Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

One question for each of us...no, just one question.

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (Through 2005) Donate to DU
 
OpSomBlood Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Fri Apr-16-04 04:43 PM
Original message
One question for each of us...no, just one question.
Do any of you have the transcript of this little exchange from the Q&A with Bush and Blair that Randi is playing today?

Thanks.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
OpSomBlood Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Fri Apr-16-04 08:12 PM
Response to Original message
1. Kick
Kick.
Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
LittleApple81 Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Fri Apr-16-04 08:15 PM
Response to Original message
2. From the WH page:
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/04/20040416-4.html

snip...
PRESIDENT BUSH: Mr. Prime Minister, thank you, sir. We will take three questions a side, and so why don't you ask one question to each of us.

You can start, Mr. Hunt.

Q Thank you, Mr. President. Mr. President, did you ask Secretary Rumsfeld to draw up war plans against Iraq in November, 2001, just as the military action was getting underway in Afghanistan? Why couldn't Iraq wait?

And Mr. Prime Minister --

PRESIDENT BUSH: No, I thought -- one question apiece. Not one question or one question apiece.

You know, I can't remember exact dates that far back. I do know this, that at a key meeting at Camp David, the subject of Iraq -- this was on September the --

Q Fifteenth.

PRESIDENT BUSH: Fifteenth. We had been attacked on September the 11th, obviously. On the 15th, we sat down, I sat down with my national security team to discuss the response, and the subject of Iraq came up. And I said as plainly as I possibly could, we'll focus on Afghanistan. That's where we'll focus. I explained this to the Prime Minister, as well, in a subsequent meeting. That was about the 20th of September, I think, we came and talked about the response we were going to take in dealing with the attacks on our country.

So I don't remember in times of -- what was being developed or not being developed. But I do know that it was Afghanistan that was on my mind. And I didn't really start focusing on Iraq until later on, particularly about the time I started going to the United Nations with this message. To the United Nations, I said, let's uphold the demands of the world, finally, after decades of -- after a decade of threats to Saddam -- you know, if you don't do this, this will happen -- why don't we finally just say something that we mean?

And it was at that point in time, when a President steps up in front of the United Nations and you say, either take care of business or we, others will, you better mean it. And I meant it when I went up in front of the United Nations at that point in time.

Q I was asking you about November.

PRESIDENT BUSH: I can't remember. I'd have to get back to you about a specific moment. But I can tell you, in September, I said, let us focus on Afghanistan, let us make sure that we do this job and do it well.

Q Prime Minister, the -- Prime Minister, the handover of power is just, what, 80 days away, and yet the killing is going on, there is still kidnapping. Do you accept it was an error not to involve the U.N. much more early in the process?

And I wonder, Mr. President, if I could ask you if that's a mistake that you're prepared to accept, as well?

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: First of all, we have been involving the U.N. throughout. And, actually, the work that Mr. Brahimi has done, we've both made it clear that we welcome. And I can tell you from the conversations I had with Kofi Annan last night that I think there's a common approach. Obviously, we have to discuss the details in particular with the Iraqi groups, themselves, as to how this political transition is to come about.

But let me just say one thing to you about the violence and the killing there. There was always going to be resistance to transition to democracy. And, in particular, as the date for transition to a sovereign Iraqi government that's going to be broad based as that date draws near. There's going to be violence. There's going to be violence from people who don't want an Iraqi future different from the past. And I don't think we should be surprised at this. There will be religious fanatics, outside terrorists, former Saddam people who will come together and they will kill innocent civilians, they will try and kill coalition troops, they will kill Iraqis -- they'll kill anyone who stands in their way. And the reason that they're doing this is because they don't want a democratic Iraq.

Now, what is the response of ourselves, and, indeed, the whole of the world community, regardless of whether you support the war in Iraq or not? The response has got to be that we hold firm, we keep to the political transition, we keep to the timetable, and we do everything we humanly can to build up the capability of the Iraqis to take control of their own affairs. Because in Iraq there will be all sorts of people -- that vast majority of people out there who aren't terrorists, who don't want to kill people, who want to lead an ordinary life, raise their family, have a job, have some prosperity, have some freedom -- as other people in the world do -- and they will be sitting there, watching and waiting for one thing: do we have the will and the determination to finish the job.

And what you're hearing from myself and the President of the United States is, we will stay there and we will get the job done, because that's what we promised to do. And we will continue until it's finished.

PRESIDENT BUSH: Steve.

Q Hosni Mubarak is saying the new U.S. policy on the West Bank could escalate violence. How do you respond to his concerns?

