Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 01:53 PM Feb 2025

Will Musk/Trump kill Social Security and Medicare?

Who's going to stop them?

These issues have always been the "third rail" of politics. The Republican Party would never have done it because they knew it would end them. But today's Republican Party is a group of people who are living in fear and merely trying to keep what they have, and not displease the two kings.

What they've done over the past two weeks is mind-boggling. That was part of their plan and it's working.

The only way to fight back is through the court system. But what happens when court orders are simply ignored? After all, how many armies are controlled by judges?

We're in a terrible place at this moment, and no one seems to know how to put an end to it.

I know I'm going to get slammed as a "doom and gloom" person, Nonetheless, I'm only stating what I see happening.

So I ask, what are we going to do when Musk/Trump kill Social Security, Medicare and all the other safety net programs?

70 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Will Musk/Trump kill Social Security and Medicare? (Original Post) Cyrano Feb 2025 OP
They don't want to kill the programs. They want to profit on it. haele Feb 2025 #1
+1 leftstreet Feb 2025 #8
Fire Depts will probably be turned into that portrayed in "Fahrenheit 451" Cyrano Feb 2025 #30
Interesting. Can't burn eBooks but you can cut off internet access. erronis Feb 2025 #57
50/50 they will be killed. 90% chance there will be cuts or no more increases. Irish_Dem Feb 2025 #2
I see it as you do, although I think the odds are higher it will be killed altogether. LiberalLoner Feb 2025 #10
What do you think are the odds? Irish_Dem Feb 2025 #22
I would say 75% shut it down altogether, 25% they send checks only to MAGA. LiberalLoner Feb 2025 #26
Yes at least 50/50 federal pensions will be reduced. Irish_Dem Feb 2025 #31
💙 LiberalLoner Feb 2025 #53
The more people get, then the more they want misanthrope Feb 2025 #39
I agree, it's 50/50 with 90% probability of cuts Dave says Feb 2025 #17
until their asses are kicked out. GreenWave Feb 2025 #46
All he has to do is "accidentally" kick several blue states'-worth of enrollees out of various federal Wingus Dingus Feb 2025 #3
I'm already hearing complaints online and on talk shows about partial SSI checks. nt yaesu Feb 2025 #4
I'm wondering if Elon is Arger68 Feb 2025 #5
Somebody on here, I don't know who it was, valleyrogue Feb 2025 #16
Yeah, hard to say. Unfortunately, the Arger68 Feb 2025 #20
They probably think they can get away with it because they think they have the courts on their side, MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #21
Yep. A few of his Supreme Court "Justices" have Cyrano Feb 2025 #23
Your post is not doom/gloom delisen Feb 2025 #6
The goal of the ruling class is killing all public programs leftstreet Feb 2025 #7
No. Seniors make up a huge % of the GOP voting block. Lemons UK Feb 2025 #9
LOL, voting. As if that's a concern going forward. Wingus Dingus Feb 2025 #11
Exactly. LiberalLoner Feb 2025 #27
Which begs the question, why are we bothering to talk about this stuff. BannonsLiver Feb 2025 #42
Yeah, let's be silent while they put leashes on our necks. Cyrano Feb 2025 #43
He will privatize Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid gab13by13 Feb 2025 #12
Privatization has to be a goal of theirs FullySupportDems Feb 2025 #25
I gather that all of those who supposedly want to end PoindexterOglethorpe Feb 2025 #13
Musk's mother doesn't need Social Security or Medicare. She is rich. totodeinhere Feb 2025 #48
And I'm sure all of the neo-nazis that are being installed have been told they will be rewarded. erronis Feb 2025 #61
Actually, the check hasn't been in the mail for decades now. PoindexterOglethorpe Feb 2025 #66
Another thread to trash. valleyrogue Feb 2025 #14
Agreed. MarineCombatEngineer Feb 2025 #15
this is why we are here markie Feb 2025 #18
Wait now, hold up FullySupportDems Feb 2025 #29
So trash it. Is the announcement necessary? Scrivener7 Feb 2025 #34
Agreed. beaglelover Feb 2025 #36
I don't really care. If you don't like a topic, delete it don't read it. Fla Dem Feb 2025 #69
Absolutely Blue Full Moon Feb 2025 #19
Targeted Johnny2X2X Feb 2025 #24
They want to privatize it. Emile Feb 2025 #28
:"Privatize." A way of saying it goes into their own pockets. Cyrano Feb 2025 #32
"... no one seems to know how to put an end to it." Charging Triceratops Feb 2025 #33
What you say is true. However, Cyrano Feb 2025 #37
It's got to start somewhere ... Charging Triceratops Feb 2025 #40
If they mess at all with Social Security or Medicare... SnoopDog Feb 2025 #35
If he can, yes misanthrope Feb 2025 #38
If they want to see people with pitch forks and torches videohead5 Feb 2025 #41
Liberals / Democrats decided to unilaterally disarm, and thus they don't see us as a threat DSandra Feb 2025 #44
They won't "kill" Social Security and Medicare - they will seek to privatize both so they can LoisB Feb 2025 #45
Republicans have been salivating over the Medicare trust fund for decades dlk Feb 2025 #47
Musk And DOGE Are Criminals Baron2024 Feb 2025 #49
Stopping Musk Baron2024 Feb 2025 #50
No, but they will try to privatize them. Ocelot II Feb 2025 #51
social security Snark Twain Feb 2025 #52
you know... markie Feb 2025 #63
reduce the required deduction from paychecks yellowdogintexas Feb 2025 #65
A lot of their decisions do seem like they have no other purpose than to kill people off, so who the fuck Karasu Feb 2025 #54
The Pitch Will Be: Move your SS dollars into a 401k to reap higher interest. cer7711 Feb 2025 #55
Privatization Cirsium Feb 2025 #56
They'll cut it for future recipients. Figarosmom Feb 2025 #58
No. Senior vets have guns too and they sure know how to use them... Justice matters. Feb 2025 #59
MAGAS benefit from those programs too DemocratSinceBirth Feb 2025 #60
Even if Social Security is left LPBBEAR Feb 2025 #62
Doom & gloom berksdem Feb 2025 #64
Yeah Faux pas Feb 2025 #67
Trump and Musk will kill Social Security and Medicare Progressive dog Feb 2025 #68
No, they'll just steal the money. Hassler Feb 2025 #70

