Early, before collapse of the system and the fiscal panic, would have been good. The problem was that a marginally (D) controlled Congress refused to cooperate with the minority party and the president to pass a bill. Larger bill were proposed when the recession began, but they were all struck down. It was only when there was a (D) Congress with a (D) president that there was enough trust to pass a larger stimulus. The little stimulus was, at the time, considered a short-term stopgap measure whose effect would peter out in August or September.
When did the crisis strike? A month or so after the predicted end of the stimulative effect of the mini-stimulus.
The larger stimulus, oddly enough, most insist on calling the Obama stimulus but making it part of the Bush II budget. Claim the credit, dodge the blame.
Many also act like the Obama stimulus was the only stimulus and refer to it as "the" stimulus. It was the second. Obama didn't want a large first stimulus. At the time, he was promising a balanced budget in his first term, and panning Bush II for the size of the deficit. Once he was in charge of the budget, $400 billion, larger than the one he panned, was a manageable deficit for the indefinite future.
Congress Years Total Dems Reps Others Vacant Total Dems Reps Others Vacant
110th 20072009 100 49 49 2 435 233 198