PRESIDENT BUSH: I think this is a fantastic opportunity -- the fact that Ariel Sharon said, we're going to withdraw from territory, is an historic moment. And it creates a chance for the world to come together to help develop a Palestinian state based upon a solid foundation, a foundation where the institutions are bigger than the people, just like our respective governments are founded.

It's a chance to provide a framework for international aid that will help a Palestinian economy grow. It's a chance for people to come together to work on measures that will enable people to live in peace -- security measures. This is an historic moment, and I think people need to view it as such, and seize the moment, and help a Palestinian state become a reality, a Palestinian state that can live at peace with its neighbors.

And, you know, there's a lot of talk about the final status discussions. And that's all and good. The problem is, is people, by doing so, don't pay attention to the moment. It's a moment we've got to seize. The final status discussions will become a lot plainer -- and by the way, we're not going to prejudge the final status discussions. But the answers will become a lot plainer once there is a peaceful state that's committed to fighting off terror and a state that's capable of providing hope for its people.

I think it's possible. And the Prime Minister and I have spent a lot of time on this subject. And I'm not going to put words in his mouth, but he thinks it's possible. And we look forward to working together to make it possible. But it's going to require a commitment by the Palestinian people to find leadership that is committed to peace and hope. And it's going to require a commitment by people in the neighborhood to support the emergence of a state.

This is an historic moment, and I appreciate the Prime Minister of Israel coming here to announce it. And we intend to seize the moment and to take advantage of an opportunity.

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: I think what's happening here is that despite all the reaction -- some of which I think it's expected and natural that always rebound around the world when a statement like this is made -- let's just go back and see what the opportunity is here. If there is disengagement by Israel from the Gaza and from parts of the West Bank, that then gives us the opportunity -- and this is where the international community has got to play its role -- that gives us the opportunity to help the Palestinian Authority with the economic, the political and the security measures they take, and they need to take, in order to get to the point where the concept of a viable Palestinian state becomes a real possibility -- not something that's put in a document and talked about, or discussed in resolutions or speeches, but actually is a real, live possibility. And I see this not in any shape or form as pushing the road map to the side. On the contrary, I see it as a way back into the road map.

Now, I know there'll be all sorts of issues to do with the final status negotiations. And as the President said, no one is prejudging those. But, you know, let's not look this particular opportunity in the eye and then turn away. It is an opportunity for people.

And what I want to say to, not just to the Palestinians and the Israelis, but to the international community is, whatever the doubts and worries, get involved now, because there is a possibility when that disengagement happens, the Palestinian Authority have got to have the wherewithal in political, in economic, in security terms to start running the land, the territory that will be, then, under their control, and use that as the basis of getting back into a proper road map negotiation.

Because we -- this is a -- we deal with many difficult issues -- Cyprus, we discussed earlier, Northern Ireland, that I'm dealing with. The one advantage that you have in this situation -- which is as well to keep in mind, even at this difficult moment -- is that there is now an agreement that there should be two states, an Israeli and a Palestinian state, and that Palestinian state should be viable. And I can assure you, and I believe this very strongly from the conversations I've had with the President, that if the Palestinians are willing to make that effort and the international community helps in doing so, then they will find all of us, then, ready to engage and ensure that the proper discussion and settlement of these issues takes place. We will be ready to step up and do that.

Yes, Mark, sorry.

Q Mr. Sharon says this agreement by the President has ended the dreams of Palestinians. Many Palestinians seem to agree with that, as well. Why do you two not see it in that light? The Israelis see it as a victory for their side.

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: Well, I don't -- I haven't come across those particular words, and I would like to see the context of that. But I don't think that this ends anyone's dream. I think what it does is give us at least the possibility of moving it forward.

What have people been asking for years? They've been asking for the Israelis to withdraw from the occupied territories. Now, this is not the final end of it. This is not -- this is not a unilateral attempt to impose a settlement. But it does at least give the Palestinians, if they're able, then, to seize this opportunity, the ability to construct in the Gaza and those parts of the West Bank that will be under their control, with the settlements removed from there. And, remember, I can't remember exactly how many people it is, it's maybe 7,000 people that there are in the Gaza part of -- and those settlements withdrawn.

Now, forgive me, but I've been dealing with this for almost a decade. And it's been very, very difficult ever to get a situation where an Israeli Prime Minister is prepared to say, we're actually going to take these settlements away -- and make that not conditional on something that the Palestinians are doing, but say, we're just going to do that.