haele

(14,384 posts)
1. They don't want to kill the programs. They want to profit on it.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 01:56 PM
Feb 2025

I'm sure they're happy to keep the programs going on if they re-jigger it so they can skim off the top and only give us back what we put into it and no more.

Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
30. Fire Depts will probably be turned into that portrayed in "Fahrenheit 451"
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:42 PM
Feb 2025

Trump & Co. are in the process of bringing about some of our worst dystopian nightmares.

It's possible that they may decide burning books is easier than banning them.

erronis

(20,531 posts)
57. Interesting. Can't burn eBooks but you can cut off internet access.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:47 PM
Feb 2025

That's my biggest fear and there's no reason they won't do it.

Irish_Dem

(72,132 posts)
22. What do you think are the odds?
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:25 PM
Feb 2025

I was a bit conservative on my questimate based on the fact that
Trump will face a great deal of pushback if he kills Medicare and SS outright.

However if he does a slow death of SS and Medicare,
like turning it all over to crooked managed care companies
and private industry who will gradually reduce benefits then
I will raise the odds to 80 or 90%.

Once the managed care companies deny medical care to seniors,
they will start dying and SS will save money.

And once the billionaires get their hands on the IRAs, older people
will be more on the margins and that group has a higher death rate.
So more money saved on SS.

All this money of course goes to greedy billionaires and corrupt politicians.

LiberalLoner

(11,454 posts)
26. I would say 75% shut it down altogether, 25% they send checks only to MAGA.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:35 PM
Feb 2025

I’m also not optimistic about other federally funded pensions such as fed and military.

Irish_Dem

(72,132 posts)
31. Yes at least 50/50 federal pensions will be reduced.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:45 PM
Feb 2025

I think you are a bit high on the total shut down odds, but I would not be at all shocked if you are correct.

misanthrope

(8,926 posts)
39. The more people get, then the more they want
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:07 PM
Feb 2025

That is why absolute power corrupts absolutely.

GreenWave

(11,110 posts)
46. until their asses are kicked out.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:37 PM
Feb 2025

We should confiscate musk's wealth and make him repay plus interest.

