Regarding background checks

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

The current NICS applies only to sales from FFLs. There has been a lot of talk about requiring a background check for non-FFL sales. What reasons are given as arguments against this idea?

I don't much care if you happen to be for or against the idea of expanding the background check requirements or if you find any particular reason for or against the idea especially appealing. I'm not looking for you to make a case pro or con unless you feel motivated, I'm actually just looking for those reasons.

Thanks

[rrneck]

1. Universal background checks are, in principle, a fine idea.

In practice they are an unworkable invasion of privacy. Transfers of firearms between a merchant and a customer are a business transaction and can be regulated as such. Guns are actually not being regulated, but a business transaction as defined by that relationship. Personal relationships are, well, personal and there is really no way to regulate that without violating people's privacy. The Snowden leak affair is an ironic counterpoint to the universal background check controversy.

Here's an old OP on the subject, but don't kick it.

http://www.democraticunderground.com/1172118043

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

2. Thanks for the link...

...and info. I'll be thinking on these aspects.

[kudzu22]

11. I agree - it's basically unworkable

If every "transfer" has to go through NICS, when transfer is defined as me handing a gun to someone else. It would be much better to have a national FOID card that identifies a person as having been checked out and OK to possess a gun. No need to go through the check each time you touch someone else's gun.

[rdharma]

3. There's no reason for background checks of gun transfers between friends....

If a shady stranger is buying my gun, then he's my friend!

See how that works?

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

4. re: "See how that works?"

Yes, I've always understood how snark and sarcasm work.

Thanks

[rdharma]

5. Sarcasm works best ....... with a bit of reality mixed in!

It makes for a better teaching point!

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

6. I'm not exactly sure...

...if I'd say "best" but it works, usually.

[rdharma]

7. I'm glad you basically agree. nt

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

8. ...

Have a nice day.

[rdharma]

9. Thanks! You too!

[discntnt_irny_srcsm]

10. Well...

...usually it works.