Now, of course, there's a whole string of things that, then, have to be decided. All these issues have to be negotiated. We have to get back into the road map and get on a proper process towards a resolution of those issues.

But if that disengagement takes place, surely the intelligent thing, not just for the Palestinians, but for the international community, is to be ready to respond. And here's where the Quartet can play a part, the other part that's in this process. The European Union, for example. We put money into reconstruction in the Palestinian Authority. I believe that there is a real possibility if we can get the right political system there, the European Union putting money in to help reconstruct the country, to help build the proper security capability.

These are -- these are things, however difficult, that offer opportunities. That's all I'm saying, and I think we should seize them.

PRESIDENT BUSH: Let me say one quick thing about this. I haven't seen the context in which he said it, either. But I can tell you what he told me. He told me he supported a Palestinian state. He thinks it's in Israel's interest that there be a Palestinian state. Obviously there's a caveat. He wants a peaceful Palestinian state. And he wants somebody who will promote peace, not violence, somebody who's willing to join with a lot of us to fight off terror.

He also recognizes that it's important that there be hope in his neighborhood. And a peaceful Palestinian state that gets help from the world is a state that can help small businesses grow, help an education system develop, help a health care system develop that provides basic services to its people. I think this is a great opportunity. And you're going to have to ask him exactly what -- whether that was in context or not.

But the impression I got, from having sat with the man right upstairs here in the White House, was he views this as a hopeful moment, as well, and made it clear that it's a part of the road map process, and knows what I know, that as we gain confidence in a Palestinian leadership and a Palestinian state that's committed itself to peace, further progress will be made -- further progress will be made on territory. And, therefore, the final status discussions -- and I repeat, which are not being prejudged by the American government, as stated clearly on Wednesday -- will be easier to deal with. And that's what's important.

We'll seize the moment, is what the Prime Minister is saying.

Let's see, April.

Q Mr. President, some of your critics are saying that it's a political ploy by you to stand firm to this June 30th deadline, especially that you don't have an Iraqi organization to transfer power over to. What do you say to that? And for -- what organization would you like to see transferred power over to, both of you, if you could answer that?

PRESIDENT BUSH: Well, I appreciate that. I guess, it's a political year, everything I'm going to say is being -- they're going to say is political. What's important is that we honor our word and honor our commitments to the Iraqi people. I suspect that if you look deep into the soul of the Iraqi people, they'd be saying, we don't know if we can trust America and Great Britain to be tough and hang in, hang in with us. And one of the things we've said is, we'll transfer sovereignty on June the 30th, and we're going to.

If they believe that we'll cut and run -- in other words, if times get tough, and we'll just say, see you later -- nobody is going to take a stand for freedom and liberty; they're afraid of getting killed or tortured or maimed. These are -- I said the other night that a year seems like a long time for Americans and people in Great Britain. But a year is not much when you're trying to shed yourself from the habits of tyranny and torture. Remember where these people came from. They came from a society where if they dared speak their mind, it's likely they'd end up in a mass grave or in a torture room. If they criticized Saddam Hussein in any way, they would be maimed or killed. And that's a hard thing to forget.

See, it's easy for us to not recognize that fear because, fortunately, our societies are such that we don't have to live with it. They did. And if they think that we will be leaving because of politics, then they won't take a risk toward freedom. We're not leaving because of politics, April. We're standing firm on our word because it's right, and it's in the long-term interests of our countries that we stand firm, because a free Iraq is an historic opportunity to change the world for the better.

There's a lot of talk about the war on terror, and can we win the war on terror. Of course we can win the war on terror in the long run. We can do a lot of things in the short-term to protect ourselves, starting with staying on the offensive. But in the long-term, it's the spread of freedom that will win the war on terror.

See, the great thing about our two countries is we believe in the power of free societies. And we don't say freedom is only -- is consigned to one group of people or one religion. We believe freedom is universal. And free societies are peaceful societies. And freedom will be the cure for those who harbor deep resentment and hatred in their heart. And I appreciate the Prime Minister understanding that vision, as well. It's a wonderful feeling to have a strong ally in believing in the power of free societies and liberty. And that's why we're going to stay the course in Iraq. And that's why when we say something in Iraq, we're going to do it, because we want there to be a free society. It's in our long-term interests. It's in the interests of our children and our grandchildren that Iraq be free.

Q Mr. Prime Minister --

Q Who is going to --

PRESIDENT BUSH: Hold on for a second. That's going to be decided by Mr. Brahimi. That's the recommendation of Brahimi. He's in the process -- you're watching a process unfold. And you won't have to ask that question on July the 1st.

