Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

nickinSTL

(4,833 posts)
66. Yeah, uh...this doesn't really make sense to me
Thu Feb 14, 2013, 11:40 PM
Feb 2013

First, what's the source? I don't know this site, and I'm not seeing anything in the story saying where the info comes from.

Second, while I think Ratzinger's shielded priests who've abused children, I don't see HIM being a likely target. The bishops & priests are a lot more likely.

Third, the pope is a head of state, and as such, immune to prosecution. If it was true, he'd be personally much safer remaining pope.

Along with that, everything I've read suggests that when he leaves, he'll be first heading to Castel Gandolfo in Italy - while that might explain a request to the Italian President for immunity, why would he leave the Vatican? I'm sure there are apartments he could stay in temporarily if there were a chance of him being arrested outside the country.

Fourth, there is no reason, imo, to believe that his resignation is for any reason other than age & ill health. Despite what some seem to believe, Ratzinger has for years said that he believed that a pope had both a right and in fact a duty to resign if he could no longer continue to fulfill his mission. From what I've read, it seems that his health has really taken a downturn recently & I think he believes he's come to that point.

As much as I dislike him & wouldn't shed a tear if he were indicted & imprisoned, I think this is all a bunch of BS and everyone's in a hurry to believe it because he is so disliked & they desperately WANT there to be more to it than a sick old man retiring.

