HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Topics » Economy & Education » Economy (Group) » STOCK MARKET WATCH -- Tue... » Reply #87

Response to Demeter (Reply #66)

Tue May 22, 2012, 09:24 AM

87. Philip Pilkington: Why the Germans Probably Won’t Allow Greece to Exit the Euro

 

Last edited Tue May 22, 2012, 10:44 AM - Edit history (1)

I'D LIKE TO SEE THEM STOP GREECE, IF IT GETS UP THE NERVE...

http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/05/why-the-germans-probably-wont-allow-greece-to-exit-the-euro.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+NakedCapitalism+%28naked+capitalism%29

Well, there’s been a lot of talk recently about a potential Greek exit from the Eurozone. Some, like Marshall Auerback, have been calling this a lot of hot air and in seems that, in light of recent events taking place from deep within the bowels of the Eurozone banking system they may indeed be correct...Yesterday, Gavyn Davies over at the Financial Times blog ran an excellent piece on the silent bank run that has been taking place across Europe since the sovereign debt crisis began. It would seem that the bank run has sped up somewhat, as many will likely be dimly aware of from recent articles about bank deposits moving out of Greece. The extent to which it has accelerated, however, is quite interesting and can be seen in the following chart which tracks the Target2 interbank lending system in the Eurozone:



As the reader can see the flight out of the ‘dodgy banks’ in the periphery has increased quite a bit.

The reason for this, as Davies points out, is not the type of reason classically associated with a bank run. In a typical bank run depositors get nervous that the bank will not be able to fork over their cash should they want it...So, all the central bank has to do to counteract it is to step in and provide the liquidity. Then depositors will come to see that their money is guaranteed to be safe because the central bank — which prints money — is standing behind their bank ready to meet their desire for hard cash. The ECB, for whatever else it has done wrong, has performed this role perfectly throughout the recent crisis. However, the bank runs nevertheless continue. Why?

Because this is not, as Davies points out, a typical bank run. The reason that people are moving their deposits from peripheral banks to core banks is not because they are concerned about the peripheral banks’ ability to repay. Instead they are concerned that their government might exit the euro and reissue its own currency. In that case there is a good chance that if their deposits were sitting in a bank in their own country they would be converted into the new currency and, hence, automatically devalued vis-a-vis the euro (or neo-Deutschmark if the whole thing fell apart). If the depositor moves their money to a German bank, however, this shouldn’t be a problem — and given that there are no capital controls in Free Europa, moving your money is pretty easy. The real problem — for the Germans, that is — is that, as Davies points out, in preventing a bank run the ECB is loading up on some pretty serious risk:

“As deposits are withdrawn from Greek banks, the ECB replaces these deposits with liquidity operations. If these are standard repo operations, such as those undertaken in the LTROs in December and February, then the ECB is directly assuming risks which the Greek private deposit holder is no longer willing to hold. If the liquidity is injected via Emergency Lending Assistance, then the Bank of Greece is theoretically assuming the risk, rather than the ECB as a whole. But in the event of a euro break-up, these losses would ultimately fall on the ECB itself.”


See the dilemma here — at least from a German point-of-view? This silent bank run is seriously stacking risk upon risk onto the ECB balance sheet. Now, as long as the currency union stays together this isn’t really a problem. But if one of the links in the chain snaps, the ECB balance sheet takes a hit — a big hit. Now, since the ECB issues its own currency this is not really a problem from an operational point-of-view. Central banks, after all, can never really go bankrupt. However, the Germans hate the idea that the ECB might allow its balance sheet to take significant losses. So, what does all this mean? Well, it looks like the Greeks have just got a rather massive bargaining chip handed to them by the citizens of the periphery voting against the Germans by removing their deposits from peripheral banks. A classic case of subversive European democracy in action, it would seem!

