Don’t buy the right-wing myth about Detroit
There's a lot of right wing spin on Detroit floating around the internet. Here's some good info:
As mythology goes, the specific story being crafted about Detroits bankruptcy is truly biblical more specifically, just like the fact-free mythology around the Greek financial collapse, it is copied right from the chapter in the conservative movements bible about how to distort crises for maximum political effect.
In the conservative telling of this particular parable, Detroit faces a fiscal emergency because high taxes supposedly drove a mass exodus from the city, and the supposedly unbridled greed of unions forced city leaders to make fiscally irresponsible pension promises to municipal employees. Written out of the tale is any serious analysis of macroeconomic shifts, international economic policy failures, the geography of recent recessions and unsustainable corporate welfare spending.
This is classic right-wing dogma the kind that employs selective storytelling to use a tragic event as a means to radical ends. In this case, the ends are big shocker! three of the conservative movements larger long-term economic priorities: 1) preservation of job-killing trade policies 2) immunity for corporations and 3) justification for budget policies that continue to profligately subsidize the rich.
Pretending Detroit and the NAFTA era are unrelated: The bait-and-switch on the first two objectives is fairly easy to see.
Detroit isnt just any old city it happens to be the biggest population center in the state hit the hardest by the rights corporate-written trade agenda. Indeed, according to the Economic Policy Institute, the state lost more jobs than any other from NAFTA (43,600, or 1 percent of its total job base) and lost another 79,500 jobs thanks to the China PNTR deal. And thats just two of many such trade pacts. Add to this the citys disproportionate reliance on American auto companies which made a series of horrific business decisions, and Detroit is a microcosmic cautionary tale about what happens when large corporations are allowed to write macro economic policy and dictate the economic future of an entire city.
If told, this cautionary tale would likely spark a discussion about revising current trade deals, regulations, public investment and industrial policy in general. That is, it would spark precisely the discussion that the conservative movement and the corporations that fund politicians dont want America to have. So the right works to make sure that discussion is short circuited by a narrative that focuses the Detroit story primarily on taxes and public pensions.
MORE:
http://www.salon.com/2013/07/23/dont_buy_the_right_wing_myth_about_detroit/