Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

stopdiggin

(13,187 posts)
30. to a degree, yes.
Tue Oct 1, 2024, 11:15 PM
Oct 2024

but I also believe that there is (in general terms at least) a degree of complicity within the 'hosting' community.

So, it kind of depends. For the 5 year old that was just playing in the street when the gunfire (or missile strike) erupted - yeah, just plain bad luck. Other hand - if you happen to be a doctor that has been patching these bastards up and sending them back out to murder some more ... Or the truck driver that is 'just doing his job' (and being careful NOT to know what kind of freight ..) Ah, no - in that case you're playing some part in your 'bad luck'. (and so - to some degree - are a lot of other 'moving parts' in the community) Some of that cooperation is due to subjugation and a cowed population, yes. But, let's be honest here - some of it also comes in the form of willing and wholehearted support.

So - my own belief is that the 'innocent civilian' argument - has a good deal of nuance and shades of gray lurking around the margins. There's bad luck, and then there's bad luck ...

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I wish the people living in the apartments would not allow the jimfields33 Oct 2024 #1
Sarcasm, I presume? onandup Oct 2024 #2
I wish they could do something. jimfields33 Oct 2024 #3
It destroyed several high rise apartment buildings onandup Oct 2024 #6
Tough situation. jimfields33 Oct 2024 #7
Right iemanja Oct 2024 #17
Terrorists certainly don't. That's who I blame solely. jimfields33 Oct 2024 #20
Well, that won't matter iemanja Oct 2024 #21
Who knows what will happen. I do know Israel can't just say, "oh cool 150 bombs from Iran just arrived". jimfields33 Oct 2024 #24
And any amount of carnage is fine with you? iemanja Oct 2024 #29
Kill for peace! Klarkashton Oct 2024 #26
Did I miss the part Mountainguy Oct 2024 #4
Details, details, sarisataka Oct 2024 #8
+1. legitimate targets stopdiggin Oct 2024 #10
The tweet explicitly states the reason was civilian casualties onandup Oct 2024 #12
Are you serious? Mountainguy Oct 2024 #13
Hmmm....tough to think of an example. Let me ask my Japanese friend. I'll be right back. CincyDem Oct 2024 #28
The Tweet is simply a lie from the get go. Jk23 Oct 2024 #23
Some leave out important background info and Context.. Cha Oct 2024 #25
Just their bad luck I guess FullySupportDems Oct 2024 #5
people in your neighborhood are lobbing missiles (daily)? stopdiggin Oct 2024 #9
Yes, that is my point FullySupportDems Oct 2024 #14
so when the terrorists go to ground in your neighborhood stopdiggin Oct 2024 #15
Like I said originally, just bad luck then FullySupportDems Oct 2024 #22
to a degree, yes. stopdiggin Oct 2024 #30
Yes, but it doesn't sound good when you say it out loud FullySupportDems Oct 2024 #31
This message was self-deleted by its author iemanja Oct 2024 #19
2 different situations. And we did many other attacks JI7 Oct 2024 #11
Pakistan has nuclear weapons Johonny Oct 2024 #16
Remember the fringe left shitting on Obama for using drones? nt LexVegas Oct 2024 #18
Oh yeah. Cha Oct 2024 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Obama Team declined dropp...»Reply #30