Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Economy
In reply to the discussion: Weekend Economists Ring in the Old, Wring Out the New: Dec. 30, 2011 to Jan. 2, 2012 [View all]Demeter
(85,373 posts)125. Law to Find Tax Evaders Denounced
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/12/27/business/law-to-find-tax-evaders-denounced.html?_r=1
Legislation meant to help the United States government locate overseas assets of American tax cheats created little stir when it was quietly slipped into a jobs bill last year. But the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, or Fatca, as it is known, is now causing alarm among businesses outside the United States that fear they will have to spend billions of dollars a year to meet the greatly increased reporting burdens, starting in 2013. American expatriates also say the new filing demands are daunting and overblown. Congress came in with a sledgehammer, said H. David Rosenbloom, a lawyer at Caplin and Drysdale in Washington and a former international tax policy adviser for the Treasury Department. The Fatca story is really kind of insane.
Congress created the act after the Justice Departments successful pursuit in 2009 of UBS that resulted in the Swiss bank which had encouraged American citizens to set up secret offshore accounts paying $780 million and turning over client details to avoid criminal prosecution. The law is meant to ensure Americans cannot use hidden trusts overseas to evade taxes, a goal that is widely applauded. But critics say that it amounts to gross legislative overreach, and that the $8 billion the Treasury expects to reap in taxes owed over 10 years pales next to the costs it will impose on foreign institutions. Those entities are being asked, in effect, to pay for the cost of tracking down American tax evaders. The law demands that virtually every financial firm outside the United States and any foreign company in which Americans are beneficial owners must register with the Internal Revenue Service, check existing accounts in search of Americans and annually declare their compliance.
Noncompliance would be punished with a withholding charge of up to 30 percent on any income and capital payments the company gets from the United States. Under the law, for example, if Deutsche Bank, having agreed to register with the United States authorities in compliance with the law, were to transfer $25 million to a noncompliant Polish bank, Deutsche Bank would be required to withhold part of that sum, transferring it to the I.R.S. The Polish recipient would then have the option of challenging that withholding by filing an American tax return, claiming the money, despite not being an American citizen. In practice, tax experts say costs like that might drive the Polish bank out of business. Theyre trying to force every financial institution in the world to sign onto this regime, said Denise Hintzke, who heads the global tax compliance initiative at Deloitte in New York.
Financial institutions outside the United States also say that the laws costs will be imposed overwhelmingly on them, giving a competitive advantage to United States rivals. The European Banking Association estimates that its members would have to pay at least $10 to vet each existing account plus overhaul data systems and procedures...The I.R.S., under pressure from angry and confused financial officials abroad, has extended the deadline for registration until June 30, 2013, and is struggling to provide more detailed guidance by the end of this year. But beginning in 2012, many American expatriates already the only developed-nation citizens subject to double taxation from their home government must furnish the I.R.S. with detailed personal information on their overseas assets. American Citizens Abroad, an advocacy group, estimates the new form will add three hours to tax preparation. Considering that the law provides harsh penalties for even unintentional errors, the organization says it is simply not realistic for a vast swath of the normally law-abiding filer community unable to afford the expensive services of a professional tax adviser. Even with the new requirement, American expatriates must continue reporting their foreign financial assets to the Treasury Department, meaning they will be reporting twice, to different arms of the government, according to different standards. The Fatca legislation treats all Americans with overseas bank accounts as criminals, even though most of them are honest, hard-working individuals who happen to be living and working or retired abroad, said Jacqueline Bugnion, a director of American Citizens Abroad.
Legislation meant to help the United States government locate overseas assets of American tax cheats created little stir when it was quietly slipped into a jobs bill last year. But the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act, or Fatca, as it is known, is now causing alarm among businesses outside the United States that fear they will have to spend billions of dollars a year to meet the greatly increased reporting burdens, starting in 2013. American expatriates also say the new filing demands are daunting and overblown. Congress came in with a sledgehammer, said H. David Rosenbloom, a lawyer at Caplin and Drysdale in Washington and a former international tax policy adviser for the Treasury Department. The Fatca story is really kind of insane.
Congress created the act after the Justice Departments successful pursuit in 2009 of UBS that resulted in the Swiss bank which had encouraged American citizens to set up secret offshore accounts paying $780 million and turning over client details to avoid criminal prosecution. The law is meant to ensure Americans cannot use hidden trusts overseas to evade taxes, a goal that is widely applauded. But critics say that it amounts to gross legislative overreach, and that the $8 billion the Treasury expects to reap in taxes owed over 10 years pales next to the costs it will impose on foreign institutions. Those entities are being asked, in effect, to pay for the cost of tracking down American tax evaders. The law demands that virtually every financial firm outside the United States and any foreign company in which Americans are beneficial owners must register with the Internal Revenue Service, check existing accounts in search of Americans and annually declare their compliance.
