HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » As a physicist, my two ce... » Reply #42

Response to redgreenandblue (Original post)

Thu Aug 6, 2015, 02:42 PM

42. Hypocrisy on the part of some Physicists.

My opinion has always been that if the bomb has been available 6-12 months sooner, or the war lasted 6-12 months longer, then Berlin would have been the first target. Those who now condemn the use of the bombs on Japan would not have said a thing about their use on Germany. Their attitude would have been that the dirty Fascists got what they deserved.

The Nazis were executing more people toward the end of the war in the concentration camps because they had perfected the mechanical means of the Holocaust. How many Jews, Poles, Gypsies, homosexuals and others might have been saved if the war in Europe had ended 6-12 months sooner?

Those scientists who worked on the bomb (many of the Jewish refugees from Hitler) did not seem to develop scruples until it was clear that Germany would no longer be the target. They knew for a fact that Berlin, and its civilians would certainly be the main target. They certainly didn’t have any concerns about German civilians being killed.

And for those who cry moral outrage I see no difference between the fire-bombing of Dresden, Tokyo and other Japanese cities and the atomic bombings. Dead is dead.

The Japanese were just as bad as the Nazis. But too many people weep tears for the “victims" of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, as if the Japanese did nothing to start the war in Asia. The Chinese suffered between 20-35 million casualties during the Japanese invasion of China (1937-1945). The Japanese forced Korean women into sexual slavery as “comfort women” in field brothels where the women were forced to sexually service, as many as 70 Japanese soldiers a day. In other words these women were raped 70 times a day for years on end. Everywhere the Japanese conquered, they acted like barbarians toward Allied POWS and civilians. The Japanese beat, starved, tortured and executed men and women. They used living human beings as living test subjects in their infamous biological warfare Unit 731.

People these days find it easy to take some moral high-ground when they are not involved in a war to the knife for the future of civilization. Hindsight is easy.

Finally, I personally think if Truman had not used the bomb out of moral scruples, and Operation Downfall had gone ahead, then America would have suffered terrible casualties. The truth about the bomb would have come out. And I think Truman would have been impeached.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 74 replies Author Time Post
redgreenandblue Aug 2015 OP
Journeyman Aug 2015 #1
KingCharlemagne Aug 2015 #73
Sherman A1 Aug 2015 #2
MannyGoldstein Aug 2015 #31
raccoon Aug 2015 #35
Whiskeytide Aug 2015 #44
MillennialDem Aug 2015 #50
Sunlei Aug 2015 #3
Flying Squirrel Aug 2015 #11
Sunlei Aug 2015 #22
Art_from_Ark Aug 2015 #65
JustABozoOnThisBus Aug 2015 #30
Maedhros Aug 2015 #59
pnwmom Aug 2015 #4
Ilsa Aug 2015 #6
redgreenandblue Aug 2015 #17
Recursion Aug 2015 #5
Martin Eden Aug 2015 #15
redgreenandblue Aug 2015 #16
CTyankee Aug 2015 #20
HFRN Aug 2015 #28
hunter Aug 2015 #32
Recursion Aug 2015 #34
Unknown Beatle Aug 2015 #7
Adrahil Aug 2015 #8
MillennialDem Aug 2015 #53
Adrahil Aug 2015 #57
pnwmom Aug 2015 #10
jeff47 Aug 2015 #24
hifiguy Aug 2015 #40
gratuitous Aug 2015 #37
Adrahil Aug 2015 #9
Android3.14 Aug 2015 #12
Live and Learn Aug 2015 #13
HFRN Aug 2015 #27
skepticscott Aug 2015 #14
The2ndWheel Aug 2015 #18
Hydra Aug 2015 #19
Shankapotomus Aug 2015 #21
Lee-Lee Aug 2015 #23
jeff47 Aug 2015 #25
HassleCat Aug 2015 #26
Warpy Aug 2015 #29
hunter Aug 2015 #33
Warpy Aug 2015 #48
Go Vols Aug 2015 #39
Warpy Aug 2015 #47
Go Vols Aug 2015 #49
Warpy Aug 2015 #56
Codeine Aug 2015 #36
cherokeeprogressive Aug 2015 #38
MicaelS Aug 2015 #41
cherokeeprogressive Aug 2015 #43
MicaelS Aug 2015 #46
hunter Aug 2015 #63
LineReply Hypocrisy on the part of some Physicists.
MicaelS Aug 2015 #42
Spider Jerusalem Aug 2015 #45
AllFieldsRequired Aug 2015 #51
Cleita Aug 2015 #52
Motown_Johnny Aug 2015 #54
still_one Aug 2015 #55
One of the 99 Aug 2015 #60
dogknob Aug 2015 #58
Rex Aug 2015 #61
MADem Aug 2015 #62
hifiguy Aug 2015 #64
quaker bill Aug 2015 #66
jimlup Aug 2015 #67
redgreenandblue Aug 2015 #70
jimlup Aug 2015 #74
Takket Aug 2015 #68
ThoughtCriminal Aug 2015 #69
davidpdx Aug 2015 #71
Marrah_G Aug 2015 #72
Please login to view edit histories.