Wingus Dingus

(9,173 posts)
3. All he has to do is "accidentally" kick several blue states'-worth of enrollees out of various federal
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 01:57 PM
Feb 2025

Last edited Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:39 PM - Edit history (1)

entitlement/benefit programs systems and then tell them they have to jump through all sorts of hoops to restore their status and payments and accounts--betting of course that many won't ever succeed because they're too disabled/disconnected/poor/technically challenged. I was up half the night thinking of what they're planning to do to the most vulnerable.

Arger68

(724 posts)
5. I'm wondering if Elon is
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:04 PM
Feb 2025

setting up something to skim a few percent off of every transaction for social security and medicare. He could rake in billions that way. Like instead of having the government administered payments, they run through a private corp owned by Elon, and probably trump also.

valleyrogue

(2,203 posts)
16. Somebody on here, I don't know who it was,
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:19 PM
Feb 2025

was speculating over the possibility Musk was putting in something that was something like PayPal, that he (and perhaps the likes of Thiel) would get a tiny amount of money for each transaction.

On the surface, it would make sense, but it raises more questions than it answers. Where is the transparency? Why not have security clearance? Moreover, why is Musk making proclamations (and Trump is also doing it) that are brazenly illegal?

Arger68

(724 posts)
20. Yeah, hard to say. Unfortunately, the
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:25 PM
Feb 2025

scenario where they are setting up something to pull percentage off of every transaction is probably the least nefarious thing they could be doing.

MarineCombatEngineer

(15,862 posts)
21. They probably think they can get away with it because they think they have the courts on their side,
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:25 PM
Feb 2025

but here's the thing, the USSC, with their insane immunity decision giving Been A Dick Donald almost 100% immunity to any crime he commits while CiC, has lead to this, what they fail to realize is that under that decision, Been A Dick can remove them, have them jailed or worse and it would be legal.


Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
23. Yep. A few of his Supreme Court "Justices" have
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:30 PM
Feb 2025

put there heads in a noose with that "Presidential Immunity" piece of insanity.

delisen

(7,106 posts)
6. Your post is not doom/gloom
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:04 PM
Feb 2025

You presented very rationally and poster are responding rationally.

Thanks for opening up discussion on this valid concern

leftstreet

(36,839 posts)
7. The goal of the ruling class is killing all public programs
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:08 PM
Feb 2025

They've been fighting back, eroding dollars and public trust in these programs since the New Deal

Everything will be privatized, and NO ONE will stop it

gab13by13

(28,772 posts)
12. He will privatize Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:14 PM
Feb 2025

Put the funds in his Sovreign Wealth Fund and launder the money.

No funds no social safety nets.

FullySupportDems

(355 posts)
25. Privatization has to be a goal of theirs
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:32 PM
Feb 2025

That way they can get their hands on the money, and say they "saved" the programs. If they talk a good enough game, I think the magas will fall for it too.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,996 posts)
13. I gather that all of those who supposedly want to end
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:14 PM
Feb 2025

Medicare and Social Security are orphans with no elderly mothers dependent on these programs.

Personally, if my only son were speaking out against these programs, I'd promptly move in with him, to remind him of what it used to be like.

My wonderful son is not that way at all. He's kind and generous and if I needed money, he could help me out.

totodeinhere

(13,637 posts)
48. Musk's mother doesn't need Social Security or Medicare. She is rich.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:00 PM
Feb 2025

And Trump's parents are dead.

erronis

(20,531 posts)
61. And I'm sure all of the neo-nazis that are being installed have been told they will be rewarded.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:54 PM
Feb 2025

"Don't worry about your ill grandmother - you'll get tons of tax-free bonuses if you just reprogram this Social Security system.
Trust me (trumpmusk) - we always honor our contracts......
And the check will be in the mail."
(Whoops the USPS is defunct.)

markie

(23,487 posts)
18. this is why we are here
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:22 PM
Feb 2025

to discuss, help, quell fears, commiserate, etc. I am sorry you are sick. Maybe rest and liquids would help

FullySupportDems

(355 posts)
29. Wait now, hold up
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:39 PM
Feb 2025

When people tried to discuss the possibility of Harris losing, they got similarly ridiculed. It happened quite a few times that I saw. That denial didn't help anyone deal with the loss.

