Not sure why some are so negative about AA.
I hope someone who has experience overcoming alcoholism chimes in below.
To those who shared, Thank You for sharing your heartfelt stories and AA experiences. Sharing is how we help each other. There is no shame. Addiction is an indiscriminate disease.
The stories of AA recovery in the comments below are the best part of this article.
I will share that I lost two spouses and my one brother to early deaths from Alcoholism. They held their noses when AA was mentioned.
On the other hand, I became friends with many who succeeded in controlling their addiction by regular AA attendance every week for the rest of their lives.
Here’s what a kind, honest agnostic shares below:
Comment # 32.
Agnostic with 17+ years sober through AA.
I distinctly remember cracking open the Big Book for the first time looking for religious (Biblical) terms, names and phrases that I didn't want anything to do with. They weren't there.
The only word I saw was God and AA clearly say's to choose a God of YOUR understanding. That I could deal with.
Since I'm agnostic and have no clue who, what or if God is, I "took what I needed" from the program and left the rest, which AA has no problem with you doing.
Individual counseling does not have a higher success rate and the co-pays are unaffordable for most.
AA is free!
Addiction is never “cured” but controlled. Addiction lurks, it ebbs and flows and can easily be triggered. The addict benefits from regular group support. Those that can afford individual counseling improve their control by also attending a support group.
But with both, if the addict doesn’t work the program, the program doesn’t work. Therefore, success rate score cards are arbitrary.
Here’s a bit of comparative analysis
Another study mentioned in the same publication observed a smaller outpatient sample. The results concluded that over 70% of those who attended a 12-step program weekly for 6 months before the two-year follow-up point were abstinent from alcohol. Another study conducted on those with an untreated drinking problem showed 70% of those with 27 weeks or more in AA were abstinent from alcohol at the 16-year follow-up mark. Moreover, the study revealed those with a shorter duration of time in AA had lower rates of abstinence.11
https://americanaddictioncenters.org/rehab-guide/12-step/whats-the-success-rate-of-aa
Same applies to any addiction. The addict is the only person that can succeed in using tools and faithfully work whatever programs he/she chooses.
There but for the Grace of God or Your Higher Self go you or I! Addiction is a disease.
Outlier Zealots on the spiritual scale can’t seem to help but vehemently argue with each other. The grinding need to “Be Right” is the very basis of being an indignant loudly verbose zealot.
I fear zealots on either side of the issue of Faith the most. Haven’t zealots led the greatest atrocities throughout history?
That said, I hope we all encourage the addicts in our orbit to try & work all the tools available to get the monkey on their back under control.
Addiction is a chronic, life long disease.
Warn the children! My parents warned me and scared me enough that I didn’t start using substances. Forever grateful ❤️
The anti-AA campaign is mystifying.
Could it be fueled by the hugely profitable rehab industry?