General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNYTimes: How to Make Fun of Nazis
The Opinion Pages
How to Make Fun of Nazis
By MOISES VELASQUEZ-MANOFF
AUG. 17, 2017
For decades, Wunsiedel, a German town near the Czech border, has struggled with a parade of unwanted visitors. It was the original burial place of one of Adolf Hitlers deputies, a man named Rudolf Hess. And every year, to residents chagrin, neo-Nazis marched to his grave site. The town had staged counterdemonstrations to dissuade these pilgrims. In 2011 it had exhumed Hesss body and even removed his grave stone. But undeterred, the neo-Nazis returned. So in 2014, the town tried a different tactic: humorous subversion.
The campaign, called Rechts Gegen Rechts the Right Against the Right turned the march into Germanys most involuntary walkathon. For every meter the neo-Nazis marched, local residents and businesses pledged to donate 10 euros (then equivalent to about $12.50) to a program that helps people leave right-wing extremist groups, called EXIT Deutschland.
They turned the march into a mock sporting event. Someone stenciled onto the street start, a halfway mark and a finish line, as if it were a race. Colorful signs with silly slogans festooned the route. If only the Führer knew! read one. Mein Mampf! (my munch) read another that hung over a table of bananas. A sign at the end of the route thanked the marchers for their contribution to the anti-Nazi cause 10,000 (close to $12,000). And someone showered the marchers with rainbow confetti at the finish line.
The approach has spread to several other German towns and one in Sweden (where it was billed as Nazis Against Nazis).
This week, following the violence in Charlottesville, Va., Wunsiedel has come back into the news. Experts in nonviolent protest say it could serve as a model for Americans alarmed by the resurgent white supremacist movement who are looking for an effective way to respond (and who might otherwise be tempted to meet violence with violence).
We've got to be able to come up with something equivalent. Let's work to turn every hate group rally into a pledge drive for the Southern Poverty Law Center (other suggestions welcome). Call on sane people to contribute X dollars to anti-hate cause for every every hateful person who shows up at the rally. Put up a big fund raising thermometer. Cheers and thanks to the assholes who show up for their part in raising money for such a wonderful cause.
angstlessk
(11,862 posts)'KKK, thanks for funding the Black College Fund' For every foot you walked we have donated ??? dollars.
"Nazi's, thanks for the Jewish Anti Defamation League contribution...for every foot you walked we received ??? dollars.
If a right-wingnut event is a march, do the same thing as the town of Wunsiedel did (i.e., Paint start and finish lines. Confetti and thanks to the finishers. Jeering signs.) If it is a rally, not a march, instead of money per foot, it can be money per person who shows up. The greater their turnout, the more they work against themselves.
I think keeping it playful is what makes this tactic effective. Certainly, violent reactionaries are a serious danger. Their violence, and the ideology they promote, costs lives. Yes, we must protect ourselves and work against them. But when directly confronting them, we need to stop meeting their anger and hate with anger and hate. When we do that we play into their "look how we are victimized" recruitment rhetoric. When meeting "face-to-face," better to laugh in their faces, than to puff up their sense of self-importance by showing them anger and fear.
I can't think of a more effective way to derail them than to turn their efforts to band together in public as a show of strength into big, fat, extremely visible, fund raisers for the forces that oppose them. What seems key is to make a direct and visible connection between what they are doing -- the number of feet walked in a march, or the number of people who show up an event -- and the dollars raised against them. There are many worthy organizations out there, but it would be best to make each right-wing nut event a pledge drive for just one of them so the tally of dollars raised isn't "diluted." Different wingnut events, different orgs, sure. But for a given event, pick one to raise money for.
My two cents. YMMV.
Danascot
(4,897 posts)A local nonprofit has deployed a fund-raising tactic used to counter neo-Nazi groups in Germany ahead of Saturdays controversial Boston Free Speech rally on the Common.
Union Capital Boston, a Jamaica Plain-based charity that fosters community engagement and advocates for equality, has launched an initiative to raise money for groups like Black Lives Matter and the Southern Poverty Law Center.
People can pledge a certain amount of money per rally attendee.
The more people who attend the free speech rally, the more money will be raised for groups that stand in opposition to the rally.
https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2017/08/17/boston-novel-fund-raising-model-combat-saturday-free-speech-rally/c2wdqrKqH7EgO5LkVB7JML/story.html
mitch96
(14,686 posts)That would be neat.. How about taking a picture of a Nazi Rally attendee and pledge using that pic as a donation sponsor.. "We pledge $100 to XYZ in honor of this gentleman"...
The guy could never show his face on Stormtrooper again!!!
m
pat_k
(10,879 posts)pat_k
(10,879 posts)canetoad
(18,150 posts)Read it the other day and was amused and inspired by the town's lateral thinking.
K&R
SWBTATTReg
(24,170 posts)Wonderful!!!
zentrum
(9,866 posts)DoBotherMe
(2,350 posts)They are so dangerous I really don't know how we counter protest without the fear of death or the likelihood of a melee. It's a conundrum for us here in the US.
Hekate
(94,842 posts)Worth a try.
DeminPennswoods
(16,325 posts)nt
pat_k
(10,879 posts)AJT
(5,240 posts)A 60s sit in(or out). You can't be violent sitting down, you do have to have self control. Reacting with anger and aggression just feeds their fire.
I think just not showing up at all is a great idea, but mocking them is a good alternative.
greeny2323
(590 posts)I liked the guy who showed up with a sousaphone at a Nazi rally in South Carolina.
BowlLikeAChicken
(69 posts)right at the beginning of the march with a picture of a doctor that says
A message from the Proctological Society of America Please NAZI's you're giving assholes a bad reputation .
zanana1
(6,294 posts)doodsaq
(120 posts)That's how you counterprotest. Ridicule them until they shrink into a tiny ball of irrelevance.
mcar
(43,534 posts)flt rsk
(92 posts)I think a group dressed in Halloween costumes and holding bags with trick or treat signs, would be appropriate.
wryter2000
(47,509 posts)And the SPLC would be the perfect beneficiary
Brother Buzz
(37,904 posts)pat_k
(10,879 posts)Need some additional brass, but these would be my requested "hate-rally" accompaniments.
These guys are dressed the part!
Liberty Belle
(9,612 posts)And maybe some loud rap music, too.
pat_k
(10,879 posts)Perhaps Mel Brooks "The Hilter Rap" should make the list.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwin9sG36ubVAhUFjVQKHUxhBVkQ3ywIKTAA&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4zpYQJkBQp0&usg=AFQjCNFkngiuOQvmcGnMBIFLcHm21HNwcw
DinahMoeHum
(22,496 posts)Imagine sousaphones and tubas playing this!