Holy crap. Arugula Latte Feb 2013 #1
Finally, this is making sense rocktivity Feb 2013 #2
Should these claims come to fruition, Segami Feb 2013 #4
Who knows? they may even be willing to spill some beans in exchange for leniency. arcane1 Feb 2013 #36
Yup! n/t Agschmid Feb 2013 #62
Thanks for posting this....much appreciated. nt. OldDem2012 Feb 2013 #3
K&R n/t OneGrassRoot Feb 2013 #5
This guy is basically the anti-christ. JaneyVee Feb 2013 #6
Haha! The popes are a succession of anti-christs! Jesus would prob puke to know what they do! hue Feb 2013 #132
I thought Vatican City was a sovereign state. Sheldon Cooper Feb 2013 #7
Can the Pope Be Arrested in Connection with the Sexual Abuse Scandal? Segami Feb 2013 #9
He would no longer be considered a head of state, so that Sheldon Cooper Feb 2013 #13
But then why resign theKed Feb 2013 #29
Can you say, "UNDER PRESSURE"?! (Remember John Paul I?) WinkyDink Feb 2013 #75
But by whom? theKed Feb 2013 #82
There was a lot of speculation Aerows Feb 2013 #94
That's my guess. Since, in the tradition of the papacy, the pope is the closest human being to God loudsue Feb 2013 #102
This all well might play out as high Catholic drama. n/t RKP5637 Feb 2013 #30
My first thought, too. n/t tuvor Feb 2013 #11
This an important detail Bigbluebrush Feb 2013 #34
it is BainsBane Feb 2013 #43
We could just fly a drone up his ass. It's perfectly legal they say. R. Daneel Olivaw Feb 2013 #78
I don't know the answer to that but your comment may snagglepuss Feb 2013 #114
That's why he's cloistering himself at the Vatican for the rest of his life, I guess. hedda_foil Feb 2013 #125
What a bunch of BS. The ICC complaint is wholly frivolous. tritsofme Feb 2013 #8
Now wait a second Aerows Feb 2013 #79
The title of the OP has immunity in all caps. tritsofme Feb 2013 #86
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!! Zoeisright Feb 2013 #96
You actually think the pope resigned because he was desperately seeking immunity? tritsofme Feb 2013 #97
You may not agree with the speculation, but to call it CT garbage rhett o rick Feb 2013 #117
Good Politicalboi Feb 2013 #10
I sincerely hope this is the beginning of the end of the entire church. Walk away Feb 2013 #121
May Justice Be Served Whisp Feb 2013 #12
I will dance with you. nt DollarBillHines Feb 2013 #15
Here's a crazy idea: Stop fucking kids! NightWatcher Feb 2013 #14
Religion and Faith should never be mixed together. Segami Feb 2013 #16
Neither should religion and sex.... Spitfire of ATJ Feb 2013 #53
As a kid religion was no big deal to me, but I never believed a bit of it, nor did I believe RKP5637 Feb 2013 #35
Right on. I'd add to that excellent suggestion for the Church snagglepuss Feb 2013 #113
Alleged by whom? 'Addicting Info' doesn't give any source muriel_volestrangler Feb 2013 #17
That's not important. Now, it's ONLY about shaming the Church one way or the other. cherokeeprogressive Feb 2013 #33
You're right. Maybe it's true, maybe it's not. pnwmom Feb 2013 #59
Well Aerows Feb 2013 #80
I understand where you're coming from, I do. It gets to the point though where cherokeeprogressive Feb 2013 #87
I'm not blaming Church members Aerows Feb 2013 #93
Alleged by the Internatinal Tribunal into Crimes of Church and State LiberalAndProud Feb 2013 #74
Yeah, I read that Aerows Feb 2013 #95
Yes, I followed the trail defacto7 Feb 2013 #98
need a more credible mainstream source for this story to have legs srican69 Feb 2013 #18
I agree but this event's (Pope's resignation) facts is still in its infancy. Segami Feb 2013 #20
I knew it! ananda Feb 2013 #19
Frankly... ReRe Feb 2013 #73
This is tragic for people in a faith community. MissMarple Feb 2013 #21
Occam's razor: The pope is old. He's quitting because he can't stay awake. jsr Feb 2013 #22
People need their layers of hidden truths or something, I suppose. (nt) Posteritatis Feb 2013 #24
Do you honestly believe the Pope resigned because Segami Feb 2013 #25
As much as I want to see church officials in jail jsr Feb 2013 #26
No, he's been thinking about it for at least DonViejo Feb 2013 #84
Perfect storm I think is accurate. glinda Feb 2013 #118
I just re-read... DonViejo Feb 2013 #119
Wish I could find the Catholic online magazine newsletter where glinda Feb 2013 #122
Popes die in office. "Old" doesn't cut it. And "Too Old For Lent"? VERY odd. WinkyDink Feb 2013 #76
Yes, because just after he became Pope defacto7 Feb 2013 #99
Occam's Razor is not foolproof Taverner Feb 2013 #111
B-b-but he's old and ill! He bumped his head and walks a little slow! backscatter712 Feb 2013 #23
Hmmmmmm! rdharma Feb 2013 #27
For a long time I wonder if the pope is guilty of liking little children alittle to much. southernyankeebelle Feb 2013 #28
