Arizona tribes oppose English as official language

[Kire]

Arizona tribes oppose English as official language

January 21, 2005
by: Brenda Norrell / Indian Country Today

PHOENIX - Arizona Indian tribal leaders opposed new legislation that would make English the official state language, as they struggled for solutions to meet the needs of economic development and housing, during the 10th annual Indian Nations and Tribes Legislative Day.

Arizona Indian women leaders received standing ovations at the Arizona State Capitol when they objected to the proposal to make English the state language.

''In plain English, sir, we don't like it, and we don't want it,'' said San Carlos Apache Chairwoman Kathy Kitcheyan. ''As the first Americans, we never asked anyone to speak a specific language.''

Tohono O'odham Chairperson Vivian Juan-Saunders said the proposal was reminiscent of BIA boarding schools, where Indian children were verbally and physically abused for speaking their Native languages.

Juan-Saunders, also president of the Inter-Tribal Council of Arizona, said Navajos and other American Indian soldiers used their Native languages as unbreakable codes to pass messages, which helped win World War II.

House Concurrent Resolution 2030, being considered during this year's legislative session, would allow Arizona voters to declare English the official state language.

More: http://www.indiancountry.com/content.cfm?feature=yes&id=1096410213

[Lydia Leftcoast]

1. English is not endangered anywhere in the U.S., but

most Native American languages are on life support, if not extinct. One of the major culprits was the longstanding practice of taking Native children to distant, multi-tribal boarding schools at an early age and not letting them go home for years at a time.

I can see why the tribes are upset about this.

[Astarho]

2. I've met a few code talkers

who are quick to point out that the language they were beaten for speaking in schools was what saved us in WWII. Hopi is only spoken by about half the population (None of the Hopi I've met speak it).

But good news is that the Yavapai have recently started a language course.

[Maestro]

3. Yep! no need for English as the official language.

It doesn't need protecting. What needs protecting are the indigenous languages of the world.

[manic expression]

4. They are exterminating a culture

Genocide is what I would call it. Absolutely disgusting.