You are viewing an obsolete version of the DU website which is no longer supported by the Administrators. Visit The New DU.
Democratic Underground Latest Greatest Lobby Journals Search Options Help Login
Google

Reply #58: The Other Vietnam Syndrome (April 2003) [View All]

Printer-friendly format Printer-friendly format
Printer-friendly format Email this thread to a friend
Printer-friendly format Bookmark this thread
This topic is archived.
Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU
ProSense Donating Member (1000+ posts) Send PM | Profile | Ignore Thu May-24-07 10:28 AM
Response to Original message
58. The Other Vietnam Syndrome (April 2003)

The Other Vietnam Syndrome

Slate, April 23, 2003

Catharin E. Dalpino, Fellow, Foreign Policy Studies

Last week the United States concluded the military phase of the war in Iraq and began discussing the creation of a new political regime and a new system. During the warjust as in every other U.S. military intervention of the past decadeWashington had to face the so-called Vietnam syndrome: the fear that conflict in a foreign country will lead to quagmire, especially in a country where the native population can use guerrilla tactics to stymie superior military technology. But there's another type of Vietnam syndrome, less well-known but just as pervasive. It derives from our relationship with South Vietnam and the political quagmire that resulted from our experience as democratic imperialists there. And if we don't address it, we may very well repeat it in Iraq.

What wrong turns did the United States take in South Vietnam?

Underestimating nationalism. The alliance between the United States and South Vietnam was uneasy and ambivalent. The failure of America's "hearts and minds" campaign in the South can be attributed as much to nationalism as to the North's resolve to expel foreigners from Vietnamese territory. Americans saw themselves as protectors; many South Vietnamese viewed them as occupiers. Early warning signs were plentiful but ignored. The majority of Saigon streets were named after Vietnamese heroes who had liberated the country from a millennium of foreign occupiers: Chinese, French, and Japanese. Washington's opposition to a reunification vote was based in part on intelligence that Ho Chi Minh would win a free election in the South because his nationalist credentials trumped reservations about ideology. A similar cognitive dissonance appears to be brewing in Iraq, evidenced by the mounting anti-American demonstrations in Mosul and other areas.

Reinforcing religious and ethnic divisions. When France gained control of Vietnam in the 19th century, French administrators put many Catholics in official government positions, replacing the traditional Vietnamese leaders who had quit their posts in protest against colonial rule. By the mid-20th century, Catholics made up 20 percent of the Vietnamese population and formed the political elite. When the United States took up the struggle against Vietnamese communism, Washington, too, showed an initial preference for the Catholic elite. Many Buddhist leaders equated the repressive South Vietnamese government with its American sponsors and were an early source of anti-Americanism.

In an eerie parallel, the percentage of Sunni Muslims to Shiites in Iraq is roughly that of the Catholic-Buddhist ratio in Vietnam in the 1950s. The United States has historically been closer to the Sunni community, and some Shiite groups have issued calls to resist any American involvement in a postwar government. Conversely, some Sunni groups fear that the U.S. will try to compensate for its past slight of the Shiites and are protesting the American presence in Iraq on the grounds that they will be disadvantaged.

In both countries, the United States also enlisted ethnic minorities as military mercenaries: Montagnards in Vietnam (as well as Hmong in Laos) and Kurds in Iraq. In Southeast Asia this patronage exacerbated ethnic tensions, which have rippled outward ever since: Twenty-eight years later, Montagnards are still fleeing the Central Highlands. The Kurds have undoubtedly improved their position with the U.S. victory in Iraq this month, re-enlisting to help maintain order in the north. However, giving Kurds a military franchise will do little to persuade the rest of the country that we have the best interests of all Iraqis at heart.

Importing political leadership. Following the 1954 Geneva Conference, which partitioned Vietnam, Washington found few political allies in Saigon. So the United States promoted Ngo Dinh Diem, an exiled Catholic politician, who returned to become South Vietnam's head of state. Virtually unknown in Vietnam, Diem had spent several years in the United States and was dubbed both the "new George Washington" and the "Churchill of Asia" by President Eisenhower. He proved to be neither. With no real constituency or grass-roots support, Diem became increasingly corrupt and oppressive while publicly shunning Western democratic mores. He was murdered in a 1963 coup that had been blessed beforehand by the United States. Forty years later, the internal debate in the Bush administration is over Ahmad Chalabi, the exiled Iraqi National Congress leader who has a strong chance to become the interim head of state in Iraq. Before returning to the country this month, Chalabi had not lived in Iraq for more than 40 years.

Creating the illusion of democracy. From the beginning, U.S. policy in South Vietnam was a conflict between realpolitik and democratic ideals. For the Johnson administration, the solution was to legitimize Washington's choice of a leader after the fact with elections. But in the "demonstration elections" of 1967, the designated favorite, Nguyen Van Thieu, won a plurality of only 35 percent. The runner-up, Truong Dinh Dan, had promised to support a cease-fire with the North. Shortly after the elections, Thieu threw him in jail, sparking anti-government demonstrations in Saigon that nearly turned into riots.

