Well, I would say this: As long as they are living a totally traditional lifestyle, with no Western (Reply #18)

In the discussion thread: New Trump public land rules will let Alaska hunters kill bear cubs in dens [View all]

Fri May 29, 2020, 12:18 PM

Coventina (25,304 posts)

18. Well, I would say this: As long as they are living a totally traditional lifestyle, with no Western

components, then OK.

If they are driving up to the dens in SUVs, then getting out ATVs, snow mobiles, etc. and shooting with guns, then I call bullshit.

Not all "traditional" practices are acceptable behavior.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

37 replies	Author	Time	Post
New Trump public land rules will let Alaska hunters kill bear cubs in dens [View all]	Judi Lynn	May 2020	OP
Anyone needing to kill a bear cub in its den is a very sick person. . . . nt	Bernardo de La Paz	May 2020	#1
For example, Donald Turd Jr.	lagomorph777	May 2020	#25
100% gas lighting .... Boy will this piss off the liberal tree huggers	Botany	May 2020	#2
This is how I interpret these laws too.	Mike 03	May 2020	#5
This Nazi rat fucker is behind a lot of the shit the orange one does.	Hotler	May 2020	#9
The Trump Doctrine is "kill everything."	Vinca	May 2020	#3
Publicize the shit out of this.	3Hotdogs	May 2020	#4
The mighty hunter.	keithbvadu2	May 2020	#6
Native Alaskans do this with bear cubs	Drahthaardogs	May 2020	#7
Never heard this before, do you have a link? I'd like to read up on it. n/t	Coventina	May 2020	#10
No link, just an Athabaskan neighbor	Drahthaardogs	May 2020	#14
Well, I would say this: As long as they are living a totally traditional lifestyle, with no Western	Coventina	May 2020	#18
You ever seen them whale hunt?	Drahthaardogs	May 2020	#19
I'm a vegetarian, FWIW. "Part of their culture" is not an acceptable excuse for cruelty.	Coventina	May 2020	#20
You just equated shooting a sleeping bear to raping a woman	Drahthaardogs	May 2020	#21
No, I was saying cruelty is not OK, no matter the victim, or the "excuse" given for it. n/t	Coventina	May 2020	#22
I'd like to see that too	Bayard	May 2020	#12
I don't get it?? Oh wait...regulation written by the Obama Administration. That clears that up	Bengus81	May 2020	#8
exactly, trump must sit in his office with a list	IcyPeas	May 2020	#23
support the right to arm bears....	dhill926	May 2020	#11
I really, truly, hate this man	Bayard	May 2020	#13
How sporting.	olddad65	May 2020	#15
Sick fucks.	BusyBeingBest	May 2020	#16
"David Vela""more closely align hunting and trapping regulations with those established by the state	turbinetree	May 2020	#17
This is why I rejoice with every headline noting a hunter mauled to death.	TheFourthMind	May 2020	#24
Do you feel that way about all hunters?	Dial H For Hero	May 2020	#26
You suggesting I shouldn't? n/t	TheFourthMind	May 2020	#28
Just seeking clarificatiion. I presume you feel the same, then, about these hunters:	Dial H For Hero	May 2020	#29
Which one of these individuals has been mauled to death while hunting or poaching? n/t	TheFourthMind	May 2020	#30
You said you had these feelings about all hunters. These men are hunters.	Dial H For Hero	May 2020	#31
No, you need to believe that's what I said in order to make your point. Which you failed to do	TheFourthMind	May 2020	#32
You ought to edit then your original post to show you support ethical hunters	Kaleva	May 2020	#33
Rejection of A does not imply rejection of B	LanternWaste	May 2020	#36
His later comments seem to suggest he supports ethical hunters like Pres. Carter.	Kaleva	Jun 2020	#37
When I asked if you felt this way about all hunters, you asked if I was suggesting you shouldn't.	Dial H For Hero	May 2020	#34
"the Tanana Chiefs Conference,...supports the rollbacks."	Kaleva	May 2020	#27
Another reason I have difficulty allowing respect to anyone who kills for entertainment.	LanternWaste	May 2020	#35

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.