So I think it's wrong to shut down this discussion. The radical right has wanted to "do something" with Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid for many years. I think it's pretty likely they're mulling around what they can do now. I value what others think about it.

Fla Dem

(26,868 posts)
69. I don't really care. If you don't like a topic, delete it don't read it.
Wed Feb 5, 2025, 12:50 PM
Feb 2025

Why do you feel you have to stifle other DUer's opinions and concerns. That's why we're here.

Johnny2X2X

(23,036 posts)
24. Targeted
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:30 PM
Feb 2025

They are trying to kill the parts of it that benefits Democrats. It will be targeted, just watch.

 
33. "... no one seems to know how to put an end to it."
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 02:51 PM
Feb 2025

We know. We just can't say it here or anywhere else online.

You don't stop a tyrant with legislation, protest marches or a strongly worded letter.

Cyrano

(15,388 posts)
37. What you say is true. However,
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:04 PM
Feb 2025

we are totally unprepared for what you are implying. They are succeeding in attaining their goals while we are still trying to put on our pants.

"Preparation is the key to success."

 
40. It's got to start somewhere ...
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:10 PM
Feb 2025

The kindling is there. It needs a hot, hot spark. We need to make the '60s look like a church picnic. Hell, we need to make Fort Sumter look like a church picnic.
All the warning lights are flashing red and we're looking for useless congresspeople to act. Ain't gonna happen, kids.

SnoopDog

(2,684 posts)
35. If they mess at all with Social Security or Medicare...
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:01 PM
Feb 2025

...then it will be time for a revolution.

I am not a tough guy and I am retired, but I will not let them take what is mine and ours...somehow...

videohead5

(2,696 posts)
41. If they want to see people with pitch forks and torches
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:11 PM
Feb 2025

At the gates of the White House, let them try.

DSandra

(1,626 posts)
44. Liberals / Democrats decided to unilaterally disarm, and thus they don't see us as a threat
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:27 PM
Feb 2025

Conservatives are far more likely to own a gun than liberals (45% to 16%)

This, since they own most of the guns (as well as more extensively train with them), conservatives have this country for themselves.

LoisB

(11,054 posts)
45. They won't "kill" Social Security and Medicare - they will seek to privatize both so they can
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:33 PM
Feb 2025

get their hands on that money.

dlk

(12,755 posts)
47. Republicans have been salivating over the Medicare trust fund for decades
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 03:55 PM
Feb 2025

They can’t wait to raid it.

 

Baron2024

(1,492 posts)
49. Musk And DOGE Are Criminals
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:04 PM
Feb 2025

Musk and his DOGE Agents are actually the ones guilty of committing a crime. Their "authority" is unconstitutional. They are guilty of Obstruction of Government Operations.

Their attempts to freeze Federal funds is illegal as well. The Executive Branch does not have the legal right to freeze funds that have been authorized by the Congress. They also have no legal right to dissolve an Agency created by Congress.

This is a flagrant violation of the Constitution and the Separation of Powers. These people are domestic enemies of the Constitution and everyone that has taken an Oath to defend the Constitution must take action against these traitors and criminals.

It seems clear that these fascists will now weaponize the criminal justice system in DC and will drum up false and spurious charges against anyone that tries to stand against their authoritarian takeover of OUR government. This is an attempted deathblow to our Democracy. I do not believe that the People will stand for it. There will be an uprising of millions.

 

Baron2024

(1,492 posts)
50. Stopping Musk
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:06 PM
Feb 2025

Musk and DOGE seizing the Treasury payment system is illegal and unconstitutional. It is a long shot, but perhaps Federal law enforcement could retake control of the Treasury payment system from Musk and his DOGE Agents.

If a Judge rules again that freezing federal money is unconstitutional then the FBI and other Federal law enforcement agencies would have a legal basis for retaking the Treasury payment system. They must be loyal to their oaths to defend the Constitution, not to any illegal orders to support an unconstitutional action by Musk. Hopefully these Federal Agents would be loyal to their oaths to defend the Constitution and not to those who are in violation of the Constitution.

