General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Pick up the pace! Slow walkers four times more likely to die from COVID-19, study finds [View all]hlthe2b
(107,288 posts)will be coded as obese), but it can be addressed with other variables. To use walking speed alone as a measure of fitness is far more problematic. So, no. The epidemiologic literature (not "Nature" would disagree). Walking distance and regularity may well be a far more accurate assessment, along with adjustment for other fitness activities (e.g., cycling) especially for a significant subpopulation. Alternately, nearly every elite athlete with walking-related disabilities or injuries would be assessed as unfit and thus assumed at risk for severe adverse outcomes from COVID-19. Not to mention the tons of other unaddressed confounding factors, from preexisting disease & conditions to concurrent medications to nutritional deficiencies impacting immunity to...
The study in the OP is ridiculously confounded--along the lines of the infamous comparison of Utah v Nevada populations that would have you conclude "gambling causes cancer." I know you are British, but look up the differences in Utah v Nevada populations if this is not obvious to you as the ultimate example of confounding.