HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » 84 Years Ago Today; Dr Bo... » Reply #25

Response to Dennis Donovan (Original post)

Mon Jun 10, 2019, 09:19 AM

25. It's fascinating to me that AA has such a hold on addiction science and medicine -- and it's a

harmful one, IMO, as AA has not kept up with new understandings of use, abuse and addiction.

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/04/the-irrationality-of-alcoholics-anonymous/386255/

Alcoholics Anonymous has more than 2 million members worldwide, and the structure and support it offers have helped many people. But it is not enough for everyone. The history of AA is the story of how one approach to treatment took root before other options existed, inscribing itself on the national consciousness and crowding out dozens of newer methods that have since been shown to work better.

(snip)

People with alcohol problems also suffer from higher-than-normal rates of mental-health issues, and research has shown that treating depression and anxiety with medication can reduce drinking. But AA is not equipped to address these issues—it is a support group whose leaders lack professional training—and some meetings are more accepting than others of the idea that members may need therapy and/or medication in addition to the group’s help.

AA truisms have so infiltrated our culture that many people believe heavy drinkers cannot recover before they “hit bottom.” Researchers I’ve talked with say that’s akin to offering antidepressants only to those who have attempted suicide, or prescribing insulin only after a patient has lapsed into a diabetic coma. “You might as well tell a guy who weighs 250 pounds and has untreated hypertension and cholesterol of 300, ‘Don’t exercise, keep eating fast food, and we’ll give you a triple bypass when you have a heart attack,’ ” Mark Willenbring, a psychiatrist in St. Paul and a former director of treatment and recovery research at the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, told me. He threw up his hands. “Absurd.”

Part of the problem is our one-size-fits-all approach. Alcoholics Anonymous was originally intended for chronic, severe drinkers—those who may, indeed, be powerless over alcohol—but its program has since been applied much more broadly. Today, for instance, judges routinely require people to attend meetings after a DUI arrest; fully 12 percent of AA members are there by court order.

We once thought about drinking problems in binary terms—you either had control or you didn’t; you were an alcoholic or you weren’t—but experts now describe a spectrum. An estimated 18 million Americans suffer from alcohol-use disorder, as the DSM-5, the latest edition of the American Psychiatric Association’s diagnostic manual, calls it. (The new term replaces the older alcohol abuse and the much more dated alcoholism, which has been out of favor with researchers for decades.) Only about 15 percent of those with alcohol-use disorder are at the severe end of the spectrum. The rest fall somewhere in the mild-to-moderate range, but they have been largely ignored by researchers and clinicians. Both groups—the hard-core abusers and the more moderate overdrinkers—need more-individualized treatment options.


Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 44 replies Author Time Post
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 OP
malaise Jun 2019 #1
marble falls Jun 2019 #14
Rhiannon12866 Jun 2019 #2
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #4
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #7
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #9
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #11
tymorial Jun 2019 #13
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #24
Rhiannon12866 Jun 2019 #38
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #40
Rhiannon12866 Jun 2019 #41
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #43
Rhiannon12866 Jun 2019 #44
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #3
tymorial Jun 2019 #12
KY_EnviroGuy Jun 2019 #16
murielm99 Jun 2019 #5
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #6
murielm99 Jun 2019 #8
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #10
marble falls Jun 2019 #15
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #17
marble falls Jun 2019 #20
usaf-vet Jun 2019 #18
Dennis Donovan Jun 2019 #19
HopeAgain Jun 2019 #22
wendyb-NC Jun 2019 #21
HopeAgain Jun 2019 #23
LineReply It's fascinating to me that AA has such a hold on addiction science and medicine -- and it's a
WhiskeyGrinder Jun 2019 #25
Farmer-Rick Jun 2019 #26
WhiskeyGrinder Jun 2019 #27
Rhiannon12866 Jun 2019 #39
cally Jun 2019 #28
demosincebirth Jun 2019 #29
Cuthbert Allgood Jun 2019 #30
WhiskeyGrinder Jun 2019 #32
demosincebirth Jun 2019 #33
WhiskeyGrinder Jun 2019 #35
demosincebirth Jun 2019 #37
TheBlackAdder Jun 2019 #42
ismnotwasm Jun 2019 #31
demosincebirth Jun 2019 #34
KentuckyWoman Jun 2019 #36
Please login to view edit histories.