MSNBC: Do you think the 911 calls made on Sept. 11 should be made public?

[sabra]

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12098729/

Do you think the 911 calls made on Sept. 11 should be made public in their entirety?

* 2198 responses

Yes60%

No 31%

Not sure 10%

[helderheid]

1. done k and r

[annofark]

2. NO

Why open old wounds. what good does it do? And I don't think anyone should be blamed. No one knew what was going on.

[Thorandmjolnir]

5. Well, considering

the Government want to put a man to death for 9-11, I think someone claims to know what was going on.

[Atman]

8. Oh, puhleeze!

We've been living with an old festering open wound for five years now. Every single freakin' time a plane goes down, the FCC releases the black box tapes. But on this one, suddenly it's too sensitive. Bullshit. It is nothing more than more coverup for the massive fuck-ups that took place.

[jus_the_facts]

12. Welcome to DU...please read around the 9/11 forum.....

:hi:....a couple definitions...MIHOP..made it happen on purpose...LIHOP..let it happen on purpose....the Pentagon KNEW and didn't scramble jets to intercept the planes on 9/11 as per standard military procedure before and since. :think:

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=102&topic_id=629950

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=show_topics&forum=125

[Zhade]

19. No one knew?

You mean, like, first responders? Or are you trying to say that the criminals in the White House, who were warned long before 9/11 that attacks were coming, didn't know?

Hope it's the former, because the latter is not only laughable, it's a fucking lie.

[stillcool]

3. done n/t

[Beware the Beast Man]

4. I'm not too keen on it.

I really don't think they should be public, and I sure as hell wouldn't want to hear any of them. Let the victim's families hear them if they want, and leave them in peace.

[mtnester]

6. If the families want to hear them in private, that is OK by me

otherwise, I am not sure of the public value..although I am guessing that the Bush admin would love nothing more than to make the public right now....they need to sharpen up the fear factor of us unrully citizens.

[gardenista]

22. Exactly. Those who promote public airing of these tapes will regret

doing so, once they see the planned effect, and the way in which it will benefit BushCo.

[Squeech]

7. No

I think the August 6 2001 Presidential Daily Briefing should be made public.

[DoYouEverWonder]

9. I'd much rather hear the cock pit recorders

and see the data from the black boxes on the planes. That would be much more useful.

[TomInTib]

16. There were no black boxes or cockpit recorders recovered

according to the official version.

Those four crashes are the only instances of unrecovered boxes in the history of land crashes in the US.
And that includes the jet that went down in the Everglades.

I find that really interesting, somehow.

[DoYouEverWonder]

21. Supposedly some of the black boxes were recovered

I don't have the links off hand (at work) but they definitely recovered black boxes at the Pentagon and in PA. Also, they allowed the Flight 93 families to listen to the cockpit recordings so we know those were recovered.

[rfranklin]

10. No, I want the real story of 9/11 to be made public...

and I want those who are responsible to be brought to trial and executed if found guilty.


These tapes are another distraction.

[LSparkle]

13. Me too

They're being released to provoke an emotional response that (they probably hope) will rally the lemmings back to *'s side.

[laruemtt]

11. like someone else mentioned i think

yesterday, they should play them on a split screen with * sitting there in that classroom reading "my pet goat." powerful.

[tridim]

14. I want to see the security tapes that captured the Pentagon "plane crash"

The security video tapes that were confiscated from private businesses by the Feds before anyone could see them.

Show us those and the entire 9/11 plan/coverup will be exposed.

[PVK]

15. Yes. n/t

[0007]

17. Absolutly. And those that say no, don't have to listen.

[DinahMoeHum]

18. The families involved should have been informed before this

was made public; and they should have been allowed to hear it in private before the public heard it.

:evilfrown:

[gardenista]

20. Absolutely not. What good is this going to do?

It will simply re-open the wounds of people who lost their loved ones.

It would be much more helpful to declassify all of the warnings of passenger liners being flown into large buildings; the warnings that Bin Laden was poised to strike the WTC again; and the truth about the "exercises" that were taking place that day. THAT might make a difference.

[SmokingJacket]

23. Made public, but not broadcast.

Guess I'm saying I don't want to accidentally hear it on CNN when I'm trying to catch the weather, but I do think if there's info in there, it should be available.

[Suziq]

24. Chris Hanley's Parents are Great!

I watched Chris Hanley's parents on a local New York news channel. They gave permission to release their son's 911 call. Their reason - they are tired of all the secrecy of our government!

I gave Chris's parents a huge :thumbsup: Hearing their son was extremely hard for them. Brought tears to my eyes.

[harpo]

25. I not only want them made public, I'll host them...

the TRUTH needs to be heard....not just read.

[NJ Democrats]

26. Yes, in their entirety!

No editing, like they are doing!!!
Do you think the 911 calls made on Sept. 11 should be made public in their entirety? * 4613 responses


Yes
57%

No
33%

Not sure
10%

[msgadget]

27. Available to families who desire to hear them, for litigation and possibly

archived for history but I have no desire to hear them played on the evening news. It just doesn't serve any purpose, doesn't resolve anything (for me).

[Kellanved]

28. Absolutely not

For the families and as historic documentation maybe, but certainly not for broad public. No good can come from publishing them.

[Polly Hennessey]

29. Tapes

Of course they should be heard. We all have a right to know what those people went through and how the calls were handled. There is too much secrecy surrounding 9-11. I have read some of the transcripts and even that is painful, but I was really disturbed by the dispatchers and their failures. More than anything it reminded me of the horror and helplessness that the people in the Towers felt. Don't ever be afraid to hear the truth. Now about the Pentagon------?

[bigwillq]

30. Done

Do you think the 911 calls made on Sept. 11 should be made public in their entirety? * 6049 responses


Yes
54%

No
36%

Not sure
10%