Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

intheflow

(28,462 posts)
25. Librarian here. I'm going with: the book hasn't been banned.
Wed Aug 24, 2022, 04:40 PM
Aug 2022

It's been removed from required reading, but as far as I can see from the OP article, excerpts can still be taught (as they have in the past) and its not being removed from the school library. From another article, the age-inappropriateness content at issue is probably an account of a lynching early in the book. And, there actually are books (or parts of books) that are not appropriate for 7th graders in a public classroom situation. 7th grade in particular is prickly because at least a third of the kids are still emotionally immature for their ages.

Before you all jump on me, I'm not saying I agree with this decision. I read Helter Skelter in 6th grade, so I'm sure the majority of 7th graders in this Texas town could handle one horrific scene in an otherwise inspirational book. But this didn't come about in response to a parental request, or any MAGA assholes, it was reviewed by a panel of "teachers, principals and curriculum coordinators" as part of a regular review of teaching materials.

But okay, let's be true progressives and shit on public educators because - obviously, if they live in Texas, they must all be criminally insane and incompetent.

That's just sad. Haggard Celine Aug 2022 #1
This stuff just gets crazier and crazier. Biophilic Aug 2022 #2
Obviously we have woken in bizarro world questionseverything Aug 2022 #5
It sure feels like it. Biophilic Aug 2022 #7
See! You said "woke". COL Mustard Aug 2022 #16
Not to mention creepier and creepier Rural_Progressive Aug 2022 #21
Why not. Srkdqltr Aug 2022 #3
Next up, Dr. MLK Jr Day gratuitous Aug 2022 #4
It is more than books, the GOP wants to destroy American culture, history and values. Irish_Dem Aug 2022 #6
Sounds just like what Russia wants to do to Ukraine. Biophilic Aug 2022 #8
Bingo. Exactly 100% the same. Irish_Dem Aug 2022 #10
Post removed Post removed Aug 2022 #11
Bull. Elessar Zappa Aug 2022 #12
That's just ridiculous but what an inspiring story. underpants Aug 2022 #9
We need to roll this astroturf school board takeover shite JCMach1 Aug 2022 #13
The radicalized Republican party wants permanent, total control. Education is in their way. Hermit-The-Prog Aug 2022 #14
The school district denies that the book has been banned. TomSlick Aug 2022 #15
Wonder if they consider the Bible "age appropriate" with its incest, murder, and more. keithbvadu2 Aug 2022 #18
This is just absolutely ASININE. calimary Aug 2022 #17
Twitter reply: Rhiannon12866 Aug 2022 #19
That is just straight up evil ck4829 Aug 2022 #20
this has got to be the work of a minority of parents... bahboo Aug 2022 #22
I was reading pretty sophisticated books in middle school. Shakespeare, Euripides, etc. SharonAnn Aug 2022 #23
Can we buy this book ? JI7 Aug 2022 #24
Librarian here. I'm going with: the book hasn't been banned. intheflow Aug 2022 #25
why don't we just shit on Texas? CatWoman Aug 2022 #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Grandson of slave learned...»Reply #25