I wonder, have there been any allegations about that ... and he seems to purposely always be after RKP5637 Feb 2013 #37
I'll be honest Aerows Feb 2013 #83
Something is up. A pope just doesn't resign like that. Maybe someone has something southernyankeebelle Feb 2013 #106
Who else would cover for a pedophile... CoffeeCat Feb 2013 #88
And some of them Aerows Feb 2013 #90
It makes you sick to think about people like this have ruined organized church. southernyankeebelle Feb 2013 #105
Everybody at Penn State? KamaAina Feb 2013 #112
Even if there is sarisataka Feb 2013 #31
They are remodeling a building in the Vatican and he will live there Autumn Feb 2013 #38
I would think they would do that no matter what ... it would really be weird to have the pope RKP5637 Feb 2013 #39
I'm just wondering, what the hell does a retired Pope do? Autumn Feb 2013 #41
Good question ... he sure can't pal around with the other popes, like call them up for a game of RKP5637 Feb 2013 #46
Since it has been so long since a Pope retired sarisataka Feb 2013 #65
If this were La Repubblica or a similarly prominent Italian geek tragedy Feb 2013 #32
How reliable is this source? hrmjustin Feb 2013 #40
I was tempted to post something about this earlier today. LiberalAndProud Feb 2013 #42
I just googled it and saw some Italian links to it. hrmjustin Feb 2013 #45
Help me out. LiberalAndProud Feb 2013 #50
I just doubled checked and it appears I was mistaken. hrmjustin Feb 2013 #55
No worries. LiberalAndProud Feb 2013 #69
It seems like wishful thinking. hrmjustin Feb 2013 #70
Finally the other shoe drops.. Bennyboy Feb 2013 #44
Nothing is going to happen. He does not need... Lady Freedom Returns Feb 2013 #54
Oh I know nothing will happen Bennyboy Feb 2013 #60
But that is why they are making a residence in the Vatican Lady Freedom Returns Feb 2013 #64
PR nightmare for the Vatican. Segami Feb 2013 #67
I do believe so. Lady Freedom Returns Feb 2013 #68
The answer is no. defacto7 Feb 2013 #100
Vatican city is a country Drahthaardogs Feb 2013 #47
+1 Lady Freedom Returns Feb 2013 #51
Message auto-removed I am Ian Feb 2013 #48
Coming from this group, I don't believe it. This is the news of the millennium if true. Hosnon Feb 2013 #49
I would love to see this man trade papal vestments DonCoquixote Feb 2013 #52
Don't get your hopes up. This story leaves out some facts. Lady Freedom Returns Feb 2013 #61
It's not illegal when the Pope does it? n/t eggplant Feb 2013 #56
I would be very happy if this proves true. That said, I do not believe it at all. Stinky The Clown Feb 2013 #57
I knew something was up! southern_belle Feb 2013 #58
And people wonder how this could happen.... Spitfire of ATJ Feb 2013 #63
Yeah, uh...this doesn't really make sense to me nickinSTL Feb 2013 #66
Roger Mahoney got away with so much Iwillnevergiveup Feb 2013 #71
Just because Mahoney is gone doesn't mean we've heard the last of him. Initech Feb 2013 #115
This message was self-deleted by its author ohheckyeah Feb 2013 #72
All the people here who suspected this, raise your hands! Fawke Em Feb 2013 #77
The term "Allegedly" should be highlighted in the title to the same degree Adsos Letter Feb 2013 #81
Would all of the OJ Simpson and Michael Jackson deniers please stand up. lindysalsagal Feb 2013 #85
Yes, children were raped. LiberalAndProud Feb 2013 #89
That I wouldn't know about. lindysalsagal Feb 2013 #91
I haven't seen anyone denying the child abuse and sexual crimes Adsos Letter Feb 2013 #92
Louis CK learns about the Catholic Church Go Vols Feb 2013 #101
While I dislike the RCC hierarchy as much as anyone, this story sounds like a bunch of crap. progressoid Feb 2013 #103
Holy Mackerel! burrowowl Feb 2013 #104
Guess he's not infallible after all. Skidmore Feb 2013 #107
The "infallibility" of the pope, as a doctrine, is often misunderstood. whathehell Feb 2013 #116
And by whose authority is he not misleading or speaking in error? Skidmore Feb 2013 #128
According to church doctrine, he is guided by whathehell Feb 2013 #133
kick'd and rec'd lunatica Feb 2013 #108
Why am I not surprised malaise Feb 2013 #109
I'm confused. The Vatican is a sovereign state KurtNYC Feb 2013 #110
He's ok within their precincts dipsydoodle Feb 2013 #129
This message was self-deleted by its author dipsydoodle Feb 2013 #130
The only news articles I can find corroborating this all link back to this article Matariki Feb 2013 #120
Jesus wept. AzDar Feb 2013 #123
Wait...hate to pop reality nadinbrzezinski Feb 2013 #124
I agree something does not seem right here. hrmjustin Feb 2013 #126
Bring him to trial. obxhead Feb 2013 #127
Not a whole lot different , assuming it to be true , from : dipsydoodle Feb 2013 #131
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Pope Allegedly Sought IMM...»Reply #66