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: That's absolutely right. And what will happen is there will be discussions, obviously, that Mr. Brahimi is conducting. But the idea will be to have a broad-based government, and then next year to move to a new constitution, and then, finally, to democratic elections. And that's the -- so who's going to end up governing Iraq ultimately? It's going to be the Iraqi people with a proper democratic constitution.

PRESIDENT BUSH: One final point on this -- thank you, April, for bringing it up. Transitional administrative law that had been written is a -- this is an historic document. And it's a wonderful opportunity. It is for the people of Iraq to say, here's how civilized people must live. Here's how you protect minority rights. Here's how you protect the rights of religious people. And here's how civilized people should live if they're going to provide hope for the future.

And there doesn't seem to be much focus on that, what we call the TAL these days. And yet, it is a -- it is the cornerstone for what is going to be a free and hopeful society.

Go ahead, final question.

Q If I could just ask you about Iraq again. The fact of the matter is that weapons of mass destruction have not been found, that a link between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda has not been proved; and that the year on, troop numbers are going up, not coming down. So however determined you are to make a better Iraq, isn't the awkward fact for both of you that you misled your peoples in taking troops to war and shedding blood as a result?

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: First of all, I just remind you that when, in November of 2002, we passed the United Nations resolution calling upon Saddam to comply fully with the United Nations inspectors, we did that on the basis of an understanding that wasn't confined simply to Great Britain and America, but was right across the hall of the Security Council, that Saddam Hussein was a threat -- and, indeed, it would difficult to conclude otherwise given that his was a regime that actually used chemical weapons, weapons of mass destruction against their own people.

And yes, a year on, we have faced some difficult times. We'll face difficult times again in the future. But one of the most interesting things to me is when I go and I actually talk to other leaders out in that region -- and some of them have got very difficult politics over this issue, as you all know, for very obvious reasons -- but I'm struck by how much more secure they feel with Saddam Hussein gone. And whatever their differences over the conflict, they know how important it is to their

region and their stability and, actually, their chance of changing their own country, that Iraq does become a stable and democratic state.

And this is one of these situations where -- you know, people often say to me, well is it -- is the world safer, given all the difficulty and violence that you have in Iraq? And I say to them, well, first of all, don't think that violence wasn't happening every day in Iraq under Saddam Hussein, it was. But, secondly, when you take on and you deal with these issues, yes, of course, you face difficult times. You're bound to have them. But the question is, is the aim and objective you're trying to secure one that if you do secure will make the world, indeed, safer and better. And that's why -- I find now, whatever the differences people have over the wisdom of the conflict -- and that's a debate that will go on, and go on for many, many years, no doubt; the historians can all pour over it -- but everybody should recognize the common interest today in making sure that Iraq achieves the aim that we have set out and that everybody of any sense in the international community supports, because if --

Q (Inaudible.)

PRIME MINISTER BLAIR: No, because I believe the important thing is to make the world more secure as a result of Saddam Hussein going, as a result of that threat, then, from Saddam and his regime, the threat that they carried out in their own region. I just listed for you two wars in which there were over a million casualties; hundreds of thousands of his own people killed.

Now, this is an historic struggle, and we're at a very, very crucial moment. And I think, for many, many people in Iraq, I think what the President said just a moment ago is absolutely right. Of course they're going to be sitting there asking, after all the decades of tyranny we've had, after all the promises that the international community gave us, and frankly let us down on, are these people going to stay the course?

And we are, and we want the international community to work with us in doing that. We're not setting aside the United Nations or that process at all. We're actually trying to work with the U.N. now, because everybody understands the importance of fulfilling that objective. And you just imagine an Iraq, stable and prosperous and democratic, and think of the signal that would send out. Think of the instant rebuttal of all that poisonous propaganda about America, about it all being an attack on Muslims or it being part of a war on civilization -- Iraq, run by the Iraqis, the wealth of that country owned by the Iraqis, and a symbol of hope and democracy in the Middle East.

Now, for me this is a cause that any person of good will and good heart should be able to support.

PRESIDENT BUSH: Good job, Prime Minister. Thank you, sir.

Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
DU AdBot (1000+ posts) Click to send private message to this author Click to view 
this author's profile Click to add 
this author to your buddy list Click to add 
this author to your Ignore list Fri Apr 19th 2024, 04:38 AM
Response to Original message
Advertisements [?]
 Top

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (Through 2005) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC