Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LongTomH

(8,636 posts)
110. The Curiosity rover's instruments are not designed for life detection..........
Wed Nov 21, 2012, 03:10 PM
Nov 2012

.....only to identify organic (carbon-based) compounds. Finding organic molecules would, however, validate the results from the Viking Labeled Release experiment. That was designed to detect living organisms and did come back with positive results. When the Viking Gas Chromatograph failed to find organic compounds in the soil, most researchers assumed the Labeled Release results were due to 'exotic soil chemistry.'

Gil Levin, who designed the Labeled Release experiment, has always believed that the Vikings found life on Mars. If the Curiosity science package finds evidence of organic molecules, it will prove Dr. Levin right after 36 years.

This ought to be a fun thread when people start waking up... Voice for Peace Nov 2012 #1
Precisely as the Mayans predicted Berlum Nov 2012 #2
Obama and NASA are going to destroy the world? Confusious Nov 2012 #7
Rats! You beat me to it!!!! emsimon33 Nov 2012 #112
transformers roguevalley Nov 2012 #119
+1 uponit7771 Nov 2012 #124
evidenvce of organic life leftyohiolib Nov 2012 #3
I bet it was a finger. Native Nov 2012 #20
It's an ear Puzzledtraveller Nov 2012 #34
...Or a toe slackmaster Nov 2012 #48
Where's Bunny? AAO Nov 2012 #83
Van Gogh's ear maybe.... n/t We are Devo Nov 2012 #63
Jimmy Hoffa melm00se Nov 2012 #50
Doctor Manhattan? Joe Bacon Nov 2012 #69
Lord Lucan Turborama Nov 2012 #71
I'll have to keep my ears open in the local coffee shops. Kablooie Nov 2012 #4
They found his reading glasses... trumad Nov 2012 #5
now THAT's a blast from the past.. Voice for Peace Nov 2012 #13
A trilobite fossil? tclambert Nov 2012 #6
I think the socks are in the 4th dimension, not mars. Confusious Nov 2012 #8
People there have been wondering where those socks keep coming from lunatica Nov 2012 #11
they use them as antenna warmers. Voice for Peace Nov 2012 #14
Per the Sarcastic Rover: FrodosPet Nov 2012 #9
LOLOLOL. nt Pale Blue Dot Nov 2012 #23
KHAAAAAANNNN!! yodermon Nov 2012 #54
I love sarcastic rover! We are Devo Nov 2012 #64
It is interesting that they are taking their good time to confirm it. aandegoons Nov 2012 #10
Not LBN dipsydoodle Nov 2012 #12
The forum police have arrived? theHandpuppet Nov 2012 #16
Statement of purpose for LBN is 12 hours : not 24. dipsydoodle Nov 2012 #18
Well you'll have to pardon me if I was ASLEEP at the time theHandpuppet Nov 2012 #22
"We'll handle this." - KC Berlum Nov 2012 #21
Mitt's tax returns? nt DippyDem Nov 2012 #15
They found Hoffa DainBramaged Nov 2012 #17
During half time at the Rose Bowl? Kolesar Nov 2012 #19
I bet they find a blue dress. nm ncteechur Nov 2012 #24
evidence reteachinwi Nov 2012 #25
did they find a dead Engineer from Prometheus ??? Setsuna1972 Nov 2012 #26
I already know about it Botany Nov 2012 #27
Beat me to it alcibiades_mystery Nov 2012 #87
If brilliant minds think alike, you and I are geniuses! closeupready Nov 2012 #108
At last they found... whistler162 Nov 2012 #28
Ohhh I know, I Know! NomadicView Nov 2012 #29
In my wildest dreams? NomadicView Nov 2012 #30
OMG! Life??? Odin2005 Nov 2012 #31
That's what I'm wondering! deutsey Nov 2012 #36
or even evidence that there was once life. That'd be huge for me. Victor_c3 Nov 2012 #46
May have to update the book of Genesis for the Holy Rollers. AAO Nov 2012 #84
The Curiosity rover's instruments are not designed for life detection.......... LongTomH Nov 2012 #110
Announcing an announcement? Is Donald Trump heading up NASA now? Ian_rd Nov 2012 #32
Or LeBron James JustABozoOnThisBus Nov 2012 #40
I hope they tell us before the world ends on Dec. 21st. jpak Nov 2012 #33
WMD's!! We had the wrong desert! Puzzledtraveller Nov 2012 #35
Okay, I'll play. It's that damned monolith from 2001: Space Odyssey Zen Democrat Nov 2012 #37
Proof of Transformers, cementing Michael Bay's reputation as a visionary Godhumor Nov 2012 #38
They found Rmoney's tax returns? 2pooped2pop Nov 2012 #39
Of course! Rosa Luxemburg Nov 2012 #127
that is exciting. barbtries Nov 2012 #41
SANDWORMS! Lochloosa Nov 2012 #42
That would be perfect. nt onehandle Nov 2012 #72
Sandworms! You hate 'em! I HATE 'EM!!! Ryano42 Nov 2012 #78
The worms ARE the spice. Dr. Strange Nov 2012 #79
