Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSuperstition helps explain how people think about gun laws
https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21730013-large-number-republican-voters-indulge-magical-thinking-superstition-helps-explain
A large number of Republican voters indulge in magical thinking
THE Onion put it best: No Way To Prevent This, Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens. An accurate summary of gun-control opponents response to Americas periodic gun massacres, the headline was also familiar. The satirical website has run it, with few alterations to an accompanying spoof article, five times: after six people were murdered in California in 2014; after nine were murdered in South Carolina, nine in Oregon and 14 in California in 2015; and after the killing of 58 and maiming of 489 people by a lone gunman in Las Vegas on October 1st.
Satire thrives where the usual checks on human folly fail. In this case it points to the fact that America, despite having a gun-murder rate 25 times higher than that of other developed countries, has no serious debate on how to reduce the killing, because Republican lawmakers refuse to countenance the only thing that easily would. By making it even a bit harder for killers to get gunsas action taken in Australia, Britain and Canada showsAmerica would have fewer gun deaths. Yet only a quarter of Republican voters accept that demonstrable truth. Most say America would have less crime if only more Americans were armed.
The usual explanation for this delusion is brilliantly effective lobbying by gun clubs. Since the 1970s the National Rifle Association, supported by gun makers, has recast what was once a public- safety issue into an argument about liberty: if you believe gun ownership is a thin red line against government tyranny, as the NRA claims, it scarcely matters whether it also leads to more killing. At the same time, the lobbyists have bullied Republican lawmakers so thoroughly that none dares speak against them. Asked for his position on gun control this week, Paul Ryan said hed rather talk about cutting taxes. The Onion could not improve on that.
Yet though Republican voters have moved markedly against gun control over the course of the NRAs lobbying, it alone cannot explain that shift. Many Republican voters are more selective in their support for guns than the ideologues; they tend to be momentarily keener on gun controls after a massacre, for example. It also seems notable that the same people who believe guns make America safer are also likely to hold a number of other irrational views. Around half of Republicans do not believe in evolution or anthropogenic climate change. They have also just elected as president a man who has suggested vaccines cause autism. Donald Trumps insurgency in itself suggests that any explanation of Republican attitudes rooted in conservative ideology should be treated with caution.
A forthcoming book by the political scientists Eric Oliver and Thomas Wood, Enchanted America, offers an alternative explanation. It argues that people who believe guns make America safer, among other fallacies, display a strain of superstition that has always existed in American politics, on the right and the left, but which in recent decades has concentrated on the right, and now threatens to subsume it. Its proponents, who the authors call intuitionists, understand the world on the basis of feelings and gut instinct, not doctrine or empirical facts, even when confronted with them. Much of what looks like an ideological gap in this country, the authors write, is due more to the power of these innate intuitions than abstract principles or values.
A large number of Republican voters indulge in magical thinking
THE Onion put it best: No Way To Prevent This, Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens. An accurate summary of gun-control opponents response to Americas periodic gun massacres, the headline was also familiar. The satirical website has run it, with few alterations to an accompanying spoof article, five times: after six people were murdered in California in 2014; after nine were murdered in South Carolina, nine in Oregon and 14 in California in 2015; and after the killing of 58 and maiming of 489 people by a lone gunman in Las Vegas on October 1st.
Satire thrives where the usual checks on human folly fail. In this case it points to the fact that America, despite having a gun-murder rate 25 times higher than that of other developed countries, has no serious debate on how to reduce the killing, because Republican lawmakers refuse to countenance the only thing that easily would. By making it even a bit harder for killers to get gunsas action taken in Australia, Britain and Canada showsAmerica would have fewer gun deaths. Yet only a quarter of Republican voters accept that demonstrable truth. Most say America would have less crime if only more Americans were armed.
The usual explanation for this delusion is brilliantly effective lobbying by gun clubs. Since the 1970s the National Rifle Association, supported by gun makers, has recast what was once a public- safety issue into an argument about liberty: if you believe gun ownership is a thin red line against government tyranny, as the NRA claims, it scarcely matters whether it also leads to more killing. At the same time, the lobbyists have bullied Republican lawmakers so thoroughly that none dares speak against them. Asked for his position on gun control this week, Paul Ryan said hed rather talk about cutting taxes. The Onion could not improve on that.
Yet though Republican voters have moved markedly against gun control over the course of the NRAs lobbying, it alone cannot explain that shift. Many Republican voters are more selective in their support for guns than the ideologues; they tend to be momentarily keener on gun controls after a massacre, for example. It also seems notable that the same people who believe guns make America safer are also likely to hold a number of other irrational views. Around half of Republicans do not believe in evolution or anthropogenic climate change. They have also just elected as president a man who has suggested vaccines cause autism. Donald Trumps insurgency in itself suggests that any explanation of Republican attitudes rooted in conservative ideology should be treated with caution.
A forthcoming book by the political scientists Eric Oliver and Thomas Wood, Enchanted America, offers an alternative explanation. It argues that people who believe guns make America safer, among other fallacies, display a strain of superstition that has always existed in American politics, on the right and the left, but which in recent decades has concentrated on the right, and now threatens to subsume it. Its proponents, who the authors call intuitionists, understand the world on the basis of feelings and gut instinct, not doctrine or empirical facts, even when confronted with them. Much of what looks like an ideological gap in this country, the authors write, is due more to the power of these innate intuitions than abstract principles or values.
Republicans are a strange beast. Their gut talks to them, tells them things that won't be swayed by liberal lies such as "data" or "evidence". Socialists always want to collect data because they have no guts. It feels true so it must be so.
Stephen Colbert Truthiness: the quality of seeming or being felt to be true, even if not necessarily true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truthiness
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
2 replies, 1784 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (3)
ReplyReply to this post
2 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Superstition helps explain how people think about gun laws (Original Post)
IronLionZion
Oct 2017
OP
Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)1. How can you be special if no one is out to get you?
Governance through the sympathetic magic of ideology...
IronLionZion
(45,380 posts)2. You're so important that someone some day is coming after you
any day now. Just you wait. As soon as you drop your guard for one second....