Noncompliance would be punished with a withholding charge of up to 30 percent on any income and capital payments the company gets from the United States. Under the law, for example, if Deutsche Bank, having agreed to register with the United States authorities in compliance with the law, were to transfer $25 million to a noncompliant Polish bank, Deutsche Bank would be required to withhold part of that sum, transferring it to the I.R.S. The Polish recipient would then have the option of challenging that withholding by filing an American tax return, claiming the money, despite not being an American citizen. In practice, tax experts say costs like that might drive the Polish bank out of business. Theyre trying to force every financial institution in the world to sign onto this regime, said Denise Hintzke, who heads the global tax compliance initiative at Deloitte in New York.
Financial institutions outside the United States also say that the laws costs will be imposed overwhelmingly on them, giving a competitive advantage to United States rivals. The European Banking Association estimates that its members would have to pay at least $10 to vet each existing account plus overhaul data systems and procedures...The I.R.S., under pressure from angry and confused financial officials abroad, has extended the deadline for registration until June 30, 2013, and is struggling to provide more detailed guidance by the end of this year. But beginning in 2012, many American expatriates already the only developed-nation citizens subject to double taxation from their home government must furnish the I.R.S. with detailed personal information on their overseas assets. American Citizens Abroad, an advocacy group, estimates the new form will add three hours to tax preparation. Considering that the law provides harsh penalties for even unintentional errors, the organization says it is simply not realistic for a vast swath of the normally law-abiding filer community unable to afford the expensive services of a professional tax adviser. Even with the new requirement, American expatriates must continue reporting their foreign financial assets to the Treasury Department, meaning they will be reporting twice, to different arms of the government, according to different standards. The Fatca legislation treats all Americans with overseas bank accounts as criminals, even though most of them are honest, hard-working individuals who happen to be living and working or retired abroad, said Jacqueline Bugnion, a director of American Citizens Abroad.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
150 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Weekend Economists Ring in the Old, Wring Out the New: Dec. 30, 2011 to Jan. 2, 2012 [View all]
Demeter
Dec 2011
OP
Put the the bazooka to the transitory unintended consequences from black swan events
Po_d Mainiac
Dec 2011
#10
Krugman is -- and has been -- ivory towered and out of touch for a long time n/t
Tansy_Gold
Dec 2011
#70
Leasing Through the Back Door: The Private Financing of “Public” Prisons By Christopher Petrella
Demeter
Dec 2011
#73
Cities that broke up Occupy camps now face lawsuits over free speech, use of force
Demeter
Jan 2012
#84
Populism Isn't Dead, It's Marching: What 19th Century Farmers Can Teach Occupiers About How to Keep
Demeter
Jan 2012
#116
"We’ve got to change it all, and we’ve got to do it before the ice caps melt"
bread_and_roses
Jan 2012
#132
Lies, Damn Lies And The Four Whoppers Of 2011 (Jonathan Alter is a Bloomberg View columnist)
Demeter
Jan 2012
#99
How Germany Builds Twice as Many Cars as the U.S. While Paying Its Workers Twice as Much
Demeter
Jan 2012
#100
Goodbye "Shop Til You Drop" Mentality: Renegade Band of Economists Call for "Degrowth" Economy
Demeter
Jan 2012
#101
I REPEAT: The original purpose of the Postal Service was to Deliver Democracy!
Demeter
Jan 2012
#108
"The Protester" Becomes Time's Person of the Year, Wants More by: J.A. Myerson, Truthout
Demeter
Jan 2012
#120
What if the SEC investigated Banks the way it is investigating Mutual Funds? By William K. Black
Demeter
Jan 2012
#126
Firefox has completely stopped working...again, and screwed up the machine doing it
Demeter
Jan 2012
#135
GENERAL, OFF-TOPIC QUERY: What has changed so much on DU that it feels like a foreign land?
Demeter
Jan 2012
#140
The Number One Catastrophic Event That Americans Worry About: Economic Collapse
Demeter
Jan 2012
#143
Michael Olenick: Is Shadow Housing Inventory Vastly Larger Than Widely Believed?
Demeter
Jan 2012
#146