Reply #39: you don't seem to know much about education

[Gabi Hayes]

how do you measure the 'calibre' of teacher being laid off?

test scores, is my guess

what's the 'calibre' of teacher being hired, at cost of thousands per recruit, being used to replace many of these teachers laid off?

then there's this, from our own madfloridian, discussing the phenomenon of experienced teachers being laid off, then replaced by TFAers:

http://journals.democraticunderground.com/madfloridian/6032

Teach for America. A way to replace experienced, higher-salaried teachers?

Posted by madfloridian in General Discussion
Mon Apr 19th 2010, 07:36 PM

From the University of Oklahoma student paper, there is an interesting point of view.

Teach for America not as good an idea as some graduates believe

The article presents it from a point of view of a social consciousness.


Those who are thinking of participating in Teach for America with a social justice mission in mind should consider this. Although a far more daunting task for sure, those really interested in social justice should consider ways of solving problems like unavoidable unemployment and low-wage jobs.

On top of failing to make a dent in poverty, Teach for America actually detracts from social justice by hurting real teachers. Teach for America students take low, entrance-level pay while also receiving a government subsidy for their salary in the form of Americorps stipends. Schools lay off teachers and then hire Teach for America teachers to fill positions that real teachers would otherwise be filling. Teach for America teachers are undercutting the wage needs of real teachers and causing them to be laid off as a result.

Imagine this: a well-off college student takes a subsidized teaching position at an impossibly low wage and displaces actual teachers who might already be struggling to get by — all for social justice!

For anyone who has any concern for labor rights, this is extremely abusive. Not undercutting wage demands of often unionized workers is rule number one of how to be a serious social justice advocate

http://oudaily.com/news/2010/mar/12/column-teach-america-not-good-idea-some-graduates-/