Mysterious 'Z' Painted on Russian Tanks Closing in on Ukraine Border
Source: Daily Beast
While the world continues to watch Russian troops mass and maneuver at Ukraines vast borders, an esoteric group of investigative journalists and military experts are focusing on an ominous Z that has started appearing on military hardware heading towards Ukraine.
Video posted on social media has shown hundreds more tanks, communications vehicles and rocket launchers bearing down on the border. Many of those captured on camera have been painted with a Z inside a large white square.
Bellingcat reporter Aric Toler, says his group has been monitoring Russian military symbols for the last eight years, but they have no idea what they [the Zs] are and havent seen them before. So, assume the worst, I guess/fear, he wrote on Twitter.
...
Others have speculated Russia is borrowing a play used in World War II by allies who used symbols to avoid friendly fire accidents since most Ukraine tanks are Soviet era and easily confused with Russias fleet. There is also speculation that the Z could stand for Russian enemy no. 1: Ukraine president Volodymyr Zelensky, who has vowed he wont be drawn into action by the saber rattling around his country.
Read more: https://www.thedailybeast.com/z-painted-on-russian-tanks-and-military-vehicles-near-ukraine-border?ref=scroll
doc03
(37,129 posts)marie999
(3,334 posts)jgmiller
(457 posts)They do it to avoid friendly fire. In the middle of battle it's really hard to tell one type of tank from another. Reporters just love creating mysteries out of nothing.
Also the tanks the Ukraine has are all ex-Soviet tanks which are the exact same ones Russia has so they would get confused. One would think a smart Ukrainian general might do the same paint job but with a subtle difference and get the drop on some Russian tanks.
Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)I seem to recall reading that dressing up in the enemy's uniforms/colors is a war crime. I also remember the Nazis doing something similar. Believe it was called Operation Werewolf or something like that.
InstantGratification
(292 posts)They have some of the same equipment. As long as each army is using their home nation's colors and markings, they aren't crossing the line. The only way this would count is if the Ukrainian forces had that "Z" on them and the Russians were impersonating that. It seems far more likely that this is just to make "friendly" forces (from the Russian perspective) easier to identify. US forces did it with our fighters in WW2 to stop our own AAA units from firing on them.
Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)I was referring to the suggestion that Ukrainian tank units add the "Z" marking to throw the Russians off and make them think Ukrainian units were friendlies.
jgmiller
(457 posts)I've never heard of impersonating your enemy as being a war crime.
Definitely painting a military unit as a medical unit and then fighting with it is a very big war crime. As is attacking a unit that is marked as such. That's why US Navy hospital ships are painted bright white with a huge red cross so there is no mistaking them as non-combatents.
Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)Under Article 39 of Protocol I of the Geneva Convention, it's illegal to "mask yourself as the enemy." Not sure if that applies to vehicles or only to personnel.
So maybe not a "war crime" per se but against the gentlemanly rules of war, if such a thing can be said to exist.
LiberalLovinLug
(14,386 posts)CloudWatcher
(1,947 posts)Like invading and taking the Crimea? Or our invasion of Iraq looking for those WMDs?
What's the point of defining war crimes if there are no consequences for violations?
paleotn
(19,737 posts)although Ukraine's are older models for the most part.
C Moon
(12,632 posts)Javaman
(63,233 posts)Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)Javaman
(63,233 posts)I was throwing things at the screen (I watched it at home)
Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)Once it became clear it was just another mindless zombie (heh) movie and not a thoughtful examination of the human condition against the backdrop of a zombie apocalypse, I turned it off in disgust. Done right, it could've arguably been the best zombie film ever made. Alas...
Hopefully Max Brooks got paid well, considering what they did to his baby.
Javaman
(63,233 posts)it's basically an adoption/adaption of the book without crediting it.
it's supposed to be an anthology of zombie stories from people who lived through the z apocalypse.
https://deadline.com/2021/10/tales-of-the-walking-dead-anthology-spinoff-series-amc-the-walking-dead-1234854559/
also, if you haven't watched it Black Summer on Netflix is fantastic zombie tv show.
Jedi Guy
(3,324 posts)I kinda lost interest in season 9, but this sounds interesting. Also appreciate the recommendation for Black Summer, will have to give it a look.
LT Barclay
(2,791 posts)Star Trek First Contact. Because the borg are essentially zombies.
IronLionZion
(47,315 posts)or friendly fire. Anything is possible these days
Skittles
(160,837 posts)Last edited Sun Feb 20, 2022, 09:23 PM - Edit history (1)
Hiawatha Pete
(1,971 posts)relayerbob
(7,078 posts)paleotn
(19,737 posts)If looked at from a distance, in the fog of war, it's difficult to tell who's friend and who's foe if you're both using similar equipment.
FailureToCommunicate
(14,359 posts)theirs.
Talitha
(7,489 posts)Bayard
(24,148 posts)Response to Wicked Blue (Original post)
monkeyman1 This message was self-deleted by its author.
Gore1FL
(22,033 posts)IndianaDave
(632 posts)which looks like our "3" or another, more complex Cyrillic letter, that I cannot reproduce here. If it is actually a Western Z, it makes no sense, unless it's intended for a Western audience.
Bayard
(24,148 posts)I agree, probably to avoid friendly fire.
Historic NY
(38,216 posts)twodogsbarking
(12,310 posts)Martin68
(24,824 posts)on their tanks. Their situation will be desperate in any case.