Red Sox Fans... Nomar or A-Rod?

[maveric]

http://cbs.sportsline.com/mlb/story/6899056

Sox are considering trading Nomar back to his SoCal roots in LA or Anaheim and then taking on the big-money that A-Rod is getting.

Please keep Nomah! He's been in Boston since day one and is beloved there.

What do ya think guys? Who would you rather see playing shortstop in Fenway?

[Don_G]

1. Steve Bartman

:evilgrin:

[maveric]

2. He wouldnt last a week in Boston!

We have our Buckner!

[Old and In the Way]

3. Agreed.....

I can maybe see a Manny for A-Rod trade, but leave Nomar alone!

[MaineDem]

4. If the Sox get A-Rod, Nomar is gone

Sad to see, though. I'd like to see Theo extend Nomar's contract and then deal Manny somewhere for a LH pitcher. But Theo hasn't consulted me on this one.

Good amount of snow out there, no? Stay warm.

[kanrok]

9. Where you gonna put Nomar if A-Rod comes over?

[ProudGerman]

10. A smart person would put Nomar at short

Among the trio of future HoF shortstops playing now, I've always thought Nomar to be the best of the three. At least defensively.

Maybe A-rod can play third.

[fameless]

13. I disagree

There is a reason why A-Rod has won the Gold Glove the past two years.

[Forkboy]

5. I like Nomar a lot

but I'd make that trade.

Manny needs to go more than anyone though.He's a space cadet,and not even a fun one like Bill Lee was :)

[joeybee12]

6. Nomar, Nomar, Nomar! This trade is sheer insanity!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Braden]

7. I like nomar but the deal looks like its picking up steam

If they can deal Ramirez its probably for the better. I hate saying that but its true.

[SiobhanClancy]

8. I know I'm probably being sentimental...

but I want Nomie to stay!:)

[WilliamPitt]

11. A-Rod

[fameless]

12. A-Rod

Though he is one of the better players in the league, Nomar doesn't have it anymore. A-Rod is that much better than him anyway. Get A-Rod, then trade Nomar to the Dodgers for someone who we can turn around and trade to get a LF, possibly JD Drew.