Your numbers are completely WRONG (Reply #9)

In the discussion thread: Romney’s deduction cap would touch sensitive tax breaks [View all]

Wed Oct 3, 2012, 01:13 PM

CreekDog (46,027 posts)

9. Your numbers are completely WRONG

500k mortgage at 4% interest rate is roughly $2400/month payment.

At 36% of monthly gross, income would be $7000/month or 84k per year.

The median housing price in San Francisco is 705k.

Anyway, I think it's pretty bad to post false numbers in order to falsely make people with 500k mortgages out to be wealthier than they often actually are.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

47 replies	Author	Time	Post
Romney’s deduction cap would touch sensitive tax breaks [View all]	Texas Lawyer	Oct 2012	OP
Keep on talking, Wrongney . . .	fleur-de-lisa	Oct 2012	#1
I hope Jim Lehrer holds Mitt's feet to the fire tonight and makes him explain himself	renate	Oct 2012	#2
The deduction cap may also negatively impact donations to the arts and charities	no_hypocrisy	Oct 2012	#3
but, but, but these agencies are supposed to do the work of helping the poor	central scrutinizer	Oct 2012	#7
The right has been at war...	awoke_in_2003	Oct 2012	#10
Change 'may' to 'will' and you have something	jmowreader	Oct 2012	#40
This is not a legitimate proposal ... it's a contrivance	bucolic_frolic	Oct 2012	#4
How about we just extend the Bush Tax cuts for the lower 95%	Cosmocat	Oct 2012	#18
That's not how it works	jmowreader	Oct 2012	#41
I am TRYING to help my somewhat sane republican friends	Cosmocat	Oct 2012	#44
Is it just itemized deductions? I'm not sure that what he said.	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#5
This is what he said:	muriel_volestrangler	Oct 2012	#14
It couldn't possibly be revenue neutral because	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#15
BINGO	Cosmocat	Oct 2012	#21
Right. It was never intended to be revenue neutral	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#25
You also forgot his corporate tax cut	jmowreader	Oct 2012	#42
There are more than two choices	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#45
We could and should do all these things...	jmowreader	Oct 2012	#46
The GNCGFH Act of 2013. I like it.	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#47
You need an annual income of roughly $150,000 to afford a $500,000 mortgage.	Lasher	Oct 2012	#6
$17,000 cap includes medical deductions, etc.	emulatorloo	Oct 2012	#8
Few People Get To Take Medical Deductions	DallasNE	Oct 2012	#13
Yup. For me the "etc." includes a couple of big deductible items: state income tax & property tax	progree	Oct 2012	#19
^Listen to Progree, he's smart...eom	Kolesar	Oct 2012	#22
Great post. N/t	emulatorloo	Oct 2012	#39
Your numbers are completely WRONG	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#9
Bay Area home buyers could still deduct most of their interest	Kolesar	Oct 2012	#16
look, if you are gung ho in defending the romney tax plan	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#26
That was stupid on your part	Kolesar	Oct 2012	#27
as proud as your are smug	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#31
I also find it laughable that you think someone can't get a mortgage more than 19% of gross income	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#11
Your ignorance doesn't make me wrong.	Lasher	Oct 2012	#32
I provided the numbers that show you are wrong	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#33
Ended up getting a cheaper place, did you?	Lasher	Oct 2012	#34
I didn't have a liar's loan, my income ratios were fine, my credit ratings well over 800...	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#35
OK let's take a closer look.	Lasher	Oct 2012	#36
you're saying my taxes should go up by 4000 so that the wealthy can have that money?	CreekDog	Oct 2012	#37
Looks like you're not laughing anymore.	Lasher	Oct 2012	#38
The Concept Makes No Sense	DallasNE	Oct 2012	#12
It is all WEALTH REDISTRIBUTION. Why should America be talking about this now?	BlueStreak	Oct 2012	#17
Isn't it crazy that Romney can beat up the President for "wealth redistribution" one day and then	Texas Lawyer	Oct 2012	#28
The deduction cap came out of Romney's dunce cap. Vapors. nt.	OldDem2012	Oct 2012	#20
The laws regarding capital gains taxes on the sale of a house already harm people in the	JDPriestly	Oct 2012	#23
This would target Romney's prime profit harvesting zone.	Turbineguy	Oct 2012	#24
Yes.	NutmegYankee	Oct 2012	#43
And don't forget Ryan's "Broaden the base"	OldHippieChick	Oct 2012	#29
We need to broaden the base to lighten the load on the overburdened millionaires and billionaires	Texas Lawyer	Oct 2012	#30

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.