Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
'A responsibility to say no': Prosecutors vow not to bring charges under severe abortion laws
This is more analysis than news.
Morning Mix
A responsibility to say no: Prosecutors vow not to bring charges under severe abortion laws
By Isaac Stanley-Becker, Reporter based in the U.K.
May 21 at 5:36 AM
The facts at first seem unambiguous: A motorist is caught with five pounds of methamphetamines, a Schedule II controlled substance under Utahs strict drug laws. ... But Sim Gill, Salt Lake Countys district attorney, would decline to pursue such a hypothetical case if he discovered that the search had been unlawful conducted without a warrant or in the absence of a reasonable suspicion that a traffic law had been breached.
Prosecutors should apply similar discretion, Gill argues, and refuse to bring charges under a wave of new abortion restrictions that plainly contradict Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Courts 1973 verdict that a woman has a constitutional right to choose whether to bear a child. ... We do this all the time, deciding that we have an ethical duty not to prosecute a case because it would be in violation of a constitutional protection afforded to citizens, Gill, a Democrat, said in an interview with The Washington Post. Whats new here is that this is an area, abortion, that we typically dont find ourselves in, because the procedure has not been criminalized like this in recent history.
Now that the question has been decisively transformed into one of criminal law in his state and others that have banned abortion weeks before the viability threshold set forth in Roe its up to prosecutors to stand up for institutional integrity in these charged times, Gill said. ... We cannot put people in jail for this, he maintained. ... A similar position has been announced by several district attorneys in Georgia, the site of one of the most searing abortion debates. Over the weekend, the Republican governor, Brian Kemp, scorned calls to boycott the state by C-list celebrities, according to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
....
[Gill] knows what his critics are saying about him: that he has overstepped in seeking to undo the will of lawmakers, who have been limiting abortion rights since the Supreme Court, in its 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey decision, gave new grounds for states to regulate the procedure. ... Gill sees matters differently. ... In a participatory democracy, we have our legislators who express what the law ought to be, but legislative expressions dont happen in a vacuum, he said. They happen in a constitutional framework. And I wont use the authority of my office to enforce a law that is constitutionally suspect as it stands right now. ... Ultimately, if prosecutions do proceed, the fate of defendants would rest with juries. A century ago, when abortion was a crime, juries regularly refused to convict.
Isaac Stanley-Becker is a reporter on The Washington Post's Morning Mix team. Follow https://twitter.com/isaacstanbecker
A responsibility to say no: Prosecutors vow not to bring charges under severe abortion laws
By Isaac Stanley-Becker, Reporter based in the U.K.
May 21 at 5:36 AM
The facts at first seem unambiguous: A motorist is caught with five pounds of methamphetamines, a Schedule II controlled substance under Utahs strict drug laws. ... But Sim Gill, Salt Lake Countys district attorney, would decline to pursue such a hypothetical case if he discovered that the search had been unlawful conducted without a warrant or in the absence of a reasonable suspicion that a traffic law had been breached.
Prosecutors should apply similar discretion, Gill argues, and refuse to bring charges under a wave of new abortion restrictions that plainly contradict Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Courts 1973 verdict that a woman has a constitutional right to choose whether to bear a child. ... We do this all the time, deciding that we have an ethical duty not to prosecute a case because it would be in violation of a constitutional protection afforded to citizens, Gill, a Democrat, said in an interview with The Washington Post. Whats new here is that this is an area, abortion, that we typically dont find ourselves in, because the procedure has not been criminalized like this in recent history.
Now that the question has been decisively transformed into one of criminal law in his state and others that have banned abortion weeks before the viability threshold set forth in Roe its up to prosecutors to stand up for institutional integrity in these charged times, Gill said. ... We cannot put people in jail for this, he maintained. ... A similar position has been announced by several district attorneys in Georgia, the site of one of the most searing abortion debates. Over the weekend, the Republican governor, Brian Kemp, scorned calls to boycott the state by C-list celebrities, according to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
....
[Gill] knows what his critics are saying about him: that he has overstepped in seeking to undo the will of lawmakers, who have been limiting abortion rights since the Supreme Court, in its 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey decision, gave new grounds for states to regulate the procedure. ... Gill sees matters differently. ... In a participatory democracy, we have our legislators who express what the law ought to be, but legislative expressions dont happen in a vacuum, he said. They happen in a constitutional framework. And I wont use the authority of my office to enforce a law that is constitutionally suspect as it stands right now. ... Ultimately, if prosecutions do proceed, the fate of defendants would rest with juries. A century ago, when abortion was a crime, juries regularly refused to convict.
Isaac Stanley-Becker is a reporter on The Washington Post's Morning Mix team. Follow https://twitter.com/isaacstanbecker
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
3 replies, 1462 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (9)
ReplyReply to this post
3 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
'A responsibility to say no': Prosecutors vow not to bring charges under severe abortion laws (Original Post)
mahatmakanejeeves
May 2019
OP
Dulcinea
(6,494 posts)1. This is happening in Georgia.
mahatmakanejeeves
(56,710 posts)2. Thanks for that link. NT
Dulcinea
(6,494 posts)3. My pleasure! nt