Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

still_one

(98,563 posts)
1. Are we talking about the flawed Brian Williams who lied about his faux Iraq helicopter crash?
Wed Apr 19, 2017, 12:27 PM
Apr 2017

Last edited Wed Apr 19, 2017, 01:03 PM - Edit history (1)

The NY Times review of the book left the impression that this book was just a feeble attempt to cash in on "why Hillary lost". From what I read in the review, I do not take this book as particularly eye opening. The review purports to use assessments from some people in her staff, and they seem to point the blame, at least how I read the review, because Hillary did not reach out enough.

Since I haven't read the book I admit I may be jumping to the wrong conclusion, but even from the title "Shattered", implying that no one in the press expected Hillary to lose, and it was a complete surprise, is bullshit.

The media's double standard, along with Comey, and the FBI's interference in the election seems to be relegated to a back seat in their analysis of why Hillary lost, and in my view that is a patently dishonest assessment.

Reading the reviews of this book over at Amazon, give it an average review, and the consensus over there seems to point to a rehash, nothing enlightening or new. Those that are clearly trump supporters believe it is bias toward Hillary, and those that seem to support Hillary or are Democrats tend to think the book presents a sympathetic look

Based on the reviews I have read, while it may not be its purpose, it provides cover for the shoddy reporting of the press.

I would be curious if anyone has read the book if it delves into how racism, sexism and bigotry was a factor, and how the news outlets legitimized it

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Are we talking about the flawed Brian Williams who lied about his faux Iraq helicopter crash? still_one Apr 2017 #1
exactly. JHan Apr 2017 #2
I doubt it covers the stuff you raised, there's a determined effort to ignore the ISMs. JHan Apr 2017 #5
As usual JHan you make some excellent points, especially about the republican primary. It still_one Apr 2017 #6
Conservatives and Media types like to ignore that bit of history.. JHan Apr 2017 #7
Flawed?? If by 'flawed' Brian Williams meant character assassination by media BlueCaliDem Apr 2017 #3
all of them can go fuck themselves.. they couldn't even report it properly. JHan Apr 2017 #4
Oh, believe you me, they 'reported' exactly as they were told to. U.S. Media are GOP lapdogs. BlueCaliDem Apr 2017 #18
Boom! sheshe2 Apr 2017 #11
Luv ya, too, sheshe! BlueCaliDem Apr 2017 #17
Bernie was flawed. ehrnst Apr 2017 #8
:) ;) JHan Apr 2017 #9
What Woah! sheshe2 Apr 2017 #12
Here is one reply to all of your posts on this thread ladym55 Apr 2017 #10
yep, I loved that piece. JHan Apr 2017 #14
I agree with your post but you left out the most important factor: the total corruption of the FBI. StevieM Apr 2017 #16
So well said. BainsBane Apr 2017 #13
It really aggravates me, it's so intellectually dishonest and blatant.. JHan Apr 2017 #15
Message auto-removed Name removed May 2017 #19
So, Trump was flawless? Sparkly May 2017 #20
Going by the logic of many pundits: JHan May 2017 #21
Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Hillary Clinton»Hillary Clinton, the "fla...»Reply #1