Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

mick063

(2,424 posts)
21. The French Revolution word game
Thu Jul 19, 2012, 03:00 AM
Jul 2012

This game converts a wiki entry to modern times to show how close we really are.



From Wiki: French Revolution: Financial Crisis.

Quote:
Louis XVI ascended to the throne amidst a financial crisis; the state was nearing bankruptcy and outlays outpaced income. This was because of France’s financial obligations stemming from involvement in the Seven Years War and its participation in the American Revolutionary War. In May 1776, finance minister Turgot was dismissed, after he failed to enact reforms. The next year, Jacques Necker, a foreigner, was appointed Comptroller-General of Finance. He could not be made an official minister because he was a Protestant.

Necker realized that the country's extremely regressive tax system subjected the lower classes to a heavy burden, while numerous exemptions existed for the nobility and clergy. He argued that the country could not be taxed higher; that tax exemptions for the nobility and clergy must be reduced; and proposed that borrowing more money would solve the country's fiscal shortages. Necker published a report to support this claim that underestimated the deficit by roughly 36 million livres, and proposed restricting the power of the parlements.

This was not received well by the King's ministers and Necker, hoping to bolster his position, argued to be made a minister. The King refused, Necker was fired, and Charles Alexandre de Calonne was appointed to the Comptrollership. Calonne initially spent liberally, but he quickly realized the critical financial situation and proposed a new tax code.

The proposal included a consistent land tax, which would include taxation of the nobility and clergy. Faced with opposition from the parlements, Calonne organised the summoning of the Assembly of Notables. But the Assembly failed to endorse Calonne's proposals and instead weakened his position through its criticism. In response, the King announced the calling of the Estates-General for May 1789, the first time the body had been summoned since 1614. This was a signal that the Bourbon monarchy was in a weakened state and subject to the demands of its people.

Now I will exchange a few terms.

Replace the following:

Louis XVI with Barack Obama
throne with presidency
France with US
Seven Years War with Iraq War
American Revolutionary War with Afghanistan War
May 1776 with November 2008
finance minister with Treasury Secretary
Turgot with Henry Paulson
Jacques Necker with Timothy Geithner
Comptroller-General of Finance with Treasury Secretary
a foreigner with a member of the Council on Foreign Relations
nobility and clergy with wealthy elite (1%)
country with middle class
36 million livres with 7 trillion dollars
restricting the power of the parlements with enacting finance reform


And it converts to:


Quote:
Barack Obama ascended to the presidency amidst a financial crisis; the state was nearing bankruptcy and outlays outpaced income. This was because of the US financial obligations stemming from involvement in the Iraq War and its participation in the Afghanistan War. In November 2008, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson was dismissed, after he failed to enact reforms. The next year, Timothy Geithner, a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, was appointed Treasury Secretary

Geithner realized that the country's extremely regressive tax system subjected the lower classes to a heavy burden, while numerous exemptions existed for the wealthy elite (1%). He argued that the middle class could not be taxed higher; that tax exemptions for the wealthy elite (1%) must be reduced; and proposed that borrowing more money would solve the country's fiscal shortages. Geithner published a report to support this claim that underestimated the deficit by roughly 7 trillion dollars, and proposed enacting finance reform.

So...... What happened in France four year later?

The "Reign of Terror"
More Precisely, Sir, The Nobles Refused To Pay Any Taxes The Magistrate Jul 2012 #1
There is that parallel. fascisthunter Jul 2012 #2
Infighting was funny. chollybocker Jul 2012 #3
Not true. Of course, it depends on what you consider the "start" of the coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #4
Actually Me. Jul 2012 #7
I'm probably betraying my age and when I went to school by saying that coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #10
Lefebvre is still a classic of that history RainDog Jul 2012 #18
I take a long view of revolutions. You know a lot more than I about the French Revolution, but CTyankee Jul 2012 #19
"We are the 99%" is an excellent meme RainDog Jul 2012 #22
And then, 'Off with their heads!' elleng Jul 2012 #34
Bon jour! CTyankee Jul 2012 #35
Ah, chocolate and hazelnut: NUTELLA!!! elleng Jul 2012 #36
didyou think I meant the singer? CTyankee Jul 2012 #37
Not for a moment! elleng Jul 2012 #38
Thar she is! CTyankee Jul 2012 #41
I confused first and second estates, thinking first was nobility and second clergy. Thanks coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #24
no strident criticism from me RainDog Jul 2012 #33
I'm sure there are postmortems on this but do you think "Anarchism" is to blame? flamingdem Jul 2012 #12
To blame for what? Occupy rigorously insisted upon non-violence, a coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #14
I think that would be tough to pull off here! flamingdem Jul 2012 #15
I raised the issue of 'Committee of Self Defense' as the final raid approached, coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #25
some anarchy/occupy links flamingdem Jul 2012 #26
Thank you for these links. Bookmarking for later reading. I'm not well versed in the coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #29
I haven't seen much Anarchist influence in my Occupy. white_wolf Jul 2012 #30
Yeah, that's my take on Occupy Los Angleles (pre-raid) too. A few self-identified coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #32
I know Les Miserables is not actually about the French Revolution SoutherDem Jul 2012 #5
A beautiful song, from a great musical; but the grim reality is..... LongTomH Jul 2012 #31
The War That Helped Bankrupt The Country Me. Jul 2012 #6
some rightwinger on twitter called Bastille Day 'French surrender Day' Viva_La_Revolution Jul 2012 #8
That truly deserves a coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #11
I kinda doubt what was said in that first sentence, TBH. AverageJoe90 Jul 2012 #9
Interestingly, the terms 'right' and 'left' as they apply to politics coalition_unwilling Jul 2012 #13
That much seems to be true. AverageJoe90 Jul 2012 #20
My understanding is that repeated attempts were made by the aristocracy to avoid the revolution Marr Jul 2012 #16
Business owners started the revolution against the aristocracy. Selatius Jul 2012 #17
The French Revolution word game mick063 Jul 2012 #21
^ A Wowza! post! ^ Mimosa Jul 2012 #40
Right, Canuckistanian. JDPriestly Jul 2012 #23
FLowers in the Night.... kooljerk666 Jul 2012 #27
I hope it isn't like the French revolution...it backfired Green_Lantern Jul 2012 #28
I've thought about the parallels Mimosa Jul 2012 #39
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Just heard something inte...»Reply #21