General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIs obsessive TIDYNESS the root of racism and homophobia?
The Yale experiments found peoples aversion towards a lack of order in images and patterns 'consistently overlapped' with their tendency to stigmatise individuals seen as different
An aversion to 'broken patterns' such as the sight of a picture hanging crookedly on a wall, out of order tiles, or a desk with things in the wrong place has been linked to racism and homophobia.
The Yale team say their groundbreaking study 'sets out a new basis for prejudice'.
The researchers say that traditional explanations of prejudice, namely that it arises from a sense of danger or some deeply embedded evolutionary flight-or-fight response, may now not be correct.
More: http://www.cetusnews.com/tech/Is-obsessive-TIDYNESS-the-root-of-racism-and-homophobia-.HJbagrcxf.html
And here's the abstract of the paper:
Relating pattern deviancy aversion to stigma and prejudice
What predicts peoples powerful and universal dislike of social deviancy? Across six studies, aversion towards non-social pattern deviancy, for example, a row of triangles with one triangle out of line, predicted aversion towards stigmatized individuals, social norm breakers, statistically negative and positive deviants, and a racial minority group (Black individuals). The relationship between pattern deviancy and social deviancy aversion emerged across explicit and implicit measures, across cultures (United States and China), and was of a moderately large magnitude (meta-analytic effect size: d?=?0.68). Studies 7 and 8 examined developmental differences. Older but not younger childrens pattern deviancy aversion related to their dislike of social norm breakers. Although non-social pattern deviancy and social deviancy judgements may seem distinct given their differing domains, peoples aversion towards non-social pattern deviancy and social deviancy consistently overlapped. These findings raise the possibility that pattern deviancy aversion plays an important role in stigmatization and prejudice.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-017-0243-x (Need to subscribe for full access - no more at link)
BigmanPigman
(51,569 posts)credential for teaching students with special needs...this goes for both the high and low ends of the spectrum. GATE (Gifted And Talented) is based on IQ tests administered to all public school students in 3rd and 5th grades in San Diego. We teachers took sample tests and they have no words at all. All the tests are a series of patterns and they get very difficult quickly. I recall the film A Beautiful Mind and the theme of how scientific theories, economics, etc is based on patterns. Math and Science is patterns. Does that mean that mathematicians, scientists, the highly intelligent, etc. are predisposed to being prejudiced?
3catwoman3
(23,951 posts)And personally reassuring. I do like pictures and Venetian blinds hanging straight, and have a couple other minor peculiarities, but am about as far from "obsessively tidy" one could be without being a hoarder. I used to have a sign hanging on my closet door knob that said, "You may TOUCH the dust, but please don't WRITE in it."
canetoad
(17,136 posts)I'd like to see more peer reviewed articles on this study; it could be a deep rabbit hole. First thoughts are the rise of Hitler and the famed German need for order.
marble falls
(57,014 posts)Girard442
(6,066 posts)...all this talk of "deviancy" makes this discussion sound like a paper about eugenics from 1930. Someone who, when confronted with diversity, sees "social deviancy" makes me think of General Jack D. Ripper from "Dr. Strangelove."
lunasun
(21,646 posts)unblock
(52,126 posts)At least in my anecdotal experience, I haven't noticed a correlation between ocd and bigotry.
Moreover, if it's just that the minority doesn't fit a pattern, it doesn't explain why it's only certain patterns that matter. Bigots may see black people as not fitting a pattern but have no problem with blonds, who also are a minority. And of course it doesn't explain sexism.
KT2000
(20,568 posts)universal dislike of deviancy - ???
I do believe conservatives consider anyone different from themselves as deviants to be thrown overboard but not so liberals.