I'm up in the air about this one (Reply #5)

In the discussion thread: Mark David Chapman, John Lennon's Killer, Denied Parole For 7th Time In NY [View all]

Thu Aug 23, 2012, 12:31 PM

5. I'm up in the air about this one

If they're keeping him in jail only because the person he killed was John Lennon, then I think he should be let out.

If there are no other mitigating factors then he should be treated just like any other prisoner and I think John Lennon would say the same thing.

Also FWIW MDC was not a legal gun owner

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

36 replies	Author	Time	Post
Mark David Chapman, John Lennon's Killer, Denied Parole For 7th Time In NY [View all]	onehandle	Aug 2012	OP
Good. nt	msanthrope	Aug 2012	#1
RIP John Lennon n/t	xocet	Aug 2012	#2
Keep rotting, asshole. nt	Comrade_McKenzie	Aug 2012	#3
GOOD!!	ailsagirl	Aug 2012	#4
I'm up in the air about this one	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#5
Chapman murdered John Lennon "only because" he was John Lennon	rocktivity	Aug 2012	#7
Are you familiar with the term "Equal justice before the Law"? NT	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#8
Lennon deserves equal justice, too	rocktivity	Aug 2012	#12
Re: Lennon deserves equal justice, too	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#14
It's fairly easy to establish a clear and present danger with Chapman.	Ty Templeton	Aug 2012	#13
You must be full of nothing but air, actually	Scairp	Aug 2012	#19
Re: you don't have the slightest clue what Lennon would say.	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#24
Whatever	Scairp	Aug 2012	#34
how about he killed ANYONE in a cold calculating way & has only served 30 years	wordpix	Aug 2012	#21
If that's normal treatment for a murderer in NY state fine NT	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#25
TRANSLATION: "Have it on MY record that I let John Lennon's assassin go free?	rocktivity	Aug 2012	#6
You got it. Matters not whether Chapman has served a sentence commensurate with similar...	Scuba	Aug 2012	#10
Re: cultural icons	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#15
"Life isn't fair." - James Earl Carter	Scuba	Aug 2012	#16
How would you know?	Scairp	Aug 2012	#20
It sounds to me like you don't want justice, you want vengeance	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#26
He's in prison	Scairp	Aug 2012	#36
While traitors and war criminals walk free and "tell their stories" in the captive MSM like RUMSFELD	bobthedrummer	Aug 2012	#9
If the decision was motivated by public safety, inmate behavior, and an unbiased	petronius	Aug 2012	#11
Agreed	alcibiades_mystery	Aug 2012	#17
You "sincerely" doubt do you?	Scairp	Aug 2012	#22
Your rage isn't hurting anyone but you, you know that right? NT	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#27
Condescending comment.	Quantess	Aug 2012	#35
Well	alcibiades_mystery	Aug 2012	#31
What If One Of Your Kids Was Killed By Chapman?	HangOnKids	Aug 2012	#23
What if one of your kids WASN'T killed by Chapman and was on the street after 12 years	Trunk Monkey	Aug 2012	#28
Bye-Bye	HangOnKids	Aug 2012	#33
Probably not	alcibiades_mystery	Aug 2012	#30
oooh!... So close!	JohnnyRingo	Aug 2012	#18
I like the way you think.	2ndAmForComputers	Aug 2012	#32
Good. I imagine there would	Cha	Aug 2012	#29

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.