In the discussion thread: At some point, pacifism becomes part of the machinery of death. [View all]
Response to Sand Wind (Original post)
Fri Sep 13, 2013, 09:23 PM
LWolf (46,178 posts)
38. Neither war nor peace, but non-violent struggle:
From an essay by Gene Sharp discussing Gandhi's response to conflict.
Modern thought widely assumes that the peaceful alternatives to violence and war consist of negotiations, dialogue, diplomacy, negotiations, compromise, conciliation, and other tools of conflict resolution. Those are all good and useful tools in many situations and they need to be explored and developed further. However, that list does not include the full range of alternatives to violence. It does not give recognition to Gandhi’s views and experience in the development of satyagraha and the important wider historical practice of nonviolent struggle in social, economic, political, and international conflicts.
The article you posted does not even give recognition to those mentioned "peaceful alternatives." It assumes that "pacifist" = passive non-response. Gandhi’s important contributions about how to deal with conflicts do not fit smoothly into established modern thought and practice. The
assumption usually is that in serious conflicts one ultimately must choose between surrender, using violence, and refusal to participate on pacifist grounds. That's exactly what those supporting a violent response are saying. Gandhi’s answer was to identify those conflicts where the issues are fundamental. Those are the conflicts when moral principles, human rights,and justice are at stake and when compromise is not possible or desirable. Then the primary task of the exponent of nonviolent means is to assist the oppressed people to become empowered by learning how to apply satyagraha, or nonviolent struggle, to change their situation, as Gandhi insisted.
Most Western conflict resolution advocates, pacifists, and peace researchers have not yet fully grasped this great contribution to the resolution of acute conflicts. It's an interesting and relevant read. http://www.aeinstein.org/lectures_papers/INDIA_GANDHI_ANSWER.pdf |
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
![]() |
Author | Time | Post |
Sand Wind | Sep 2013 | OP | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #1 | |
Tien1985 | Sep 2013 | #6 | |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #29 | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #71 | |
Daniel537 | Sep 2013 | #100 | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #102 | |
LWolf | Sep 2013 | #32 | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #70 | |
LWolf | Sep 2013 | #90 | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #95 | |
AgingAmerican | Sep 2013 | #96 | |
HooptieWagon | Sep 2013 | #101 | |
AgingAmerican | Sep 2013 | #103 | |
treestar | Sep 2013 | #107 | |
mike_c | Sep 2013 | #2 | |
scarletwoman | Sep 2013 | #10 | |
Vashta Nerada | Sep 2013 | #44 | |
zeemike | Sep 2013 | #53 | |
mythology | Sep 2013 | #56 | |
grahamhgreen | Sep 2013 | #60 | |
quakerboy | Sep 2013 | #61 | |
Egalitarian Thug | Sep 2013 | #85 | |
Zorra | Sep 2013 | #91 | |
Daniel537 | Sep 2013 | #99 | |
morningfog | Sep 2013 | #3 | |
KG | Sep 2013 | #4 | |
polichick | Sep 2013 | #5 | |
bigtree | Sep 2013 | #7 | |
backscatter712 | Sep 2013 | #8 | |
quinnox | Sep 2013 | #12 | |
L0oniX | Sep 2013 | #27 | |
backscatter712 | Sep 2013 | #40 | |
Vashta Nerada | Sep 2013 | #46 | |
Warpy | Sep 2013 | #9 | |
libdem4life | Sep 2013 | #14 | |
L0oniX | Sep 2013 | #28 | |
Enrique | Sep 2013 | #11 | |
reformist2 | Sep 2013 | #13 | |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #30 | |
reformist2 | Sep 2013 | #33 | |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #39 | |
sulphurdunn | Sep 2013 | #58 | |
UTUSN | Sep 2013 | #15 | |
rug | Sep 2013 | #16 | |
Autumn | Sep 2013 | #17 | |
Hissyspit | Sep 2013 | #18 | |
L0oniX | Sep 2013 | #26 | |
Th1onein | Sep 2013 | #19 | |
backscatter712 | Sep 2013 | #20 | |
dairydog91 | Sep 2013 | #21 | |
baldguy | Sep 2013 | #22 | |
mick063 | Sep 2013 | #23 | |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #31 | |
mick063 | Sep 2013 | #34 | |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #37 | |
mick063 | Sep 2013 | #49 | |
L0oniX | Sep 2013 | #24 | |
DisgustipatedinCA | Sep 2013 | #25 | |
GReedDiamond | Sep 2013 | #35 | |
99Forever | Sep 2013 | #36 | |
![]() ![]() |
LWolf | Sep 2013 | #38 |
jeff47 | Sep 2013 | #41 | |
Sand Wind | Sep 2013 | #43 | |
LWolf | Sep 2013 | #47 | |
liberal_at_heart | Sep 2013 | #62 | |
SammyWinstonJack | Sep 2013 | #42 | |
Precisely | Sep 2013 | #45 | |
eridani | Sep 2013 | #48 | |
truedelphi | Sep 2013 | #80 | |
eridani | Sep 2013 | #81 | |
jessie04 | Sep 2013 | #50 | |
rynestonecowboy | Sep 2013 | #73 | |
jessie04 | Sep 2013 | #75 | |
liberal_at_heart | Sep 2013 | #51 | |
jessie04 | Sep 2013 | #52 | |
Blue_In_AK | Sep 2013 | #54 | |
Maedhros | Sep 2013 | #55 | |
jessie04 | Sep 2013 | #82 | |
grahamhgreen | Sep 2013 | #57 | |
raouldukelives | Sep 2013 | #89 | |
demosincebirth | Sep 2013 | #59 | |
Dragonfli | Sep 2013 | #63 | |
rug | Sep 2013 | #65 | |
Dragonfli | Sep 2013 | #69 | |
JEB | Sep 2013 | #66 | |
uberblonde | Sep 2013 | #64 | |
AtheistCrusader | Sep 2013 | #67 | |
niyad | Sep 2013 | #68 | |
Sand Wind | Sep 2013 | #72 | |
markpkessinger | Sep 2013 | #74 | |
Deep13 | Sep 2013 | #76 | |
LostOne4Ever | Sep 2013 | #77 | |
Warpy | Sep 2013 | #78 | |
Le Taz Hot | Sep 2013 | #79 | |
sendero | Sep 2013 | #83 | |
fishwax | Sep 2013 | #84 | |
SecularMotion | Sep 2013 | #86 | |
marmar | Sep 2013 | #87 | |
KG | Sep 2013 | #88 | |
niyad | Sep 2013 | #92 | |
Daniel537 | Sep 2013 | #97 | |
Faryn Balyncd | Sep 2013 | #93 | |
Safetykitten | Sep 2013 | #94 | |
malaise | Sep 2013 | #98 | |
notadmblnd | Sep 2013 | #104 | |
AgingAmerican | Sep 2013 | #105 | |
treestar | Sep 2013 | #106 | |
Douglas Carpenter | Sep 2013 | #108 | |
Tierra_y_Libertad | Sep 2013 | #109 | |
Vinnie From Indy | Sep 2013 | #110 | |
ocpagu | Sep 2013 | #111 |
Edit History
Please login to view edit histories.