General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsNew data disproves a big concern about Covid-19 lockdowns
Critics of lockdowns claimed they would cause a spike in suicides. That didnt happen.
By German Lopez @germanrlopez [email protected] Apr 6, 2021, 8:40am EDT
Last year, as then-President Donald Trump railed against Covid-19 lockdowns and called on states to reopen their economies, he claimed the shutdowns would lead to a spike in suicides: Youre going to lose more people by putting a country into a massive recession or depression. Youre going to lose people. Youre going to have suicides by the thousands.
But new data suggests that the number of suicides actually decreased in the US last year. According to the National Center for Health Statistics, suicides totaled fewer than 45,000 in 2020, down from about 47,500 in 2019 and more than 48,000 in 2018.
So far, this seems to be true globally. England saw no increase in suicides in the aftermath of lockdowns, Louis Appleby, a researcher on suicide and self-harm at the University of Manchester, wrote for the medical journal BMJ. The same seems to be true in other nations, including Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Norway, Peru, and Sweden, based on data for the first few months of lockdowns around the globe.
Our conclusions at this stage, however, should be cautious. These are early findings and may change, Appleby wrote in BMJ. Beneath the overall numbers there may be variations between demographic groups or geographical areas. After all, the impact of covid-19 itself has not been uniform across communities.
more
https://www.vox.com/2021/4/6/22368210/suicides-covid-19-coronavirus-lockdown-2020
tanyev
(42,544 posts)That's something someone else told him to say.
underpants
(182,750 posts)I thought that it seemed strange. In general but that they went directly to that.
underpants
(182,750 posts)I know of several kids that are really struggling with this. Mostly a lack of social contact - Zooming school isnt doing it.
jimfields33
(15,763 posts)Im sure most students will be back on track in no time. Kids are very resilient.
Silent3
(15,190 posts)A heard about a study recently that showed many introverts moods improved during the lockdown. Probably due to the relief of not being forced to socialize more than they really want to.
underpants
(182,750 posts)Ima little of both but I found the lockdown to be pretty calming to me. I in no way mean to be dismissive of mental health issues that have arisen. If anything the acknowledgement and discussion of mental health may be something good coming out of all this.
I looked on it as a sit back at the beach or campground to relax and take stock. I quit smoking hold it CRAP it was a year ago today. WOW its April 6th again. I have been back into and out of the office since July so I havent really been locked in like some people.
Midnight Writer
(21,741 posts)However, I have talked with people who are climbing the walls. It seems to put quite an emotional burden on them to feel isolated.
I suspect there will be long term societal changes when things "get back to normal".
Johnny2X2X
(19,035 posts)Kids especially, but people have also been spending more time with their families, so I surmise that this led to people with issues being more able to get the help they need.
But as others have pointe out, Republicans care zero about the mental health of children, it was just a way for them to go along with Trump on opening the schools.
Claire Oh Nette
(2,636 posts)When Republicans began showing faux concern for the increase in suicides, they never offered any evidence, just speculation.
They showed zero interest in increased access to mental health care or counseling. They only pointed to suicide among children to convince people to open schools so parents could go back to work to make the economy look good for the former guy's re-election.
If they had truly been concerned, they'd have worn masks and helped keep the curve as flat as possible to help us get back to "normal" sooner.
If the GOP says it, count on studies to show the opposite.
In terms of kids being "behind," all kids globally have faced disrupted school years. Our kids are no more "behind" than any other kids. There's not a bus schedule to keep. Parents concerned about their child falling behind can alleviate a lot of worry by simply having their kid read for twenty minutes every day. Out loud to a younger sibling is better, but that's enough.
Johnny2X2X
(19,035 posts)In threads about this subject, I'd point to the data that showed that suicides were down so far in 2020 and get ignored.
Nothing matters to Republicans except pretending Trump is right.
FakeNoose
(32,626 posts)brewens
(13,567 posts)tactic to get people to rebel against lockdowns.
Johnny2X2X
(19,035 posts)It was a prime talking point for 9 months for the right even when we had data throughout the year suggesting suicides were falling.
Doesn't mean there weren't more mental health issues, just means that maybe people were able to get more help. Great news.
panader0
(25,816 posts)no studies were needed to prove it wrong.