Latest Breaking News

keithbvadu2

(40,915 posts)

3. "questioned whether he would get to heaven after killing himself"

Sat Dec 15, 2018, 01:00 AM

Dec 2018

"questioned"

Is the Catholic faith/religion so weak that it has no solid position on the issue?

Whether it is yay or nay, say it definitively.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

53 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Priest criticized teenager who killed himself at funeral [View all] Judi Lynn Dec 2018 OP

I was at a funeral for a friend's father. Gore1FL Dec 2018 #1

Missouri Synod. Says it all. We were taught in parochial school that Catholics were going ... marble falls Dec 2018 #10

I attended Lutheran parochial school too but Raine Dec 2018 #23

Missouri Synod are the Sunni of the Lutheran world. marble falls Dec 2018 #27

SAY WHAT???? The nuns told us it was the LUTHERANS who were going to the fiery place- they wouldnt Kashkakat v.2.0 Dec 2018 #25

They were lying to you. Be sure to pack your pockets Hershey bars, marshmallows and graham crackers, marble falls Dec 2018 #28

I was raised Lutheran but not LCMS Raine Dec 2018 #22

"They can't go to heaven because they're stuck in purgatory. You can free them by donating money" dalton99a Dec 2018 #2

"As soon as a coin in the coffer rings / the soul from purgatory springs." 47of74 Dec 2018 #7

They needed more money Cold War Spook Dec 2018 #32

"questioned whether he would get to heaven after killing himself" keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #3

Don't assume the news report is perfectly written. thesquanderer Dec 2018 #4

Possible... But the RCC has left in in limbo. keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #5

The existence of limbo is not a doctrine. Only speculation at best. olegramps Dec 2018 #13

That's Purgatory. I mean limbo as a vague, unspecified doctrine. keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #18

Catholic doctrine states that only God knows who goes to Heaven vs. Hell Drahthaardogs Dec 2018 #24

It's ok either way. keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #26

Huh? Drahthaardogs Dec 2018 #31

But not definitive enough for the Church to say/support in this case. keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #34

What are you talking about, definitive enough in this case? Drahthaardogs Dec 2018 #35

I see you are arguing just for the sake of arguing. keithbvadu2 Dec 2018 #37

Okay, whatever... Drahthaardogs Dec 2018 #38

Wasn't he just following his religion? flying rabbit Dec 2018 #6

My mother converted to Judaism rickyhall Dec 2018 #8

The neighbor kids across our backyard fence told us we were going to hell for being Protestants. milestogo Dec 2018 #11

There is no salvation outside the Church... Drahthaardogs Dec 2018 #36

I thought that was Sgent Dec 2018 #45

Their God is a vengeful psychopath. Is it really worthy of worship? Oneironaut Dec 2018 #9

I can't blame a non-existent god, I would have to blame the people defacto7 Dec 2018 #15

But isn't the Christian God okay with slavery, murder, genocide, and taking sex slaves as "trophies" Oneironaut Dec 2018 #16

In my understanding the god or belief systems are the people. defacto7 Dec 2018 #20

good friends kid did a murder suicide and they had a hard time getting a priest dembotoz Dec 2018 #12

A Christian friend at work many years ago 'informed' me that 'some Jews will go to Heaven.' JudyM Dec 2018 #14

Wow PennyK Dec 2018 #17

Some lack the self-insight and humility to recognize that spoon fed beliefs are not absolute truth. JudyM Dec 2018 #19

They're such brainwashed conformists. Duppers Dec 2018 #21

Brainwashed and blinded, yup. JudyM Dec 2018 #30

As a Buddhist, I am appalled, but not surprised, vlyons Dec 2018 #29

Since I don't believe that human beings can die, Biocentrism, Cold War Spook Dec 2018 #33

❓ We do die. Duppers Dec 2018 #40

Only our physical bodies die. Cold War Spook Dec 2018 #41

The double slit experiment does imply an observer is required to create a past Farmer-Rick Dec 2018 #53

I feel bad but am not at all surprised by this. Crash2Parties Dec 2018 #39

Honest question: Do Catholics these days believe that epilepsy is caused by demonic possession? Jedi Guy Dec 2018 #43

Not that I'm aware of. Crash2Parties Dec 2018 #49

Whew, okay. Jedi Guy Dec 2018 #50

Reading this headline, for me the question is, "Doesn't the AP proofread their headlines?". Totally Tunsie Dec 2018 #42

Agreed. Every time I see that headline I cringe. onenote Dec 2018 #47

That was how I read it as well. smirkymonkey Dec 2018 #48

You stay classy, Father Whoever-You-Are... Jedi Guy Dec 2018 #44

OT, but... how does one get that headline right? JackRiddler Dec 2018 #46

catholics who suicide die in a state of mortal sin rampartc Dec 2018 #51

Fanatics. akraven Dec 2018 #52