http://cnx.com/?p=1661
As the Republicans in Congress continue to hold the country’s working poor hostage in order to advance the more radical aspects of their agenda, there is once again talk from the White House and the more spineless members of the Democratic leadership of “compromise.”
The problem with that mentality is that the other side is uniquely unwilling to compromise, and is using our desire to compromise as a way to blackmail us into signing off on the worst parts of their agenda to get even the slightest crumbs of what we want. Many times, what we want are positions that they themselves championed until Obama started supporting them.
This puts me in mind of one of the paradoxes of
Zeno. Specifically, that of Achilles and the Tortoise.
Achilles is going to race a tortoise. To be fair, he is going to give the tortoise a head start of, say, 100 yards. So they take off. By the time Achilles has run 100 yards to reach where the tortoise had started, the tortoise has moved further down the road, let’s say, an additional 10 yards. So Achilles must run an additional 10 yards to catch up with the tortoise, but in the time it took him to run those 10, the tortoise has moved another yard. No matter how Achilles tries to catch up to the tortoise, every time he reaches someplace the tortoise had been, the tortoise has moved further.
Let’s use another version of the paradox, this one popularized by the Firesign Theater on the album
How Can You Be in Two Places at Once When You’re Not Anywhere At All? as the Antelope Freeway paradox. Our hero, Babe, is driving down the road looking for the turnoff for the Antelope Freeway. As he progresses, he keeps passing signs. “Antelope Freeway, One Mile.” “Antelope Freeway, 1/2 Mile.” “Antelope Freeway, 1/4 Mile.” “Antelope Freeway, 1/8 Mile.” And so on until somewhere around 1/512th of a mile to go, Babe uses his car’s climate control system to switch from the road to a tropical paradise. The moral is that no matter how fast you travel, if you only travel halfway to your destination each time, you never make it all the way to the end.
This is exactly what is wrong with our political system, and with Obama’s approach to it.
President Obama wanted an economic stimulus package. The obstructionist Republicans (and far too many obstructionist Democrats) basically told him that they’d give him half of what he wanted if he made half of that a bunch of tax giveaways for the wealthy. Deciding that half (or really a quarter) of what he wanted was better than nothing, he “compromised.” The end result was a stimulus that kept the economy on life support, but didn’t revive it.
So then as the stimulus was ending, Obama said “look, it did some good but not enough. Let’s do more.” The Republicans came back with “look, we’ll give you half of the old stimulus (by reapproving the payroll tax cut) if you agree to cut over a trillion dollars from the budget and extend the tax cuts for the wealthy. Obama “compromised.”
Now the payroll tax cut is coming up again. Obama knows that if taxes go back up on the middle class that the economy will go in the tank so he wants the tax cut extended. This time the Republicans are saying “look, we’ll let you have the tax cut for two more months if you give us this oil-sludge pipeline that isn’t going to bring a drop of oil to U.S. Markets and that even the Republicans who control the Nebraska State Legislature do not want." So now Obama is ready to compromise again.
No matter how hard you run towards the tortoise, it will move further down the road so you never catch up. No matter how many signs you pass, you never reach the Antelope Freeway.
No matter how much you compromise with the right wing, you will never accomplish what you want, or need, to do.
The answer? It’s simple. Achilles refuses to race the tortoise. Babe gives up on the Antelope Freeway. The President refuses to play their games.
That’s the way out of this stupid endless loop. Half measures never solve anything. But will the President, and the spineless Democratic leadership, take that step? We shall see.