In the discussion thread: In defense of the need to post blasphemous caricatures [View all]
Response to 99Forever (Reply #13)
Thu May 7, 2015, 08:55 PM
Yorktown (2,884 posts)
14. Well, de facto, you defend the censors.
Islam claims it can't be caricatured and must be respected.
I say, sod that. Punishment by different Islamic schools of jurisprudence[edit]
The Quran does not explicitly mention any worldly punishment for blasphemy (sabb allah or sabb al-rasul), as it does for apostasy (riddah). Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh) of Sunni and Shia madhabs have declared different punishments for the religious crime of blasphemy, and they vary between schools. These are as follows:[2][3][89] Hanafi – views blasphemy as synonymous with apostasy, and therefore, accepts the repentance of apostates. Those who refuse to repent, their punishment is death if the blasphemer is a Muslim man, and if the blasphemer is a woman, she must be imprisoned with coercion (beating) till she repents and returns to Islam.[90] If a non-Muslim commits blasphemy, his punishment must be a tazir (discretionary, can be death, arrest, caning, etc.).[6][91] Maliki – view blasphemy as an offense distinct from, and more severe than apostasy. Death is mandatory in cases of blasphemy for Muslim men, and repentance is not accepted. For women, death is not the punishment suggested, but she is arrested and punished till she repents and returns to Islam or dies in custody.[92][93] A non-Muslim who commits blasphemy against Islam must be punished; however, the blasphemer can escape punishment by converting and becoming a devout Muslim.[94] Hanbali – view blasphemy as an offense distinct from, and more severe than apostasy. Death is mandatory in cases of blasphemy, for both Muslim men and women, and repentance is not accepted.[95][96] Shafi’i – recognizes blasphemy as a separate offense from apostasy, but accepts the repentance of blasphemers. If the blasphemer does not repent, the punishment is death.[97][98] Ja'fari (Shia) – views blasphemy against Islam, the Prophet, or any of the Imams, to be punishable with death, if the blasphemer is a Muslim.[99] In case the blasphemer is a non-Muslim, he is given a chance to convert to Islam, or else killed.[100] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_blasphemy#Punishment_by_different_Islamic_schools_of_jurisprudence |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
Yorktown | May 2015 | OP | |
trumad | May 2015 | #1 | |
marym625 | May 2015 | #2 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #5 | |
marym625 | May 2015 | #28 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #32 | |
marym625 | May 2015 | #35 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #44 | |
daleanime | May 2015 | #43 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #46 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #75 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #30 | |
notadmblnd | May 2015 | #53 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #3 | |
babylonsister | May 2015 | #4 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #6 | |
babylonsister | May 2015 | #7 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #9 | |
99Forever | May 2015 | #8 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #10 | |
99Forever | May 2015 | #13 | |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #14 |
99Forever | May 2015 | #49 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #11 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #12 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #18 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #20 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #21 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #23 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #24 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #47 | |
kcr | May 2015 | #56 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #58 | |
LeftInTX | May 2015 | #15 | |
Fumesucker | May 2015 | #17 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #22 | |
Coventina | May 2015 | #60 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #63 | |
LeftInTX | May 2015 | #93 | |
Coventina | May 2015 | #94 | |
WinkyDink | May 2015 | #103 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #136 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #204 | |
Fumesucker | May 2015 | #16 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #19 | |
Fumesucker | May 2015 | #25 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #26 | |
840high | May 2015 | #27 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #33 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #34 | |
840high | May 2015 | #39 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #50 | |
840high | May 2015 | #54 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #65 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #40 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #51 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #57 | |
samsingh | May 2015 | #45 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #68 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #70 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #72 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #73 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #77 | |
CrawlingChaos | May 2015 | #82 | |
Yo_Mama | May 2015 | #229 | |
greyl | May 2015 | #67 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #76 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #79 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #201 | |
longship | May 2015 | #29 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #36 | |
longship | May 2015 | #48 | |
RandySF | May 2015 | #31 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #37 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #106 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #125 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #38 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #42 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #52 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #59 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #61 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #62 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #64 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #66 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #78 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #83 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #86 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #123 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #150 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #153 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #156 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #167 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #178 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #205 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #232 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #206 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #234 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #235 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #203 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #233 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #69 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #71 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #80 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #95 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #96 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #100 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #108 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #110 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #111 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #113 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #114 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #116 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #121 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #122 | |
Oktober | May 2015 | #124 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #129 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #172 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #177 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #179 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #181 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #182 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #208 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #157 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #164 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #166 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #81 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #97 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #98 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #101 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #102 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #105 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #141 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #158 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #159 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #161 | |
NanceGreggs | May 2015 | #162 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #169 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #163 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #168 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #210 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #212 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #213 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #214 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #217 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #215 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #218 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #220 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #221 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #223 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #225 | |
PeaceNikki | May 2015 | #226 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #227 | |
Yo_Mama | May 2015 | #230 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #207 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #202 | |
samsingh | May 2015 | #41 | |
obnoxiousdrunk | May 2015 | #55 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #74 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #85 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #87 | |
DisgustipatedinCA | May 2015 | #117 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #119 | |
DisgustipatedinCA | May 2015 | #120 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #185 | |
DisgustipatedinCA | May 2015 | #222 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #209 | |
NuclearDem | May 2015 | #88 | |
oberliner | May 2015 | #89 | |
NuclearDem | May 2015 | #90 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #91 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #127 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #146 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #152 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #160 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #165 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #171 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #175 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #180 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #184 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #188 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #189 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #191 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #193 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #194 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #195 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #196 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #197 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #198 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #128 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #143 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #145 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #148 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #154 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #155 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #170 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #173 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #190 | |
Violet_Crumble | May 2015 | #192 | |
Oneironaut | May 2015 | #84 | |
cbayer | May 2015 | #92 | |
Tommy_Carcetti | May 2015 | #99 | |
WinkyDink | May 2015 | #104 | |
guillaumeb | May 2015 | #107 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #133 | |
guillaumeb | May 2015 | #138 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #142 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #187 | |
Yo_Mama | May 2015 | #231 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #135 | |
guillaumeb | May 2015 | #149 | |
99Forever | May 2015 | #109 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #147 | |
99Forever | May 2015 | #199 | |
6000eliot | May 2015 | #112 | |
seveneyes | May 2015 | #118 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #130 | |
6000eliot | May 2015 | #151 | |
DisgustipatedinCA | May 2015 | #115 | |
beam me up scottie | May 2015 | #131 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #126 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #132 | |
okasha | May 2015 | #134 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #137 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #140 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #139 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #144 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #211 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #216 | |
treestar | May 2015 | #219 | |
Binkie The Clown | May 2015 | #224 | |
Marrah_G | May 2015 | #174 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #176 | |
Marrah_G | May 2015 | #183 | |
Yorktown | May 2015 | #186 | |
aka-chmeee | May 2015 | #200 | |
Yo_Mama | May 2015 | #228 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.