HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Rebuild, Retrain, Rethink...

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 11:22 AM

Rebuild, Retrain, Rethink the Police. Reframing the message.

Early on I was a proponent of defund the police. As I defended my position, I found myself coming back to 3 core principles each time and decided that I was not a proponent of defund the police and I have wanted to try and reframe the message. I'll preface this all by saying, I am not an expert in police reform, I am just a concerned citizen. There are others, significantly more informed than myself, who have worked on Reform, Restructuring and Rebuilding the Police and LEAs for quite some time and I pulled some of their ideas to write this outline. I hope it has some merit and is considered for what it is, a discussion tool.

The message hinges on 3 core principles. Rebuild the police. Retrain all police. Rethink community policing.

Rebuild from the ground up.
This is the most difficult piece of the puzzle. Policing in America has undergone 3 separate rebuilding/restructuring phases (see link). The United States has a very complex policing system that is actually a combination of decentralized, centralized and Community Problem Solving or COPS.

https://www.flsheriffs.org/uploads/DecentralizationProsAndConsByTAman.pdf

Some form of decentralization is most likely the best option as it makes for a more nimble and easily managed workforce, however strict enforcement of the Commander's Intent (CI is the overall mission statement that allows for decentralized leaders and personnel to operate and make decisions that follow the commander's intent for the mission as set forth in the CI) needs to be enforced and the initial Commander's Intent needs to follow community guidelines. I would like to suggest an overarching guidepost over the Commander's Intent with the Community's Mission Statement, to better align with the current trend towards a more community centric approach to policing, while still maintaining the needed structure to handle the complexity of modern departmental structure. Using this method, during large scale missions, such as crowd control, the Commander would use the guidelines set forth in the Community's Mission Statement to help formulate the CI for the mission. The CMS would be highly scrutinized and developed by the individual communities with input from all sectors of an oversight council composed of community leaders and social scientists/workers. The CMS should be revisited each year to see if updates to the mandate need to be made.

The CMS needs to be further studied with the goal to be a more compassionate and community oriented approach, while addressing the need for an easily identifiable mandate to police compassionately with a solid focus on deescalation. Large cities will be the hardest systems to redefine as they police many different communities and will require much thought in regards to rebuilding/restructuring as well as redefining how the CMS is enacted at every level.

Funding of police departments should be looked at as well. Somehow, funding needs to be taken out of the equation. A problem that exists is that in some areas, is either not enough funding or improper funding goals exist and that leads to taxation by policing to supplement police budgets. Strict fiduciary controls on Police objectives and operational parameters will reduce the need to have police patrols set up ticket mills and other revenue generators that do nothing more than exacerbate community frustrations. Gone should be the days of police that have ticket quotas. I do not have all the answers for this or other problems, this should act as merely a jump off point for discussion.

Retrain all police using latest techniques on deescalation and compassionate policing.

This component is fairly straight forward and should be easier to implement than the first piece. Instead of focusing on creating warriors who are fighting an enemy to be put down, focus should be on learning the CMS and its core principles to help guide officers during missions as they implement their CI, situational deescalation and compassionate policing wherever possible. Of course in areas where there is high violent crime other training may be required, however, by analyzing the circumstances surrounding those areas, perhaps other answers within the community can be found to reduce crime. Supporting social services, funding infrastructure, job programs and housing initiatives, supporting local schools and education programs, funding after school services for youths, etc., these areas can see a marked decrease in reliance on criminal activity for sustenance (this area has overlap with Rebuild/Rethink policing). Yearly re-training in any updates to the CMS and the latest deescalation techniques and compassionate policing policies should be mandatory. Re-certification should be part of the process.

Rethink community policing and the interaction with the people.

We need to rethink how police interact with the community and the people they police. Far in the past, foot patrols gave the police presence in the communities and police were often members of the communities they policed. However, that did present some problems in that police were easily corrupted by their friends and local political leaders. There needs to be a new paradigm in local policing policies and working in conjunction with local social services to better interact with the community. New 911 guidelines to better disperse calls to appropriate social service agencies or add social service agents to police calls to assist officers in their duty are some ideas, but nothing concrete at this point in time. There is overlap with Rebuild/Retrain the Police in that compassionate policing and deescalation techniques are valuable assets when dealing with non-traditional emergencies and planning for these during the core fiduciary restructuring of the police departments would be key to success along with rethinking how to develop a living cohesive community based CMS.

