Mr. Posner, the anti-conspiracy author, said that if there really were something explosive involving the C.I.A. and President Kennedy, it wouldn’t be in the files — not even in the documents the C.I.A. has fought to keep secret.
“Most conspiracy theorists don’t understand this,” Mr. Posner said. “But if there really were a C.I.A. plot, no documents would exist.”
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/17/us/17inquire.html?hp If no documents existed, certainly someone would be allowed to look at what does exist and verify that no documents exist. This controversy is either silly or something is being hidden. In either case, the hiding of these documents sounds more like bureaucratic rigidity than anything else.
Many of us who were alive at the time of the assassination have an uneasy feeling that something is wrong with the story we were told about it. The rapid chain of violent, seemingly unrelated and yet very related events was just jarring.
The official explanations did not ring true. Now, that does not mean that they were lies. It means that the authorities who were issuing press releases and explanations and the historians including Posner who have written have a heavy burden of suspicion to overcome in trying to convince us that the official explanations are really true.
To this date, I do not think we have nearly all the facts about the assassination. Everything should be opened up for public scrutiny. There should be no secrets, nothing hidden.
The suspected cover-up about the assassination, whether it occurred or not, was the beginning of an age of cynicism in American. We have lost our trust in our government and in our political system. And that loss of trust has grown until today we have Glenn Beck and Jon Stewart facing off with opposing comedy shows capitalizing on our distrust. (Love Jon Stewart, don't get me wrong.)
Conspiracy theories about the assassination exist because so many people have been unable to reconcile the official story with their own life experience, knowledge of the time, sense of history and the political course that drove the U.S. off cliff after cliff following that assassination. Not just the assassination, but the handling of the investigation into it, rent our country in two. And we will not be healed and whole until we deal openly and completely with the trauma of that moment on November 22, 1963 and the subsequent investigation.
Even our children, who were not alive then, though they may not know it, will forever suffer because of the secrecy that surrounds the evidence about those events. Everything even remotely related to the Kennedy assassination needs to be made public.
On edit, I add: As every litigation attorney knows, what is not in the files may be more revealing than what is. If this man had a contact with Oswald and did not report it or did not report it accurately or fully, or if there are anachronisms in the file, then the official story about what happened becomes even more questionable. So after so many years, we should be able to review this file.