The Federal Agents could restore control of the payment system to the civil service, who could then lawfully restart the federal payments. If Musk and DOGE stop the federal payments (no Social Security payments, no paychecks to federal employees, etc.) and this was ruled unconstitutional by another Judge then the FBI and other federal law enforcement would be able to legally seize the payment system back from DOGE. The loyalties of Federal Agents must be to the Constitution, not to Dictators who are flagrantly violating the Constitution.

Snark Twain

(104 posts)
52. social security
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:13 PM
Feb 2025

they will not kill it, it is an established and reliable process by which they can collect money - but they will definitely raid it in many different ways

markie

(23,487 posts)
63. you know...
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:58 PM
Feb 2025

yes, it is the reason it doesn't seem solvent... it is used as a fungible money... the republicans have delighted in calling it an entitlement as if it's a negative... SS would be fine if we didn't end the tax at $168,000+ ....or get creative in other ways

yellowdogintexas

(23,369 posts)
65. reduce the required deduction from paychecks
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 05:22 PM
Feb 2025

Dollars to donuts that is what half the folks who cheered over "no taxes on Social Security" thought would happen.

By reducing the deduction, the fund goes dry

Increasing the eligibility age for Medicare and SS

Lowering the 'cap' on deductions from our checks. I think the stop point now is $145,000. Once your income reaches that point there will be no more deductions for the rest of the year. I think they may cut that down to a lower level.

It should actually be raised, which would keep the SS solvent. Bernie (along with others) have been ranting about this for years.
The last proposal was to have a gap between the current level and maybe $300,000 then increase it with no ceiling. Medicare does not have the cap.

'offering' us the option of moving it into an IRA would be the other thing they want. Those brokers etc make money off these funds and absorb the cost of processing our SS benefits.

with Medicare, we would all be put into Managed Care Plans.

Karasu

(1,570 posts)
54. A lot of their decisions do seem like they have no other purpose than to kill people off, so who the fuck
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:27 PM
Feb 2025

even knows anymore.

cer7711

(563 posts)
55. The Pitch Will Be: Move your SS dollars into a 401k to reap higher interest.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:27 PM
Feb 2025

And when those 401ks crater... too bad; so sad.
Money gone.

Note: SS was never intended to be a high-interest gambling option. It was establisshed (and is self-funded) to ensure a person against the ravages of old-age poverty and disease.

Cirsium

(2,732 posts)
56. Privatization
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:28 PM
Feb 2025

Privatization is the goal, which will kill Social Security and Medicare but do it in such a way that is not obvious to people. So much privatization has already flown under the radar.

Militant mass organizing and popular resistance are the only options we have now.

Figarosmom

(6,760 posts)
58. They'll cut it for future recipients.
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:50 PM
Feb 2025

But they don't want to crash markets so they need that money in circulation.

We'd end up moving in with our kids and all those retirement villages would go broke. As would all the other elderly related businesses. Nursing homes, care facilities, transportation co.,etc. That's too much of the economy.

A lot of right wingers get rich off the elderly and bilking Medicare (Ala Rick Scott),

Justice matters.

(8,610 posts)
59. No. Senior vets have guns too and they sure know how to use them...
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:52 PM
Feb 2025

The two mafia kings better know that or they could end on the deep end of a golf course...

A Civil War could ensue though.

LPBBEAR

(553 posts)
62. Even if Social Security is left
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 04:55 PM
Feb 2025

mostly intact all it takes to erase someone who is deemed too loud in protest regarding Trump and Musk's illegal actions is just a little "oopsie" on the keyboard.

"I'm sorry Sir, we have no records of you ever having Social Security. Where did you say you were born?"

After all...they do have complete access to the Treasury computer systems.

Can you say "oopsie"?

berksdem

(825 posts)
64. Doom & gloom
Tue Feb 4, 2025, 05:06 PM
Feb 2025

No, for a lack of better phrasing - we are fucked. I am not sure we will ever come back from what is taking place. Our country has been hijacked and I fear there are no guardrails.

Progressive dog

(7,499 posts)
68. Trump and Musk will kill Social Security and Medicare
Wed Feb 5, 2025, 11:47 AM
Feb 2025

but they have to get rid of the Constitution first.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Will Musk/Trump kill Soci...