AND THERE'S MORE AT THE LINK

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 153 replies Author Time Post
Tansy_Gold May 2012 OP
westerebus May 2012 #1
westerebus May 2012 #2
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #3
Demeter May 2012 #4
westerebus May 2012 #7
Demeter May 2012 #11
westerebus May 2012 #16
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #17
Fuddnik May 2012 #19
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #20
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #18
Demeter May 2012 #21
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #61
Fuddnik May 2012 #71
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #75
Demeter May 2012 #80
westerebus May 2012 #81
Demeter May 2012 #85
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #88
Demeter May 2012 #97
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #99
Fuddnik May 2012 #107
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #93
Ghost Dog May 2012 #106
kickysnana May 2012 #91
Demeter May 2012 #98
AnneD May 2012 #114
Demeter May 2012 #5
Demeter May 2012 #6
Demeter May 2012 #8
Demeter May 2012 #9
Demeter May 2012 #10
Demeter May 2012 #12
Demeter May 2012 #13
Demeter May 2012 #14
Demeter May 2012 #24
Demeter May 2012 #34
Demeter May 2012 #35
Demeter May 2012 #15
girl gone mad May 2012 #25
Demeter May 2012 #39
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #64
Demeter May 2012 #58
Demeter May 2012 #59
dixiegrrrrl May 2012 #150
bread_and_roses May 2012 #152
dixiegrrrrl May 2012 #153
Demeter May 2012 #22
Demeter May 2012 #23
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #144
Demeter May 2012 #145
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #146
Demeter May 2012 #147
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #149
Demeter May 2012 #26
Demeter May 2012 #27
xchrom May 2012 #28
DemReadingDU May 2012 #37
Demeter May 2012 #44
Fuddnik May 2012 #65
xchrom May 2012 #67
Fuddnik May 2012 #68
AnneD May 2012 #119
Fuddnik May 2012 #136
AnneD May 2012 #151
Demeter May 2012 #74
xchrom May 2012 #29
Demeter May 2012 #30
Demeter May 2012 #31
bread_and_roses May 2012 #72
Demeter May 2012 #86
DemReadingDU May 2012 #115
xchrom May 2012 #32
Demeter May 2012 #33
Demeter May 2012 #36
Demeter May 2012 #38
xchrom May 2012 #40
xchrom May 2012 #41
Demeter May 2012 #66
LineLineLineReply Philip Pilkington: Why the Germans Probably Won’t Allow Greece to Exit the Euro
Demeter May 2012 #87
Demeter May 2012 #100
Demeter May 2012 #102
AnneD May 2012 #124
Demeter May 2012 #42
xchrom May 2012 #43
Demeter May 2012 #57
xchrom May 2012 #62
Demeter May 2012 #45
Demeter May 2012 #46
Demeter May 2012 #47
Demeter May 2012 #48
xchrom May 2012 #49
Demeter May 2012 #52
xchrom May 2012 #53
Demeter May 2012 #63
xchrom May 2012 #78
Ghost Dog May 2012 #108
xchrom May 2012 #109
Demeter May 2012 #50
xchrom May 2012 #51
Ghost Dog May 2012 #111
Demeter May 2012 #54
Demeter May 2012 #56
just1voice May 2012 #130
Demeter May 2012 #132
Eugene May 2012 #148
Demeter May 2012 #55
Fuddnik May 2012 #69
bread_and_roses May 2012 #70
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #76
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #138
Demeter May 2012 #60
Ghost Dog May 2012 #112
Roland99 May 2012 #73
Roland99 May 2012 #82
Demeter May 2012 #77
Ghost Dog May 2012 #113
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #79
Roland99 May 2012 #83
Demeter May 2012 #84
xchrom May 2012 #89
Demeter May 2012 #103
xchrom May 2012 #90
xchrom May 2012 #92
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #94
xchrom May 2012 #95
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #96
Demeter May 2012 #104
Roland99 May 2012 #101
Demeter May 2012 #105
AnneD May 2012 #110
Ghost Dog May 2012 #116
AnneD May 2012 #122
Ghost Dog May 2012 #117
Demeter May 2012 #118
Demeter May 2012 #120
Demeter May 2012 #121
Demeter May 2012 #123
Demeter May 2012 #125
Demeter May 2012 #126
Demeter May 2012 #128
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #127
Eugene May 2012 #129
Tansy_Gold May 2012 #131
Demeter May 2012 #134
Roland99 May 2012 #133
Demeter May 2012 #135
Roland99 May 2012 #137
Fuddnik May 2012 #140
Po_d Mainiac May 2012 #141
Roland99 May 2012 #139
Demeter May 2012 #142
Roland99 May 2012 #143
Please login to view edit histories.