He was actually pretty good. Robin Williams was ok. (Reply #5)

In the discussion thread: Who has seen The Butler? Just returned from a matinee [View all]

Sat Aug 17, 2013, 07:00 PM

mnhtnbb (29,594 posts)

5. He was actually pretty good. Robin Williams was ok.

John Cusack--whose work I usually admire--was miscast and it felt to me like he knew it
in every scene. Liv Schreiber was miscast, too, IMO. Neither one of them had the swagger,
the confidence, the arrogance of Nixon or LBJ.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

34 replies	Author	Time	Post
Who has seen The Butler? Just returned from a matinee [View all]	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	OP
Next week, we did Kick Ass (mindless flick)	nadinbrzezinski	Aug 2013	#1
I might have to see it again.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#3
I did that with lincoln	nadinbrzezinski	Aug 2013	#4
How did Alan Rickman do?	Baitball Blogger	Aug 2013	#2
He was actually pretty good. Robin Williams was ok.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#5
oooh, Alan Rickman is in it? I just love him.	liberal_at_heart	Aug 2013	#20
Four links below to the WaPo articles regarding the real WH butler Eugene Allen...	Tx4obama	Aug 2013	#6
Thanks for posting the links. I look forward to reading them	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#8
Try them again. I fixed the links - a space got in 'em by mistake.	Tx4obama	Aug 2013	#9
Yes! Thanks!	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#12
It was a rainy afternoon here and the theater was quite full.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#7
I saw it at the matinee today, too!	CTyankee	Aug 2013	#10
I'm looking forward to seeing The Butler	Hekate	Aug 2013	#11
I'm refusing to see it due to Oprah being in it.	Travis_0004	Aug 2013	#13
Oh, don't miss it because of an actor with whom you disagree.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#15
Why?	kwassa	Aug 2013	#22
"the uproar about Jane Fonda being cast as Nancy Reagan"	BumRushDaShow	Aug 2013	#14
Jane Fonda had a great look as Nancy Reagan in the movie.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#17
NANCY REAGAN approved of the casting of Jane Fonda, though--puts a crimp in their poutrage!	MADem	Aug 2013	#28
I saw it today and loved it.	avebury	Aug 2013	#16
I'm a huge fan of Lee Daniels so I can't wait to see it	Bluenorthwest	Aug 2013	#18
I plan to see it. Aunt told me about it	Triana	Aug 2013	#19
The film trashed Reagan	tavernier	Aug 2013	#21
I just read The Hollywood Reporter (gave it excellent reviews) and the cons are furious. I love it..	monmouth3	Aug 2013	#23
Lee Daniels confirms in an interview in the NY Times magazine today	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#24
Overwrought and hits you over the head with a hammer.	zappaman	Aug 2013	#25
I suspect it will be longer than 4 months to cable...#1 at box office this weekend.	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#26
My family went the other day--raved for two days straight! nt	MADem	Aug 2013	#27
I saw it yesterday	HeiressofBickworth	Aug 2013	#29
jane fonda comes full circle	BOG PERSON	Aug 2013	#30
Great comment. It is not well known that Ronnie was snitching on 'commie'	mnhtnbb	Aug 2013	#31
From one of the links:	Gormy Cuss	Aug 2013	#32
Went to see the Butler with 9 friends but for me personally	FloridaBlues	Aug 2013	#33
Robin Williams as Ike? I'd have to see it for that, if nothing else	IDemo	Aug 2013	#34

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.