In Iraq, early indications cast some doubt on Washington's insistence that Iraqis will choose their own leaders. The 75 officials invited to attend last week's conference on a new government were handpicked by the American military, on the basis of their cooperation with the United States rather than their political relevance or resonance.

Americans make poor imperialists because we are uncomfortable in the role and seek the most expedient path out of it. With the scant 18-month time frame the administration has allowed for political reconstruction in Iraq, if that, we run a high risk of repeating past mistakes. That possibility is even greater if we attempt to direct Iraqi political development alone. For Iraq's sake, and our own, the time has come to bring in the international community.



Printer Friendly | Permalink |  | Top
 
  -History Repeating Itself: Kerry-Brokered Cambodia Tribunal Set To Begin ProSense  May-16-07 09:56 PM   #0 
  - That is an amazing amount of research  TayTay   May-16-07 10:00 PM   #1 
  - Wow, great post, it is so well researched. n/t  wisteria   May-16-07 10:24 PM   #2 
  - Kick!  ProSense   May-16-07 11:33 PM   #3 
  - Kerry will do great there. Just stay off the streets of PP until after n/t  upi402   May-16-07 11:40 PM   #4 
  - Lest we forget, Reagan/Bush/Thatcher armed and trained the Khmer Rouge  Greeby   May-17-07 12:04 AM   #5 
  - Let's hope that that will come out in the Tribunal  karynnj   May-17-07 07:01 AM   #6 
  - This is exactly why the books on BushInc's decades of crimes need to be opened.  blm   May-17-07 09:40 AM   #11 
     - But they grabbed them all and stashed them  Karenina   May-17-07 04:47 PM   #15 
  - Thankfully, there are some of us interested in preserving REAL HISTORY for future  blm   May-17-07 09:06 AM   #8 
  - Kick -this needs to be seen  karynnj   May-17-07 07:44 AM   #7 
  - Thanks! It really boggles the mind  ProSense   May-17-07 12:31 PM   #13 
     - Eerily familiar:  ProSense   May-22-07 09:58 PM   #51 
  - K&R  dicksteele   May-17-07 09:10 AM   #9 
  - K & R. This is a fantastic history lesson, Prosense.  beachmom   May-17-07 09:30 AM   #10 
  - Wait, isn't John Kerry that guy  MH1   May-17-07 11:59 AM   #12 
  - Not to mention it makes joe Klein even more of an ass for  karynnj   May-18-07 08:54 PM   #27 
     - Klein never "got' John Kerry because he's too superficial himself to 'get' honest  blm   May-27-07 11:47 AM   #66 
  - Nixon's defense secretary comments on Iraq  ProSense   May-17-07 04:09 PM   #14 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-18-07 08:08 AM   #18 
  - Excellent, ProSense!  Island Blue   May-17-07 07:28 PM   #16 
  - Thanks! n/t  ProSense   May-17-07 09:33 PM   #17 
  - Journalist killed in action  ProSense   May-18-07 08:28 AM   #19 
  - Remember Sean Flynn & Dana Stone  OzarkDem   May-24-07 08:15 AM   #56 
  - Thanks for the link! Interesting article,  ProSense   May-24-07 09:05 AM   #57 
  - Three more journalists killed in Iraq in record toll  ProSense   May-30-07 10:14 AM   #69 
  - "Triangle Of Death" Is A U.S. Nightmare  ProSense   May-18-07 04:00 PM   #20 
  - TRULY superb post! ...and I see it got picked up by Kerry's blog, too.  mloutre   May-18-07 04:12 PM   #21 
  - Yay, ProSense! n/t  Democrafty   May-18-07 04:22 PM   #23 
  - Wow! Thanks for the links and for  ProSense   May-18-07 04:55 PM   #24 
  - Yay!  karynnj   May-18-07 09:04 PM   #28 
     - Just came across this.  ProSense   May-20-07 07:51 PM   #42 
  - K&R  politicasista   May-18-07 04:18 PM   #22 
  - Is Iraq Headed for Genocide?  ProSense   May-18-07 05:41 PM   #25 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-18-07 08:44 PM   #26 
  - morning kick ... because this post deserves it ... n/t  mloutre   May-19-07 06:41 AM   #29 
  - Tragic, dangerous signs in Iraq  ProSense   May-19-07 10:51 AM   #30 
  - It Was Not An Ambush  ProSense   May-19-07 11:10 AM   #31 
  - I hope you will put this in the Research Forum  WesDem   May-19-07 11:25 AM   #32 
  - Thanks. Good idea. n/t  ProSense   May-19-07 04:14 PM   #34 
  - And this guy is getting slammed daily by a few Hillary supporters in GD:P  Forkboy   May-19-07 12:50 PM   #33 
  - It's the difference between a lawmaker who uncovered IranContra, BCCI and CIA drugrunning  blm   May-19-07 04:19 PM   #35 
