HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » This message was self-del... » Reply #12

Response to Jeebo (Original post)

Wed Mar 17, 2021, 04:02 PM

12. You might appreciate this book:

Last edited Wed Mar 17, 2021, 04:36 PM - Edit history (1)

The Anatomy of Violence: The Biological Roots of Crime
by Adrian Raine (Author) Format: Kindle Edition

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B009Y4I4R4/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_hsch_vapi_taft_p1_i0

Dr. Raine's argument is basically in agreement with you and he provides a lot of explanation and evidence that is is a deeply biological, sexual behavior.

I might, somewhat agree, and I'm not even sure that most behavioral biologists, forensic psychiatrists or neuropsychiatrists would find your position all that controversial. That viewpoint that "rape is about power, not sex" was something I grew up hearing whenever the topic of rape came up--like an automatic response--and I have always wondered about its origin and it indeed left me with questions when I began to research criminal behavior and motivations in the 90s for some writing projects. It does get confusing when you are looking at the behavior of, say, sexually motivated serial killers because in a strange way it often does have to do with their relationships with their mothers, and it then does seem to circle back to being about power and (even moreso) control. But looking back at the biological roots of rape, at least according to behavioral scientists, it seems to have to do with a drive to reproduce the genes.

When we talk about a 'crime of opportunity', as you point out, it does lead to obvious questions: If it is about power and not sex, why is the perpetrator choosing to express his power sexually? It's not like there aren't dozens of other ways to express power and control. That is always why I had questions as a young person about the cliche'd response that rape is about power, not sex. It went against what I perceived to be common sense and it seemed like people were trying to avoid talking about sexual violence for what it is by tossing it in a bin with any other types of deeply interpersonal violence despite the fact those behaviors vary widely. I remember once asking someone who told me this, "Okay, but why rape?" and that person had no answer. I stopped asking and just began repeating what I was taught: "Rape is about power, not sex," but I have always wondered about it and turned to books by scientists and psychologists for deeper and more thoughtful answers.

As controversial as the issue is, it's not a hill I want to die on, but that is my two cents. I'll keep up with the latest scientific thinking on this.

One conclusion I've gradually come to is that maybe society has reached an unspoken consensus that it is important for us as to assert and believe this whether it is true or not because it serves some important function or larger purpose to culture and civilization.

Cannot reply in locked threads

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 76 replies Author Time Post
Jeebo Mar 17 OP
WhiskeyGrinder Mar 17 #1
WhiskeyGrinder Mar 17 #2
Bettie Mar 17 #3
JI7 Mar 17 #10
Jeebo Mar 17 #25
Bettie Mar 17 #35
hlthe2b Mar 17 #38
Bettie Mar 17 #43
hlthe2b Mar 17 #45
Jeebo Mar 17 #39
Mossfern Mar 17 #49
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #68
hlthe2b Mar 17 #73
hlthe2b Mar 17 #4
Jeebo Mar 17 #27
hlthe2b Mar 17 #28
Jeebo Mar 17 #36
hlthe2b Mar 17 #37
Jeebo Mar 17 #41
hlthe2b Mar 17 #51
Jeebo Mar 17 #61
hlthe2b Mar 17 #64
Jeebo Mar 17 #67
hlthe2b Mar 17 #69
MoonchildCA Mar 17 #71
demmiblue Mar 17 #5
Mosby Mar 17 #16
hlthe2b Mar 17 #29
Jeebo Mar 17 #46
hlthe2b Mar 17 #48
Jeebo Mar 17 #54
hlthe2b Mar 17 #57
Jeebo Mar 17 #65
hlthe2b Mar 17 #66
Jeebo Mar 17 #74
hlthe2b Mar 17 #75
Aristus Mar 17 #6
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #11
Aristus Mar 17 #13
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #14
Jeebo Mar 17 #30
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #55
hlthe2b Mar 17 #32
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #56
hlthe2b Mar 17 #31
Elessar Zappa Mar 17 #7
wryter2000 Mar 17 #8
Moostache Mar 17 #9
Jeebo Mar 17 #18
hlthe2b Mar 17 #34
Jeebo Mar 17 #50
hlthe2b Mar 17 #52
LineReply You might appreciate this book:
Mike 03 Mar 17 #12
aikoaiko Mar 17 #15
Treefrog Mar 17 #17
Delarage Mar 17 #19
Caliman73 Mar 17 #23
dsc Mar 17 #26
Caliman73 Mar 17 #63
hlthe2b Mar 17 #40
LAS14 Mar 17 #20
Caliman73 Mar 17 #21
Squinch Mar 17 #22
ExTex Mar 17 #24
hlthe2b Mar 17 #42
fishwax Mar 17 #33
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #59
romana Mar 17 #44
leftyladyfrommo Mar 17 #47
leftstreet Mar 17 #53
Lars39 Mar 17 #58
IcyPeas Mar 17 #60
Caliman73 Mar 17 #70
JohnnyRingo Mar 17 #62
LiberalLoner Mar 17 #72
Jeebo Mar 17 #76
Please login to view edit histories.