Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

nuxvomica

(13,379 posts)
14. We need to revisit the hero's journey
Sat Apr 12, 2025, 06:29 PM
Apr 12

When I brought it up at a writing workshop, the instructor, a professor and best-selling author, ridiculed me for doing so, saying it was too reductive and has been pretty much deprecated. Apparently it's not welcome in academia. Yet I see it as an age-old instruction for navigating adulthood. People have been writing stories and retelling myths that explore the journey since at least the Epic of Gilgamesh, so I see it as a lesson necessary for the survival of the species.

My simplified version of the journey's message is this: We are born into a state of innocence but as we grow we face challenges that make us aware of both the corruption in the world and our own powers for dealing with it. Our singular duty as adults is to preserve and protect the innocent by fighting the forces of corruption, so that the innocent can themselves grow and face challenges, so the cycle can continue. We need literature and myth to deliver this instruction as the stories show that the hero is always reluctant to hear the call because it requires sacrifice (eg. Luke Skywalker losing a hand) for which the reward is not obvious. It is non-transactional while the rewards of corruption are usually obvious and immediate. The fundamental lesson is this: adult life will not have the comforts and privileges of childhood, but if we reject the call, we may be consigned to a permanent twilight of childhood, where the wonder, honesty and playfulness of innocence are replaced, respectively, by the fear, sham and drudgery of corruption. We became overage infants enslaved to our appetites. In the final stage of the hero's journey, the hero transforms the world into safer place for the innocent. This may not necessarily make the hero rich or happy or comfortable but it gives their life meaning.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Excellent post! SharonClark Apr 12 #1
Problem, conflict, solution. Well done. cachukis Apr 12 #2
Excellent! SheltieLover Apr 12 #3
Thanks for this excllent post canetoad Apr 12 #4
I really liked the scene in the fourth episode meadowlander Apr 12 #5
Can't say this enough: yardwork Apr 12 #6
Wow, I think I'm about to be the seventh person to say that this is an excellent post, if I can keyboard fast enough. FadedMullet Apr 12 #7
Little frozen spermies in test toobbies BoRaGard Apr 12 #8
I've been a male for all of my almost 80 years and I hate the male-oriented culture. erronis Apr 12 #9
true DonCoquixote Apr 12 #12
Excellent! LoisB Apr 12 #10
Misogyny came first. It has always been with us. We can tamp it way down, but will never eliminate it. . . nt Bernardo de La Paz Apr 12 #11
The key is that misogyny should not be cool! Mopar151 Apr 12 #16
I think in the *very long run it can be defeated to the point that it will effect very few women, and that will no electric_blue68 Apr 12 #21
History May Help PocatelloLiberal Apr 12 #13
Welcome to DU LetMyPeopleVote Apr 13 #24
We need to revisit the hero's journey nuxvomica Apr 12 #14
Well Lilith said, "To hell with you" and left Adam alone in the garden. 1WorldHope Apr 12 #15
Alpha-male obsession is a narrow cage. Mblaze Apr 12 #17
... Solly Mack Apr 12 #18
Well said! GiqueCee Apr 12 #19
Amen brother. meadowlander Apr 12 #20
A good, nuanced post. 👍 Like your various examples, too... electric_blue68 Apr 12 #22
DURec leftstreet Apr 12 #23
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Which came first, the mis...»Reply #14