I thought they may have something big coming when a lot of the info and updates went quiet harun Nov 2012 #43
Apparently they found methane Gman Nov 2012 #44
They did find methane meeshrox Nov 2012 #47
Actually their last press conference was about them not finding methane harun Nov 2012 #49
For those not in the know... Victor_c3 Nov 2012 #51
Thanks for that info! What emits methane...besides cows, us & other mammals? Peace Patriot Nov 2012 #56
Wiki on methane producers... Peace Patriot Nov 2012 #58
Maybe cockroaches Mz Pip Nov 2012 #81
it could be a leaky gas line Enrique Nov 2012 #62
I didn't know. THANK YOU. aquart Nov 2012 #60
me too, but it didn't stop the federal government from hiring me as one! Victor_c3 Nov 2012 #68
It found Jimmy Hoffa? slackmaster Nov 2012 #45
Methane in the atmosphere TomClash Nov 2012 #52
Oh My God- it's fullof stars! n/t James48 Nov 2012 #53
Leftover party favors that read... FailureToCommunicate Nov 2012 #55
the KFC secret ingredients. Tutonic Nov 2012 #57
Uh oh... progressoid Nov 2012 #59
Here is an image of what they found. Dr. Strange Nov 2012 #61
you maniacs! Enrique Nov 2012 #65
...after climate change and melts..... glinda Nov 2012 #82
It's a Wall Drug sign. Hassin Bin Sober Nov 2012 #66
Curiosity.... AlbertCat Nov 2012 #67
Mars Rover Discovery dexterborg Nov 2012 #70
Anything less than evidence of past organic life will be a disappointment. onehandle Nov 2012 #73
Or.. We are Devo Nov 2012 #74
re: Mars Rover 'Curiosity' Team Reportedly Will Reveal Major Discovery In December allan01 Nov 2012 #75
Could be the missing Iraq WMDs. Saddam was a crafty fellow. yellowcanine Nov 2012 #76
Does this change the Drake equation? TrogL Nov 2012 #77
They found oil! Liberaltalker Nov 2012 #80
Fundies heads are going to explode Livluvgrow Nov 2012 #85
They discovered the perfect soil for growning kick ass ganja! AAO Nov 2012 #86
Carbon. The building blocks of life. glinda Nov 2012 #88
Could be. sofa king Nov 2012 #92
I don't blame them, considering the idiot overseers to whom they have to answer theHandpuppet Nov 2012 #95
I dunno, announcing something like that would take the wind out of those idiots' sails. Posteritatis Nov 2012 #98
It won't be major to me Ter Nov 2012 #89
If they found fossils, God put those fossils on that red planet. randome Nov 2012 #93
Is it true there's water on Mars? area51 Nov 2012 #90
Absolutely Delphinus Nov 2012 #91
From a comment on Huffington Post. randome Nov 2012 #94
Why would the rover's chemistry team be the ones who'd announce something like that? Posteritatis Nov 2012 #96
Did not think of that. Oh, well... randome Nov 2012 #97
keep it secret.... Evasporque Nov 2012 #103
Hmmmm . . . 7.62 cm is too big colorado_ufo Nov 2012 #115
That episode of Southpark with the whale. It's all true. toddmiller Nov 2012 #129
Arghhhhhhhhhhh... I wanna know NOW!!!! Marrah_G Nov 2012 #99
Joking aside, any NASA folks here care to spill the beans? mainer Nov 2012 #100
Just remember this Duer 157099 Nov 2012 #101
Talk about ... humanistcafe Nov 2012 #102
Little green men and murielm99 Nov 2012 #104
We are the Martians ThoughtCriminal Nov 2012 #105
+1 glinda Nov 2012 #113
A lot of people are going to be disapointed Bradical79 Nov 2012 #106
The Mind Reels colsohlibgal Nov 2012 #107
My crazy side says some sort of fossil or even a micro-organism. closeupready Nov 2012 #109
December 21? The end of the Mayan calendar? The Mayans are up there???? emsimon33 Nov 2012 #111
When in December? KamaAina Nov 2012 #114
Sometime between Dec. 3-7 Posteritatis Nov 2012 #120
If they have to spend so much time studying it, it wouldn't be a big enough story. randome Nov 2012 #116
Uranium, Plutonium or Gold AlphaCentauri Nov 2012 #117
I know what it is--a stink bug. Damn things are EVERYWHERE. nt valerief Nov 2012 #118
Hate to say it but I don't think it will be that interesting SWTORFanatic Nov 2012 #121
Here's a photo of it. Wolf Frankula Nov 2012 #122
I hate threads that make us all seem brain-dead... hexola Nov 2012 #123
Quick, someone, complain about the price tag! Warren DeMontague Nov 2012 #125
Maybe they will report that they found bones! Rosa Luxemburg Nov 2012 #126
ten commandments? nt donco Nov 2012 #128
I think it's Jesus's crash pad .... Trajan Nov 2012 #130
A beer can and a couple of cigarette butts StarryNite Nov 2012 #131
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Mars Rover 'Curiosity' Te...»Reply #110