HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Right-Wing Zealots Are Al... » Reply #59

Response to NastyRiffraff (Reply #39)

Wed Mar 12, 2014, 01:25 PM

59. "So, basically, the Church condemned Galileo because he was a pain in the ass."

Actually, that is a perfectly legitimate statement.

Galileo told a longstanding friend of his, Pope Urban VIII, that he was going to write on the Ptolemaic system versus the Copernican system in his Dialogue on the Two World Systems. Urban, who was well aware that Galileo was an advocate of heliocentrism, asked (not ordered, asked) Galileo to treat the geocentric model with respect and not ridicule. When Galileo did not do this, Urban was displeased. Moreover, Galileo quoted Urban, and put Urban's words in the mouth of a man named Simplicius -- "simpleton" is a good translation. Naturally, Urban really did not appreciate being called an idiot in print. So he had Galileo called before the Papal Inquisition to explain himself. Remember that Henry VIII of England had people executed for less.)

Before I go on, let me say a few words about the Papal Inquisition. Don't confuse it with the Spanish Inquisition, a wholly separate organization. The name Inquisition comes from the Latin inquirere -- to look into, or to examine ("inquire" is from the same root). In the Papal Inquisition, defendants had such things as the right to counsel, the right to be told the specific charges against them and their property would not be seized by the Inquisition. Torture was permitted, but only when specifically authorized by the Pope or the head of the Inquisition (at that time, Cardinal Robert Bellarmine) and was to be used only once.

One thing that should be pointed out is that a major part of the Dialogue on the Two World Systems was concerned with a basically flawed theory about tides. Galileo believed that tides were caused by the sloshing back and forth of water in the seas as a point on the Earth's surface sped up and slowed down because of the Earth's rotation on its axis and revolution around the Sun. He advanced this theory because Cardinal Bellarmine called for evidence that the Earth circled the Sun, and Galileo thought this would suffice. Unfortunately for him, the theory is flat-out wrong, and could be shown to be wrong -- for one thing, it said that there should be only one high tide per day, not two. Galileo clearly knew of this problem, but essentially blew it off.

Another thing that should be pointed out is that the Vatican assigned two Jesuits, Christoph Scheiner and Orazio Grassi, to look into Galileo's science. Both had solid credentials as astronomers. However, Galileo had managed to alienate both of them. Schiener was one of the first astronomers to observe sunspots and was, as far as he knew, the first to describe them in a scientific paper. (In fact, the first paper on sunspots was published the previous year by David Fabricius, but his paper was unknown outside of Germany.) Galileo attempted to grab the glory of having first seen sunspots from Scheiner, and compounded this by plagiarizing Scheiner in his own paper.

Grassi and Galileo disagreed on the nature of comets. What made things worse was that Grassi was right and Galileo was wrong. Grassi had observed a comet over a period of time, and had noticed that the moon moved faster in the sky than the comet did; Grassi reasonably (and correctly) assumed that the comet was further from the earth than the moon was. Galileo believed that they were optical illusions in the atmosphere. After several rounds of argument in various pamphlets, Galileo wrote an essay, Il Saggiatore -- "The Assayer" -- attacking Grassi and his theory. This essay is still taught in Italian schools as a masterpiece of polemical writing. Naturally, having been held up to ridicule, Grassi was no friend to Galileo.

No, calling Galileo a pain in the arse is founded solidly on the facts.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 61 replies Author Time Post
HarveyDarkey Mar 2014 OP
shenmue Mar 2014 #1
Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Mar 2014 #7
JaneyVee Mar 2014 #47
Gothmog Mar 2014 #2
warrprayer Mar 2014 #3
roguevalley Mar 2014 #31
theHandpuppet Mar 2014 #49
lastlib Mar 2014 #55
opiate69 Mar 2014 #61
Ed Suspicious Mar 2014 #4
Rosco T. Mar 2014 #15
JHB Mar 2014 #5
AverageJoe90 Mar 2014 #6
demigoddess Mar 2014 #25
nadinbrzezinski Mar 2014 #34
2banon Mar 2014 #33
Califa Mar 2014 #37
NastyRiffraff Mar 2014 #39
LineLineLineLineLineNew Reply "So, basically, the Church condemned Galileo because he was a pain in the ass."
Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2014 #59
nadinbrzezinski Mar 2014 #8
dflprincess Mar 2014 #16
niyad Mar 2014 #19
muntrv Mar 2014 #9
Warren DeMontague Mar 2014 #10
Thor_MN Mar 2014 #21
colsohlibgal Mar 2014 #11
pangaia Mar 2014 #32
3catwoman3 Mar 2014 #35
Warren DeMontague Mar 2014 #12
GoneOffShore Mar 2014 #13
eShirl Mar 2014 #14
jtuck004 Mar 2014 #17
Pretorius Mar 2014 #18
Bigmack Mar 2014 #23
lindysalsagal Mar 2014 #20
hatrack Mar 2014 #22
Hoppy Mar 2014 #24
mysuzuki2 Mar 2014 #43
drm604 Mar 2014 #26
hatrack Mar 2014 #29
Sinti Mar 2014 #40
bvf Mar 2014 #57
spanone Mar 2014 #27
malletgirl02 Mar 2014 #28
Fortinbras Armstrong Mar 2014 #60
SammyWinstonJack Mar 2014 #30
Half-Century Man Mar 2014 #36
gregcrawford Mar 2014 #38
LanternWaste Mar 2014 #41
myrna minx Mar 2014 #42
Gothmog Mar 2014 #44
corkhead Mar 2014 #45
theHandpuppet Mar 2014 #46
tjwash Mar 2014 #48
winter is coming Mar 2014 #50
FiveGoodMen Mar 2014 #51
fascisthunter Mar 2014 #52
jmowreader Mar 2014 #53
MrScorpio Mar 2014 #54
padruig Mar 2014 #56
nykym Mar 2014 #58
Please login to view edit histories.