Correct. Top sniper, White Feather, could not duplicate the shot. (Reply #28)

In the discussion thread: Watching the television show '11.23.63' and I still have one nagging question about Oswald's gun. [View all]

Response to Wilms (Reply #5)

Sun May 1, 2016, 11:07 AM

yourpaljoey (2,166 posts)

28. Correct. Top sniper, White Feather, could not duplicate the shot.

"Retired Gunnery Sergeant Carlos Hathcock is likewise skeptical of Oswald's alleged shooting feat. Hathcock is a former senior instructor at the U. S. Marine Corps Sniper Instruction School at Quantico, Virginia. He has been described as the most famous American military sniper in history. In Vietnam he was credited with 93 confirmed kills. He now conducts police SWAT team sniper schools across the country. Craig Roberts asked Hathcock about the marksmanship feat attributed to Oswald by the Warren Commission. Hathcock answered that he did not believe Oswald could have done what the Commission said he did. Added Hathcock:

"Let me tell you what we did at Quantico. We reconstructed the whole thing: the angle, the range, the moving target, the time limit, the obstacles, everything. I don't know how many times we tried it, but we couldn't duplicate what the Warren Commission said Oswald did". (KILL ZONE, pp. 89-90)."

Cannot reply in locked threads

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

36 replies	Author	Time	Post
Watching the television show '11.23.63' and I still have one nagging question about Oswald's gun. [View all]	RandySF	May 2016	OP
He would have had to practice, but it's possible	jmowreader	May 2016	#1
Three shots in 17 (???) secs.	longship	May 2016	#2
I think it was three shots within a space of 6 seconds.	RandySF	May 2016	#4
No, I believe it was 17 secs from first to third.	longship	May 2016	#6
Warren Commission Report said 3 shots, 5.6 seconds, including the infamous "Magic Bullet,"	Chasstev365	May 2016	#8
Harvey would have trained with an M1 Garand which had no bolt...	Human101948	May 2016	#7
Well, he also practiced with the gun he used.	longship	May 2016	#10
Can you direct me to the forensice that were very clear?	Human101948	May 2016	#14
Check out Gerald Posner's book, Case Closed. nt	longship	May 2016	#17
Apparently his book isn't indisputable...	Human101948	May 2016	#23
Well, if Oswald didn't do it, who in Sam Hell did?	longship	May 2016	#25
British in World War One	1939	May 2016	#3
The SMLE family doesn't utilize a "straight pull" bolt as the Ross, Schmidt Rubin...	Marengo	May 2016	#19
And now for something completety different.	Wilms	May 2016	#5
Correct. Top sniper, White Feather, could not duplicate the shot.	yourpaljoey	May 2016	#28
I have talked with a former police officer who was a marine.	roamer65	May 2016	#35
There have been volumes written about the shots that day.	gordianot	May 2016	#9
The rifle was a Mannlicher-Carcano...	gregcrawford	May 2016	#11
In my opinion, some conspiracy theories are total bullshit.	Warren DeMontague	May 2016	#12
And what about his pistol?	rgbecker	May 2016	#13
So the local cops were involved in the conspiracy, too?	30Draw	May 2016	#15
there was no way in the world he made those shots.	KG	May 2016	#16
thank you, agreed	yourpaljoey	May 2016	#29
Here's an interesting take on it	Orrex	May 2016	#18
Witnesses heard the last two shots almost on top of each other. At least two rifles used.	Zen Democrat	May 2016	#20
pull trigger, work the bolt aim and pull the trigger again.	ileus	May 2016	#21
Bigger question	One of the 99	May 2016	#22
Incorrect assertion.	stopbush	May 2016	#31
It's 22!!!! 11.22.63!!! Jeez-o. And there are scores of books for your query. Get cracking.	WinkyDink	May 2016	#24
This message was self-deleted by its author	rjsquirrel	May 2016	#26
Have you ever read the Warren Commission Report?	stopbush	May 2016	#27
I wonder why this is posted when the later House Committee on Assassinations took issue with much of	Todays_Illusion	May 2016	#32
Had you read the HCA report, you would know that they CONFIRMED	stopbush	May 2016	#33
It's been duplicated several times in reenactments.	NutmegYankee	May 2016	#30
what station is that on?...eom	mrmpa	May 2016	#34
Locking	tammywammy	May 2016	#36

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.