General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsChildren Become Risky Assets as Business Practices Come to Education
A report from the El Paso Times revealed last week that school administrators in that city may have engaged in some questionable practices to make their all-important data appear better than it ought to have been. The key element in the District's data portfolio is the 10th grade standardized test. Administrators apparently went to great lengths to prevent students likely to score poorly from taking this test. These steps included:
Placing students entering the country into the 9th grade, regardless of where their transcripts indicated they should be.
Allowing schools to reclassify students to a higher grade, without requiring they take the test - essentially skipping them over the test.
Former El Paso schools superintendent Lorenzo Garcia recently pled guilty to cheating federal accountability systems through these maneuvers. The fate of those who worked with him to implement this scheme is unclear.
This scandal echoes the patterns of manipulations associated with the "Texas Miracle" more than a decade ago, when schools in Houston reported zero dropouts. In Houston, principals who failed to hit their data goals were terminated. So they held students back, or covered up their drop-outs in other ways. This "miracle" was used to prove that educators elsewhere should be expected to produce similar results -- and thus was born No Child Left Behind.
more . . . http://blogs.edweek.org/teachers/living-in-dialogue/2012/06/children_become_risky_assets_a.html?cmp=SOC-SHR-FB
4th law of robotics
(6,801 posts)get rid of them and no more problems.
pnwmom
(108,959 posts)MadHound
(34,179 posts)For as long as we pursue the foolishness known as high stakes testing. With their career on the line, more and more teachers and administrators are going to lie, cheat and steal to beat this system.
High stakes testing needs to be seriously downsized. I think one high stakes standardized test in middle school, and one in high school is plenty. And for those tests, we need to make sure the students have a stake in them as well, grades, graduation, something. Far too many students realize that they suffer no penalty for bad test scores, so they simply walk in, fill out the bubble answer sheet in whatever pattern they find pretty or amusing, and then walk out. Time for the students to have an actual stake in the outcome.
proud2BlibKansan
(96,793 posts)as part of our plan to regain accreditation.
The sticky point, of course is WHAT KIND of test we can plan to give every 30 days that will satisfy DESE.