  - ridiculous, huh?!!!  ray of light   Jun-04-07 10:03 AM   #76 
  - Iraq Isn't Like Vietnam -- Except When It Is  ProSense   May-19-07 10:28 PM   #36 
  - On Memorial Day, Cambodians call for swift Khmer Rouge trials  ProSense   May-20-07 10:39 AM   #38 
  - fresh kick for updated content ... n/t  mloutre   May-20-07 02:46 PM   #39 
  - Yup -- and Rolling Stone magazine had that pegged two years ago this month, too.  mloutre   May-20-07 04:49 PM   #40 
     - Thanks for the link. n/t  ProSense   May-20-07 10:33 PM   #43 
  - Excellent work, ProSense  globalvillage   May-19-07 10:33 PM   #37 
  - "Iraq Isn't Like Vietnam -- Except When It Is"  ProSense   May-20-07 06:25 PM   #41 
  - Beyond Saber Rattling  ProSense   May-21-07 08:58 AM   #44 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-21-07 08:02 PM   #46 
  - McCain's Vietnam lesson  ProSense   May-21-07 12:15 PM   #45 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-22-07 07:21 AM   #47 
  - Thinking Past Plan B in Iraq  ProSense   May-22-07 11:00 AM   #48 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-22-07 01:18 PM   #49 
  - LONG STRUGGLE AHEAD (the unbelievable)  ProSense   May-22-07 05:42 PM   #50 
  - New look at Nixon-Kissinger decisions draws parallels to today's events  ProSense   May-23-07 12:49 PM   #52 
  - Bush makes a Vietnam-Iraq comparison  ProSense   May-23-07 03:12 PM   #53 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-23-07 09:02 PM   #54 
  - Former House member says, Cut off the money to the war  ProSense   May-24-07 07:18 AM   #55 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-24-07 11:54 PM   #60 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   May-25-07 09:20 AM   #61 
  - The Other Vietnam Syndrome (April 2003)  ProSense   May-24-07 10:28 AM   #58 
  - The Iraq War Is An Absolute Replay Of Vietnam  ProSense   May-24-07 07:35 PM   #59 
  - good research1  bambino   May-25-07 09:22 AM   #62 
  - Intelligence horror stories  ProSense   May-25-07 11:43 PM   #63 
  - Kick for Patrick Lang's job interview with Doug Feith. n/t  ProSense   May-26-07 02:25 PM   #64 
  - "Kissinger's record is filled with achievement and tragedy..."  ProSense   May-27-07 11:41 AM   #65 
  - "So many died because of ego and deceit... "  ProSense   May-27-07 12:20 PM   #67 
  - Spread the Word: Iraq-Nam  ProSense   May-30-07 09:32 AM   #68 
  - Nixon Republican Wanted (Peace with Honor ad)  ProSense   May-31-07 10:47 AM   #70 
  - The lessons of Vietnam By Henry A. Kissinger  ProSense   May-31-07 07:20 PM   #71 
  - Timeline  ProSense   Jun-01-07 10:51 AM   #72 
  - "a chilling 1964 phone conversation between President Lyndon B. Johnson and one of his top aides"  ProSense   Jun-02-07 10:05 PM   #73 
  - William F. Buckley: HONOR, DUTY, COUNTRY?  ProSense   Jun-02-07 10:19 PM   #74 
  - "Do they really want to turn into Pol Pot's Cambodia?"  ProSense   Jun-04-07 10:02 AM   #75 
  - Iraq isn't Vietnam because a U.S. pullout "would embolden and empower al-Qaeda"  ProSense   Jun-05-07 06:07 PM   #77 
  - Defeats Killing Fields  ProSense   Jun-07-07 12:07 PM   #78 
  - Nixon 'wrecked early peace in Vietnam'  ProSense   Jun-07-07 06:30 PM   #79 
  - Wow, great thread, ProSense! This story so belongs here!  pink-o   Jun-07-07 07:03 PM   #80 
     - Exactly, the MSM is the biggest factor. Thanks for the insights, and  ProSense   Jun-07-07 07:18 PM   #81 
     - Except THIS time the GOP machine made sure to gain control of most newsmedia FIRST  blm   Jun-07-07 07:21 PM   #82 
  - Kick! n/t  ProSense   Jun-10-07 01:00 PM   #83 
 

Home » Discuss » Archives » General Discussion (1/22-2007 thru 12/14/2010) Donate to DU

Powered by DCForum+ Version 1.1 Copyright 1997-2002 DCScripts.com
Software has been extensively modified by the DU administrators


Important Notices: By participating on this discussion board, visitors agree to abide by the rules outlined on our Rules page. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the opinions of the individuals who post them, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.

Home  |  Discussion Forums  |  Journals |  Store  |  Donate

About DU  |  Contact Us  |  Privacy Policy

Got a message for Democratic Underground? Click here to send us a message.

© 2001 - 2011 Democratic Underground, LLC