The coins in the state investment fund formerly managed by Thomas W. Noe ranged from a 1792 half-dime reportedly made from George Washington’s old silver and priced at $1.2 million to a blank penny priced at $1, records released last night show.
Noe had been fighting to keep the details about coins in the inventory secret on the ground that they constituted a "trade secret" that could cause the coins to lose value if the information became public.
But after The Dispatch and other groups sued for the records in the Ohio Supreme Court, the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation released the records from 2004 yesterday. Officials concluded that the "trade secret" argument "has been greatly diminished" by reports of missing assets and other problems.
The records show that although there were several very rare coins in the inventory, the bulk of the collection consisted of ordinary coins, according to Christopher Dunson, an Upper Arlington coin dealer who reviewed them briefly for The Dispatch. And it’s difficult to say whether the purchase prices listed for the coins were reasonable because many of the higherpriced coins — including the 1792 half-dime — are worth whatever someone will pay for them at auction, Dunson said.
http://www.columbusdispatch.com/topstory.php?story=dispatch/2005/05/28/20050528-A4-05.htmland in this article http://toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20050528/NEWS24/50528004A law enforcement source said this week’s searches at Mr. Noe’s coin shop in Monclova Township revealed records of questionable coin transactions, a law enforcement source said. One of them involved a coin purchased for more than $100,000 that was later sold for less than a dollar.
. . .
Mr. Taft denied yesterday that Mr. Noe had ever “informed me or to my knowledge, any member of my senior staff “ about his state contract with the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation.
In response to a question, Mr. Taft said he had visited Mr. Noe’s coin shop in Monclova Township, where authorities executed a search warrant Thursday. The governor said he didn’t know how many times he had visited the coin shop and when asked why he went there, Mr. Taft replied: “Just a visit.” An aide to Mr. Taft said he didn’t have any dates of when Mr. Taft dropped by Vintage Coins & Collectibles.
Asked if he and his high-ranking staff members solicited Mr. Noe to raise campaign contributions for President Bush’s re-election and the Republican Governors Association, Mr. Taft replied: “I’m sure we did.”