Room to Criticize Israel Grows—but Are Policy Changes on the Table?
Opposing the Israel lobby is no longer political suicide.
Phyllis Bennis July 15, 2014
With the collapse of an Egyptian cease-fire proposal, the horror of Israels latest Gaza assault continues. At least 185 have been killed, almost 80 percent of them civilians. Almost half are women and children. At least seventy homes were specifically targeted and destroyed. Five healthcare facilities, including a hospital, have been damaged in air strikes. There was a direct attack on a center for profoundly disabled people. It was one of Israels much-bragged-about carefully targeted bombings, including the now-iconic knock on the roof message from the Israeli bombersthe small bomb that signals much worse to come. It wasnt an accident. Three people, two patients and a caregiver, were killed there. It goes on.
And Congressindeed almost all of official Washingtonis speaking with almost one voice: we stand with Israel. Israel has the right to defend itself. No country would stand by and allow this. But something is different this time. And not only that the assault is different, and worse.
The difference is the political environment in which this attack is happening, especially the political environment here in the United States. For those of us whove been working on changing US policy in the Middle East for decades, the bad news is in front of us every day: that policy hasnt changed, and billions of dollars in aid money and uncritical political, diplomatic and military support for Israel remains constant.
But there is some good news. Its only obvious when you can back up for a moment to look past the daily bad-news reality. The good news is that the discourse has shifted dramaticallyin mainstream news coverage, punditry, pop culture and more. It's much better than ever. They dont get it right, still, but things are changing. Twelve years ago, during the siege of Yasir Arafats compound in Ramallah and the surrounding of the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, we didnt hear many Palestinian voices in the mainstream press. In 2006, during Israels attack on Gaza, The New York Times and NPR didnt send their reporters to the Khan Younis refugee camp or to Gaza City.
But the coverage had already begun to shift during Cast Lead, the three-week Israeli war against Gaza in 200809, and we realized then how much the media changes reflected the overall discourse shift. Despite Israeli efforts to exclude the international press, Al Jazeera and other Arabic channels were broadcasting live out of Gaza. The Times had a terrific young stringer, Taghreed el-Khodary, filing hour by hour. Israel probably wouldnt have allowed her into the Strip, but they couldnt stop her, she was already thereborn and raised in Gaza and living with her family.
more...
http://www.thenation.com/article/180653/room-criticize-israel-grows-are-policy-changes-table#