01 AM

11. If it sounds too good to be true ...?


From their Q & A PDF:

> 4. How does the process work?
> Basic rock such as serpentinite is mined, crushed, heated and then mixed with water
> and pressurised with CO2 to speed up the natural carbonation reaction which in turn
> forms stable magnesium carbonate powder and sand.

All of those processes (mining, crushing, heating, mixing with water, CO2 pressurisation)
require additional energy input (some require a lot of it).

> 6. Will mineral carbonation mean more mining?
> In general, yes, more mining will be required to supply the minerals for carbonation.
> By doing this, the mining industry could in fact become a large part of the solution to
> our most pressing global environmental problem.

The salient phrase is "yes, more mining will be required".

> 7. How much mining is required for mineral carbonation?
> The mining scale will be smaller than the scale of mining for coal. In fact, to secure
> all the CO2 produced from coal, only half as much mineral silicate rock will be needed
> as the original amount of rock mined to extract the coal that produced the CO2.

So ... only half a mountain top at a time then?

All of the above are merely question marks and I truly hope that the result of this
pilot study is genuinely beneficial to the environment rather than just to the company.

"Orica is the largest provider of commercial explosives and blasting systems to the mining
and infrastructure markets, the global leader in the provision of ground support in mining
and tunnelling, and the leading supplier of sodium cyanide for gold extraction. "

Pardon my cynicism here but I feel that this plays into the increasingly frantic search
for a silver bullet that will allow Business As Usual ...

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 11 replies Author Time Post
TalkingDog Aug 2013 OP
BlueStreak Aug 2013 #1
Wilms Aug 2013 #7
napi21 Aug 2013 #2
PoliticAverse Aug 2013 #3
longship Aug 2013 #4
TalkingDog Aug 2013 #5
longship Aug 2013 #6
Ghost Dog Aug 2013 #10
napoleon_in_rags Aug 2013 #8
mopinko Aug 2013 #9
LineNew Reply If it sounds too good to be true ...?
Nihil Aug 2013 #11
Please login to view edit histories.