Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sandensea

(21,600 posts)
Fri Dec 22, 2017, 06:25 PM Dec 2017

Former Foreign Minister Hector Timerman: I Am a Political Prisoner in Argentina

Former Argentine Foreign Minister Héctor Timerman who has been held under house arrest for the past week, published an editorial in the New York Times on Wednesday entitled 'I Am a Political Prisoner in Argentina'.

Timerman was arrested on December 14 on the orders of Argentine Federal Judge Claudio Bonadío on “treason” charges in which former President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, now a senator, was also included. The judge also sought her expulsion from the Senate to facilitate her arrest - a request rejected by the Senate for being “partisan and unjustified.”

The charges stem from the Memorandum of Understanding Timerman signed with Iran in 2013 for a joint investigation of the AMIA bombing, a still-unsolved 1994 incident in which 85 died in a Buenos Aires Jewish community center.

“Advancing the case was a key goal of the administration in which I served as foreign minister from 2010 to 2015,” Timerman wrote. “An Argentine judge would question the suspects in Iran and begin judicial proceedings to bring truth and justice to the victims, with a nonbinding truth commission of international jurists to observe the case.”

“For Mr. Bonadío, the agreement 'undermines' the investigation into the AMIA case and is the pretext for my indictment.”

Timerman noted, however, that before the agreement “the investigation into the attack was so flawed and corrupt that in 2004 the entire trial was annulled and the judge who led it was put under investigation. Judge Bonadío — who now accuses me of treason — led the investigation into that cover-up but was removed from it in 2005.”

Bonadío's charges rest on allegations that Fernández de Kirchner and Timerman petitioned Interpol to lift Red Notices against Iranian officials implicated in the AMIA attack - a claim rejected by the former Secretary General of Interpol, Ronald K. Noble. The three year-old claim, dismissed by Argentine courts in seven instances - including two appeals - was revived on December 14 by Bonadío.

“A biased Judge Bonadío report cannot change the truth,” Noble tweeted. “INTERPOL was never asked by Argentina or Timerman to remove the AMIA Red Notices!” He offered to testify in Argentina to that effect.

CELS, a prominent Argentine human rights organization, condemned the “use of the penal system to persecute political opponents.”

“Even if the agreement with Iran provided little guarantee of justice for the AMIA victims,” Human Rights Watch Americas director José Miguel Vivanco said, “pursuing criminal charges for treason against officials responsible for negotiating an international accord seems strained and unreasonable.”

Bonadío had been exposed in 1996 as a “napkin judge” - a shortlist of judges who lent themselves to politicized trials at the behest of then-President Carlos Menem. More recently, he has dismissed numerous corruption charges against President Mauricio Macri - including those stemming from the Panama Papers.

“Sadly, it is not the first time my family has been a victim of political persecution,” Timerman concluded. “Forty years ago, my father, the journalist Jacobo Timerman, was also a political prisoner. He spent over a year under house arrest, after being kidnapped and tortured in clandestine centers run by the military during my country’s last dictatorship.”

“Defense of human rights has been vitally important in my personal and professional life. I considered my diplomacy in this case to be part of that ideal. Instead, I find myself in a Kafkaesque process that aggravates my cancer and robs me of the time I have left.”

At: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/20/opinion/timerman-argentina-political-prisoner-bonadio.html




Former Argentine Foreign Minister Héctor Timerman and former Interpol Secretary General Ronald Noble discuss the AMIA case in 2013.

Noble has refuted claims that Timerman sought the lifting of Red Notice alerts against Iranian officials,
and has offered to testify in Argentina to that effect.
6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Former Foreign Minister Hector Timerman: I Am a Political Prisoner in Argentina (Original Post) sandensea Dec 2017 OP
Wasnt it Timmermans father who said, fierywoman Dec 2017 #1
I believe that was Winston Churchill sandensea Dec 2017 #2
Thank you for this info! fierywoman Dec 2017 #3
You're very welcome! sandensea Dec 2017 #4
I love the Rio De la Plata accent! fierywoman Dec 2017 #5
Sounds like Italian! sandensea Dec 2017 #6

sandensea

(21,600 posts)
2. I believe that was Winston Churchill
Fri Dec 22, 2017, 10:23 PM
Dec 2017

It is possible that Jacobo Timerman used that quote in one of his many op-eds and interviews over the years.

The elder Timerman, like most Argentine newspaper editors, supported the coup against the hapless Isabel Perón. He believed a coup would be merely a redux of the 1966-73 dictatorship, which was actually less repressive that Mrs. Perón and certainly a lot more competent (particularly in economic policy).

He was wrong.

The 1976 dictatorship ended up being a cross between Hitler (for its murderousness), Bush (for its militarism), Trump (for its corruption), and Paul Ryan (for its deregulatory, social Darwinist zeal). It ended a lot like the Bush regime did.

To his credit, his was the first major newspaper to turn against the dictatorship - doing so within months of the '76 coup. And the regime retaliated just as quickly: they murdered his assistant editor, Edgardo Sajón, and within weeks abducted Timerman himself.

He was tortured to the point of being left impotent, and would have been killed outright had it not been for Jimmy Carter.

Carter and Timerman finally met in Buenos Aires in 1984. "Carter saved lives, and increased democratic consciousness in the U.S. as well," he said.

Timerman died of old age in 1999.

sandensea

(21,600 posts)
4. You're very welcome!
Fri Dec 22, 2017, 10:29 PM
Dec 2017

Argentina is an interesting country, not least because it's history resembles the U.S.'s in many ways.

Only with a lot more drama.

sandensea

(21,600 posts)
6. Sounds like Italian!
Fri Dec 22, 2017, 10:59 PM
Dec 2017

And with good reason: around 3 million Italians settled in Argentina between 1860 and 1950.

The government succeeded in teaching Spanish to the successive waves of immigrants; but the accent stuck - particularly in the Pampas area, where most people live (Spaniards already spoke it, of course; but there hundreds of thousands from just about every other European country as well as Syria and Lebanon).

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Jewish Group»Former Foreign Minister H...