Well, this is a working thesis and not fully fleshed out by any means. Again, let me restate, I do not have all the answers for this or other problems, this OP is only meant to act as merely a jump off point for discussion and possible help in reframing the message. Thank you for taking the time to read this little screed, hopefully it will lead to some more discussion.

Be well, cayugafalls.

7 replies, 378 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 7 replies Author Time Post
Reply Rebuild, Retrain, Rethink the Police. Reframing the message. (Original post)
cayugafalls Jul 27 OP
MacKasey Jul 27 #1
cayugafalls Jul 27 #2
MacKasey Jul 27 #3
cayugafalls Jul 27 #4
WhiskeyGrinder Jul 27 #5
cayugafalls Jul 27 #6
MacKasey Jul 28 #7

Response to cayugafalls (Original post)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 11:30 AM

1. Great idea

Like the use of the R's

You should get it to Biden's people.
Goes with the Build Back Better meme

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to MacKasey (Reply #1)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 02:21 PM

2. Thank you.

I appreciate the feedback.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to cayugafalls (Original post)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 07:20 PM

3. More people need to read this

Kick

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to MacKasey (Reply #3)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 09:44 PM

4. Thank you for the kick.

I really appreciate your encouragement. It means a lot.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to cayugafalls (Original post)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 09:57 PM

5. Community and compassionate policing are still policing.

They results in a flow of information that goes only one way: Toward oppressive power. For more information, check out mpd150's outstanding resource here.

The entire idea of a police force is about oppression. As such, reform simply extends oppression by obscuring it and making it more acceptable.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to WhiskeyGrinder (Reply #5)

Mon Jul 27, 2020, 10:48 PM

6. I agree with a lot of what is said on that site. Thanks for the link.

In fact I mention redirecting funding from the police force towards rebuilding the communities infrastructure and creating more jobs, social services, housing, education, redirecting 911 emergency calls to appropriately dispatch the proper services, etc. With all that, you still have to get from present day to future somehow. Abolition will not happen in one fell swoop, even MPD150 states that quite clearly. It is why I was trying to reframe the message of simply defunding or abolishing the police. It has to happen overtime.

For a great part of my career I dealt with change management and you can't just force dramatic change on people overnight without a great deal of push back and anxiety. The easiest way to get buy in is to handle change incrementally and get buy in from the change owners, in this case the community at large. Small changes over time with the end goal always in mind.

I think the only reason that there is a hard push back for abolishing the police is the framing of the message. It is too harsh and anxiety inducing for the average person to comprehend. Their brain goes into tilt mode and focuses only on the word and not the overall objective and results.

I've seen it time and time again in manufacturing system when change was forced on workers who had systems in place for decades and replacement was not something that could be forced on them. When you tried to force change to quickly, you got death threats, accidents and equipment destruction. However, if you put change in slowly with lots of customer feedback and buy in, the change was so incremental that it was accepted and nurtured rather than shamed and destroyed.

I am all for removing the oppressive power structure of the current police forces. I agree with MPD150 that it will take time and redistribution of current police budgets to social services, community programs, education, housing -- while rebuilding the current policing system from the ground up to handle lower officer counts, reduced budgets, demilitarized units, psychological evaluations, yearly restructuring mandates based on yearly budget cuts, etc. All I am proposing is that during the transitional period, retraining, and rethinking go hand in hand during the process of systemic rebuilding. Yearly evaluations controlled by outside oversight and re-certification in community guidelines is all a part of the process to at least make the transition as humane as possible.

Thank you for the chance at discussion.

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink


Response to cayugafalls (Original post)

Tue Jul 28, 2020, 11:27 AM

7. It's Tuesday morning and I'm kicking it up

Hey people let's get some recommendations

More discussions

Two kicks

Reply to this post

Back to top Alert abuse Link here Permalink

Reply to this thread